44 Best American Restaurants near Fairport Harbor

“Excellent experience all around! The all-you-can-eat fish fry special is tasty and great value, and the homemade corned beef hash is delicious. Can't wait to try the perch next time. Despite being a busy Good Friday dinner service and being seated in a corner of the sun porch, we received timely, attentive, and friendly service. Highly recommended.“

“Seated promptly at the designated reservation time; A bit loud could use some deadening material installed. Service was very attentive. The best dish was the Shishito peppers, followed by the scallops.Not recommended is the grilled octopus. It had some type of slippery coating on it. 3 to 4 dishes would be enough for two people. Overall experience was very satisfactory.And will return to eat the duck and meat dishes“

“I stopped by JT's this morning for some breakfast. I was seated right away and poured a cup of coffee before I could ask for it. The staff is friendly and what you would expect from a busy restaurant. I ordered the sausage gravy and biscuits with a side of scrambled eggs. My food came out really quick. Everything was freshly prepared and nice and hot. The sausage gravy was good, but not as comparable as to the good stuff you get down south where I grew up . The restaurant was decorated nicely not that's really important to me. This is a great family run restaurant and I highly recommend that you stop by and enjoy a leisurely breakfast.“

“This restaurant has become a favorite of ours, and we've happily suggested it to friends seeking an exceptional fine dining experience. The menu boasts fresh and intriguing options, all of which are simply delightful! The ambiance exudes intimacy and charm, creating a perfect setting for a romantic dinner or a special celebration. What's more, the chef takes the time to personally greet guests at their tables and welcomes feedback, adding a personalized touch to the dining experience. For those seeking a memorable culinary adventure, Bistro 70 is sure to exceed expectations!“

“I have been wanting to try this restaurant and finally got a chance. Having been to most restaurants in the area, this food was amazing!!! Respect going to the kitchen, my goodness! We had the coconut shrimp appetizer and the lobster pizza as an app. Both were delicious. I didnt think I was going to enjoy the lobster pizza, but if we weren't sharing, I would've eaten it all. Prefect consistency and it didnt taste artificial. I worry about taste with seafood, especially crab and lobster, where they can ruin a flavor when artificial is used. The pizza was thin and perfect crisp. We also ordered the blackened shrimp entree and the wild mushroom chicken entree. I can't say enough great things. I'm not into spicy and the blackened shrimp had the slightest heat, it was pleasant and complemented the dish perfectly. Great beer choices as well as crafted cocktails and they had Friday night Lent food options. The music was flowing and the service was present. Anytime we needed something, there was no struggle to get our server. It got pretty jamming in there by 6/630pm. We are definitely going back. Do not let the location fool you and underwhelming outside view. It's beautiful inside and I've heard...it has a nice patio which im looking forward to seeing and experiencing. Thank you for a fantastic experience and thank you to the positive reviews that led us here.Parking: The restaurant is located in a plaza so there is plenty of parking even when all the businesses are busy. You might just have to walk like 10secs longer“

“Kailey was a breath of fresh air in the after math of 1 of the worst two (2) week periods my significant other have every had. With that, we decided & prayed to have a good evening wherever we go. God led us to Smokey Bones & it’s clear the reason was because we needed her + her energy! She accepted us with open arms, a warm personal, and a sense of connection to us that we never experienced with a server as a couple. All the stresses & worriers of the world went away during our time with Kailey! Thank God for her & the fact that your organization hired her. Please share the we will be forever grateful our time with & the opportunity for our fresh start to be reignited from her being simply awesome. We will be back to visit her & the rest of your wonderful team at the Mentor Smokey Bones!“

“Went here for the first time last week and was pleasantly surprised with the experience. Service was great, the food was really good, and reasonably priced as well. I got the Buffalo chicken pizza and it is probably the best one I have had yet. Highly recommend and would go here again.“

“This place is a gem! Fantastic food that won't empty your bank account. The best part is, even when you order to go, the food is still equally as delicious as eating in! You can't go wrong and I've turned so many people onto this place since I've fell in love with it. Although I may get f.a.t.s from it.. lol.“

