Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe

$ • Italian, Pizza

2776 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda
(716) 446-9026


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

Lots of varieties of pizza ready for grabbing a slice or two, in addition to ordering a whole.pie. offers traditional pizza or the sweet type. Also offer pasta specials most weekdays, and has a small deli case with some fresh salads like pasta and potato, and desserts like brownies and cake slices. Nice Italian gentlemen and his family run the place, so I am glad I can patronize a small local business and get good food.

They just might have the best piece of pizza I've had in years. We all know that Buffalo-style pizza is slightly undercooked and doughy. If you get more than a few toppings, it can be very soft on the bottom, which I'd chalk up more to impatience or an inability to change the standard cook time in a pizza oven. Not the case with Molinara's, which is New York style, and therefore larger and thinner. We got a large pizza last week (16 inches versus your standard 12" large) full review

We have ordered here many times and the food was great, however tonight our cheese and pepperoni pizza was rancid. The smell was sickening. My husband called to complain. The response from the owner was “Don’t call here anymore, I have made 300 of these today.” Beware it’s not worth your health!

More Reviews(118)


Monday 11AM - 9PM
Tuesday 11AM - 9PM
Wednesday 11AM - 10PM
Thursday 11AM - 10PM
Friday 11AM - 10PM
Saturday 11AM - 10PM
Sunday 11AM - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.