41 Best Italian Restaurants in Cincinnati

“The food is amazing, they have a large wine and spirt offering. The staff are always courteous, knowledgeable and very accommodating. Casual dining with an upscale feel.“

“We travel all around the world, even compared to Italy, their home made pasta was the best we have ever eaten. We had appetizers that were awesome as well. We Highly recommend this place!“

“Sotto embodies the feeling of understated luxury. From the wood-fired oven to the homemade pasta, the chef's dedication to every dish is evident. I particularly enjoyed their Italian meatballs and roasted eggplant appetizers, which paired perfectly with a glass of red wine. This place isn't just about dining; it's about enjoying a mini culinary journey. If you're in Cincinnati, be sure to make reservations in advance; otherwise, it's very difficult to get a table.“

“This was our first time and such a wonderful experience. The food was delicious. The chicken scallopine was the best I have had. Everything from appetizer, through dessert and lattes was wonderful. Very friendly family run business. Highly recommend.“

“As an Italian, I’m really happy and proud that Italian cuisine is well represented by Nicola’s. I went there with my lady to celebrate Saint Valentines in advance, and we were so happy to spend our time there. The place is wonderful, the service is perfect and the food… the food is astronomical! Personally I do love the Malfatti “A true love for Rome”. As being born and raised in Rome I do really appreciate that love for my city. Definitely a 10/10, and best place to experience Italian cuisine. P.S. Italiani, se siete di passaggio a Cincinnati fate un salto da Nicola, non ve ne pentirete“

“As I’m writing this review I’m still in shock! I’m in Cincinnati on business and I was craving Italian. I can’t believe there’s not a line around the block just for the meatballs! My family owned an Italian seafood restaurant in NJ for 26 years and I can say without hesitation the meatballs here are the best west of Arthur Ave in the Bronx! My NJ mind is blown!“

“Been a fan for years, this one by far best experience and customer service I’ve had. Bring on to nashville, I’ll invest.“

“We went here because was close to the hospital. Used to go to olive garden. Never again. Carrabbas is top notch from top down!“

“Absolutely delightful. Superbly delicious Italian cuisine, served by a friendly and attentive staff.“

“Food is so good! Tried the new avocado chop salad today and it's my new fave!“

“Amazing food. Wonderful views. The ambiance and service was 10/10. 💜💜💜“

“Gina was absolutely the best and celebrated our anniversary with us. She made sure everything was perfect and went above and beyond. To top it off the crew signed an anniversary card for us, complete with our other new friend Ryan, who was also a delight. Everyone we interacted with at Subito was fantastic and we will be back for many more celebrations! Not to mention the food is incredible!“

“It was our first time there and they had amazing food, great staff!!! We will definitely come back Again and would highly recommend them!!!“

“We recently attended a private "pop up" dinner here. The home made pasta dishes were absolutely delicious and the best pasta that I have experienced outside of Italy. All meal courses were wonderful and unique. The chef has a true gift. The service was friendly and efficient. We will definitely return!“

“We had a lovely time at this gorgeous restaurant. You can sit up front by the bar area and windows or back by the bustling kitchen. Delicious food and exceptional service. It was quite busy and loud when we were there and you needed a reservation.“

“A hidden Gem in Wyoming, Ohio.
The staff was exceptional! We had their meatball appetizer and supreme pizza. Both were AMAZING! Owner came over and introduced himself which shows the customer service is alive and well here!! We will be back!!“

“Our server was fantastic... and thr food was phenominal... i am not a fan of spinich and artichoke dip but theirs is fire!!!

Kid-friendliness: I saw a kid there so i guess

Wheelchair accessibility: They have handicap parking and a ramp“

“Great food, great atmosphere loved our dinner there“

“My go to spot for all my fresh pasta and sauces. Love this place!!!“

“There for a special Birthday Lunch. We were very fortunate to be seated with Shayla. I hope i spelled it right. She was very attentive, warm and welcoming. She offered a lot of knowledge of the menu, and was very informative. Great Service we we won't forget.“

“I love Scotti's we have been going there for over 45 years. We have never had a bad meal. The food is great and so are the are the owners.i give Scotti's a 5“

“Been a fan for years, this one by far best experience and customer service I’ve had. Bring on to nashville, I’ll invest.“

“Truly an outstanding meal.
- Goat cheese and honey to start, was tasty
- braised short rib was outstanding and the potatoes that came with, tasty!
- spinach infused lasagna is worth the travel, not to heavy at all
- the wine was paired perfectly
- the Tiramasu was something, no words can describe. I've never had better.
- Hurradura Anejo tequila Old Fashioned is meant to be enjoyed, well worth it.
- Vanessa our server was knowledgeable, entertaining, and honest

One hell of a meal!