“A very vast selection to choose from drink and food wise. Great prices, awesome food. The place was absolutely packed wall to wall and service wasn't lacking. Our table had the Mardi Gras omelette, Chicken and Waffles and the Crab Cake Eggs Benedict. No complaints, super tasty! Definitely my new favorite brunch spot! For the people who complain about waiting, you can simply join the wait-list online. It takes 10 seconds to fill out and submit. We had zero wait upon arrival because we utilized the wait-list.“

“Been here a handful of times over the past year. Mainly for their golf simulator. They have 2 bays. Super spacious there with a couple TVs. The cost of the simulator was only $20/hr on a Wednesday afternoon, took my 4 year old! It was great time to spend with her and hang for a bit. Played here with buddies in the past too, and just on my own dialing in my clubs. Never crowded during the week. And again, the cost of a bay during the week is about $25! CANNOT beat that!The bar itself is rather huge. LOTS of TVs, sportsbook, etc. Solid draught lineup always. Their bartenders and staff might be some of the nicest people. Always enjoyable convo and just super pleasant folks.I have ate here a few times and its pretty standard bar food. Nothing fancy, but a solid meal nevertheless!If you are thinking of going here...do it! You wont be disappointed. Book a bay online before you go and hit some balls while you drink and eat!Kid-friendliness: They threw on some cartoons for my 4 year old while he hit some golf balls. Didn't even ask! Solid stuff.“

“My husband and I went for an early dinner a little after 4pm for the first time In awhile. As soon as we wakes in the door (we came through the back) all of the kitchen staff greeted us so warmly it was so sweet. You could tell everyone was happy to be there. We sat down and since I'm pregnant I can't enjoy a nice wine however our waiter suggested they could make a raspberry lemon drop mocktail ! This was fantastic. It made me feel special and happy since I can't get what normally would've got. We had the bread and oil as an appetizer, this was delicious. We had a second helping of bread with it. My husband got the chicken pot pie and he really enjoyed it ! I ordered the pork chop with whipped sweet potatoes and Brussels sprouts. Let me say this was absolutely phenomenal. It was cooked to perfection, seasoned perfectly .. and the pairings with the sides were absolutely out of this world amazing. We had such a great night. The price points for the quality of the meals the chefs put together was of a 5 star restaurant. I really wish I had taken a picture because the plating was also very nice but I didn't get one because I was too excited to eat. We go so many places locally and this establishment needs to be commended. Absolutely blew us out of the water in every way. Thank you for such a wonderful dinner.“

“Immediately greeted by our wonderful server, who offered our choice of table or booth. We started with the bacon wrapped brisket, which was very good. Their sauce is awesome. We had soft drinks that never went before half before being refilled, and she kept coming back to check on us. Portions were large. We had the 3 choice combos and HUGE account of fries. The cornbread was more like a leaf and tasted great. Good BBQ, nice atmosphere, and great service. WE'LL BE BACK!“

“Very good food, locally owned. Owned. Not a chain. Pleasant atmosphere. In a quaint downtown area.Parking: There's some on street parking but most of the parking is behind the shopping center and also across the street of the behind the shopping center lot“

“Came here for a new breakfast experience in Lake County - Thank you Yelpers! We were seated quickly and our server Brittany was awesome. We ordered coffee and she offered if we had any questions on the menu. I ordered the Fried green tomato Eggs Benedict special (if you've seen any of my posts - you know from my trips to South Carolina - I love Fried green tomatoes when done well !) These were definitely done well !! Crunchy and a very pleasant bite for an eggs Benedict. My mother in law had a traditional eggs Benedict with fruit. The fruit was bright and fresh ! My husband had the country omelette We all enjoyed it very much. The inside was decorated ! Ohio Pride throughout. They have a nice outside patio that I'm sure will be great in warmer days ! The coffee was a bit pricey at 3.49 a cup. I would deduct a half star for that. For three people a bill over 50 seems high for a cafe breakfast. Regardless, it was a nice meal with great service ! Will definitely be back for an outside patio breakfast experience. Recommend others give this place a try !!“

“We loved this small, dimly-lite restaurant and cocktail bar.Vegetarian options: This is a steak and seafood restaurant with a limited variety of vegetarian side dishes, but those vegetable sides were delicious. Our carnivore friends were equally impressed with our generous and tasty vegetarian sides.“

“This food is delicious! I hear tell from Mother Darling that the community has ranked their hamburger sandwiches very high compared to the competition; second place, I'm told. I will need to try one!Also, that barkeep named Larry is very lively! Mother Darling and I always enjoy his company.“

