New American Restaurants near Youngstown, NY

“Stopped in for lunch while visiting the area. Very friendly staff, welcomed us right away. Food was fantastic! I had the stack burger with mac & cheese and my wife had the pulled pork sandwich with fries. Being from Kansas City, I get nervous ordering BBQ anywhere else, but Somewhere's pulled pork was VERY good. Stack burger seasoned perfect and dripping with cheese. Didn't need and condiments at all. Definitely stop in!“

“My family has been here several times over the past few years. The food is always fresh and homemade and outstanding. They have things on their menu that you don’t see anywhere else, such as these incredible crispy roasted maple brussel sprouts with smoke dust. Also there pasta is made in house and is right proper pasta. Haven’t had a single issue with anything here. We will continue to regular this place as it always leaves us satisfied!“

“Our server and all front of the house staff were excellent. The food was absolutely delicious. Adelectable amuse-bouche, followed by a wonderful choice of starters and main course. The short rib melted in your mouth. The desserts were perfect. I would highly recommend Benchmark.“

“We went here for dinner one night, and liked it so much we came back for lunch the next day! The service is great, our waitress (got lucky and had her both times) was so sweet and she gave absolutely killer recommendations. Everything we ordered was incredible, drinks and food. I'm gluten free, but intolerant not allergic. They have a great selection of fully GF options (no cross contamination/shared fryer), but also have a bunch of stuff that is technically GF if cross contamination isn't an issue for you, the staff was really knowledgeable about the menu and allergens and was able to answer all my questions. So if you can handle cross contamination/shared fryers, ask them what dishes would be okay for you!We tried:The Game Burger: it was Lamb when we went, we both got it and absolutely loved it.The Bacon Jam Burger: my boyfriend absolutely loved thisThe pot roast sandwich: super tender meat, delishThe calamari: this is so good, I can't describe it. Super buttery, and served with a little bit of spicy peppers. It is divine.The sweet potato fries: crispy and delish, and the honey butter is next levelThe Chocolate Oblivion: it's their only gluten free dessert, but it is so good. I was nervous when they described it was a "dense" flour free torte, but it has an amazing smooth texture almost like a mousse and a cheesecake had a baby. It is rich and decadent, we split it and CRUSHED it. ?Drinks:My bf enjoyed a few beers, and their beer list is HUGE. great selection.Bourbon maple smash: strong, but super tasty. Not very sweet, but I prefer thatVanilla Chai White Russian: this was my favorite, not super sweet but absolutely incredible. It's very well balanced, and just so freaking good.Cranberry Gin Fizz: Made with my favorite gin (the botanist) and it is SO tasty, perfectly sweet and tart and just a refreshing easy sipper.Just go here, it'll be worth it!Dietary restrictions: So many allergen and dietary preference options, and the staff knows their stuff on all of the above! You can probably be accommodated here, and won't have to guess if your dietary restrictions are understood or if what you're eating is okay for you.“

“Terrible service, food ok, we had omelets, home fries, toast. Toast was just warm bread, not toasted, homefries hardscrapies from bottom of pan. Restaurant didn't smell good old and musty. Needs a good cleaning and new rugs. Not going back anytime soon.“