(Reservations though, I would highly recommend)“

“Amazing food, huge portions at a reasonable price. Perfect for “pre gaming” before a show at Bogarts.“

“Quite possibly the best meal we’ve ever had!“

“We have always enjoyed the pizza, and especially the family atmosphere.“

“So happy OG delivers. Abby is so helpful & I placed an order & called back to add extra sauce . Told her I would b happy to pay extra & she did not charge me . The food portions are huge like when dining inside . Free delivery too! I highly recommend. They pack utensils & extra napkins without asking .“

“Family of 6 seated pretty quickly even though there was a waiting line when we got there on a Wednesday. Very good server, Matthew, was helpful and friendly. It did take a while between being seated to ordering drinks, then getting drinks and ordering food. Appetizer...fried ravioli, came out fairly quick. Salad and breadsticks took forever to come to the table. Didn't see our server to ask about it, but it finally was brought to the table. Entrees came not too long after that. Two Eggplant parm, spaghetti with sausage, chicken marsala, chicken alfredo and spaghetti with meatballs. All very good and hot when it came out. After that long wait for our salad, everything turned out ok even though we were there for a bit longer than we wanted to be. (two little kids with us)“

“If you’re looking for amazing Italian food, please check out this restaurant. Some of the best Stromboli and calzones I’ve ever had with great service and absolutely deliciously homemade sauces. Ask them to whip up a batch of pink sauce for you. You won’t regret it.“

“We went for my birthday to check out the place. Good food and top notch service.“

“I have been here several times and it has always been a great experience.This place never disappoints.Wonderful food,top notch service and a great relaxing atmosphere.Amazing view of the city.“

“Y’all, Francesca is the best. These are the best croissants I have had in Cincy, and some of the best coffee. I came in to pick up a birthday cake and Francesca spoke with me in Italian and was so, so kind and generous. Definitely go see this place.“

“Absolutely fabulous experience! Amazing food, drinks, and fun vibes. The roasted eggplant is to die for, and the Sauvignon Blanc blend was fantastic. Great time with friends and wonderful staff made it even better!“

“Son un verdadero Gelato italiano, frescos y de calidad. Y lo mejor es la atención, te sientes como en casa.“

“THIS is for the College Hill location... that Big Gripp is absolute ⛽ 🔥 👀 🤤“

“First time here tonight and the service was amazing and quick we were worried coming in about 7:50 since they closed at 9 and we didn’t feel rushed at all.. Food was absolutely delicious we ordered a pizza and hoagie with some cheese sticks, and that dessert especially the peanut butter pie was absolutely amazing I ask the girl at the register who makes it and Nicole idk if you will see this but you know what your doing with that peanut butter pie, it was absolutely the most delicious peanut butter pie I ever had.. it took a lot of self control to not buy every last piece that was left..“

“By Far….this is the best pizza I have had in along time. Been ordering from them for a few months now. Never been disappointed. Customer service was incredible when a mistake occurred with our order! Wonderful customer service.“

“Had a quick bite to eat before the Toto, Men at Work & Christopher Cross concert last Sunday. We were in a hurry but not too much.
We all ordered drinks and a large Detroit style pepperoni pizza with hot honey and it was GREAT! Nina our server was very helpful, fun, friendly chatting with us for awhile- she even went out of her way to help us find some black napkins to play a game while we waited for our pizza… My Miller bottle was also almost ice cold- great! We got our check right away, we devoured the pizza- I highly recommend this pizza and this location was on top of things…lots of happy patrons and tables of mixture of group sizes, etc.. all were having a nice time.
Thank you! And the pizza hit the spot for the concert- just wish that I had another one waiting for me in the car after the concert👍“

“I'm not a big fan of cheese nor of pizza .... with that being said... I am now a new favorite customer of this location. The gentleman working tonight did such an amazing job making our food being polite taking good care of this store.. thank you jets pizza“

“Great pizza! Everytime we're in town we order from the one on Sutton. Never disappointed. Very friendly and accommodating.“

“This was my first time at this Penn Station location, and as always, I’ve loved their subs—this location didn’t disappoint! I got the monthly special, the Reuben, along with fries and a drink. I chose the lemonade, though I think the special is supposed to be for fountain drinks only, but I appreciated the free upgrade! :-)

The service was great; the employees were friendly, had happy expressions, and were willing to help when needed. I visited on a Thursday early afternoon and was impressed with the service I received. The location is very convenient, close to dealerships, so I stopped by after my car maintenance.

I’ll definitely be back when I’m in the area!“