5 Best Italian Restaurants near Tonawanda

JT's Pizza Pizza • $
1161 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Chicken Wings
Cheeseburger Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Pastelillos
Fried Dough

“We had JTs for the first time tonight & we were very pleased. Super nice lady took our order & said delivery within the hr. & it came just a few minutes short of an hr! Pizza was really good & the kids liked the french fries. The barbecue wings were absolutely slamming, cooked perfectly with a light char, the sauce on them was tangy & sweet & very good with the creamy blue cheese. We'll be calling again!“

4.6 Superb51 Reviews
Olisi's New York Style Pizza • $
2352 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cheddar Broccoli Pizza
Slice of Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Single Slice of Pizza
Meat Deluxe Stromboli
Pizza with Mushrooms
Stuffed Steak Pizza
Philly Steak Pizza
Slices of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“I lived downstate for 15 years and the pizza at this place definitely can go toe to toe with anything down there. Has a downstate style menu with things like stromboli, penne alla vodka and garlic knotts. Definitely recommend if you like thin crust, foldable downstate style pizza. You will be disappointed if you prefer Buffalo style pizza with thicker crust, loads of cheese and cup and char pepperoni. However this place is a must try if you like thin crust NYC pizza.“

4.4 Superb65 Reviews
Romeo & Juliet's Cafe • $$
2512 Sheridan Dr #9410, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Ravioli
Picasso Panini
Cannoli

“What a great experience. Needed cannollis and lobster tails to go for a long ride back to Maryland. The filled the cannolis as we waited. She packed them and wrapped them for travel in a cooler at her suggestion. She cared enough to ensure they stayed fresh for when we got back home. You don't find that much anymore. The deserts were incredibly tasty and properly dry thanks to the attentiveness of their staff. You can't go wrong by eating here or getting it to go. Thank you to the wonderful staff that we were lucky to meet.“

4.6 Superb26 Reviews
John's Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
1436 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

The Stinger Sandwich
Chicken Finger Sub
Chicken Sandwich
Cheese Pizza
Party Pizza

“First time in a long time. Too long. Cup and char was great. Maybe :30 too long. Soft bite no tear which I really enjoy. Great taste sauce cheese. I very much enjoyed this pizza. Also treated us to 20 wings medium. Also very good. Crispy saucy. Large cheese pepperoni 20 wings $41 with a coupon. Definitely won’t be waiting so long to order again. Thank you“

4.2 Good39 Reviews
A Touch of Italy Italian • $
630 Delaware St, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Platter Trio Lasagna Stuffed Shells and Chicken Parmigiana
Small Cheese Pepperoni and Green Pepper Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Eggplant Parmigiana
Spaghetti Parmesan
Fettuccine Alfredo
Margarita Chicken
Chicken Marsala
Baked Spaghetti
Chicken Alfredo

“We ordered out and they have outstanding food.My only issue was... that mushrooms were asked for on a steak sub. The response was we cant do mushrooms.There are mushrooms for pizzas, mushrooms for tortellini alfredo, and chicken marsala, yet no mushrooms for a steak sub?!Again great food but that is very confusing!“

4 Good95 Reviews
Loading...
map Map