“We were hungry and had been traveling all day. We almost didn't go in because it was 7:30pm and the diner was too close at 8pm. We are so grateful we decided to chance it... Wonderful staff and the food was spot on! We didn't feel like we were a burden at all! 5 ✨ stars! We definitely will visit again in the future.“

“Absolutely the best dining experience we've had in awhile Chrissy and I....The Chicken Parmesan was so delicious... Our waiter Tim was amazing rarely find a waiter like him Thank you Tim?...This was the Mentor location... We can't wait to go back again to try the steaks.“

“We were tired and hungry when we stopped in at the end of the breakfast hour, but we were welcomed and served a great fresh meal with perfect eggs (I'm picky) and the best bacon we've ever had (my fiancé grew up on a farm where his family raised hogs, and he was so impressed, he had to find out where the restaurant purchased its bacon). We received fantastic service and enjoyed the pleasant atmosphere of this neighborhood place that we stumbled upon in our travels. We only wish we had a Yours Truly in our hometown.“

“I went for the first time this morning after getting off work. I had a huge breakfast that was absolutely delicious! The portions were large and the coffee was perfect. The waitress was very friendly and efficient. I told my husband about it and we agreed we will go back soon.“

“A hidden gem in downtown Painesville. The food is always delicious and fresh. The lobster bisque soup is one the very best we've ever had! It's cozy in the winter and chill in the summer sitting outside on the patio. Always a great choice!“

“I had looked up this place because I wanted to go somewhere nice, and I can say that it was great. There was live trivia going on which was pretty cool and we thought that the pizza sizes were going to be small, but to our surprise, they were actually pretty big. So, we were able to take some home. Our waiter, I think his name was Pat, was absolutely great. 10 out of 10, would recommend.“

“Stong enough for a meat eater. PH balanced for a vegetarian. Everything is great here from the seating, drinks, food, and staff. This is a shining example of balance between pro and anti meat eaters should expect.Vegetarian options: Great options. Don't hesitate to go here.“

“First and foremost, I wish I had gotten a picture of the hot dogs because they looked awesome! Second, the gentleman was fantastic. I couldn't decide between the Hawaiin Dog or the Breakfast Dog, and I didn't feel rushed. I know it's Mentor Mall, but the atmosphere this section gives off feels great. They offer free refills, no matter which soft drink you get. These aren't just "hot dogs," these are soooo worth the money!!! The wait wasn't long for the food either, maybe 5 minutes tops. I'm definitely going back.“

“We ordered a cevapi plate and it was ready in about 15 mins and was absolutely delicious! The owner made us our food and was very nice and helpful. The amount of food you get for how much it costs was pleasantly surprising. Everything tasted fresh!“

“Our first time here, we weren't sure what to expect. Local bar atmosphere but everyone was so friendly, even the other patrons. My Porch burger was excellent and prices very reasonable. Bonus, they are dog friendly! We'll be back.“

“Today was my first time trying Scooters after hearing from my coworker at The Genesis Center talk about how good the food was. I’m rating a four because I step outside to take a confidential phone call and heard my name being called for my order from an employee and I was told that I must stay and wait inside for my order. Quite embarrassing walking in to receive my order. The food is as good as my coworkers told me.“

“Delicious food in a nice, modern feeling restaurant. I loved all the food I ate from the zucchini bisque, to the crab cakes to the salmon. Service was friendly and attentive. I believe there is some outdoor seating in addition to the large indoor area. Would definitely go back “

“Awesome. Servers ran around like chickens with their heads removed. They were friendly and delivered crab after crab. This is the real deal, the crab was fresh not over cooked and delicious, the redskin potatoes were the bomb. I can't wait to go back and feel guilty telling others about this secret¡“

“Definitely a fun place to watch sports with a lot of TVs! Consistent food with many choices. Overstuffed sandwiches have been my favorite since the 90's! Great outdoor patio! Only reason I didn't give a 5 star, is the newer staff could be a little more friendly! Old staff they had for several years was the best! Unfortunately Covid caused that with most of the food establishments. Still a great place to frequent!“

“Lunch with the wife. She had chicken marsala and I had a Chicken Ceasar Salad. She said the Marsala was good and the portion was large. My Salad was excellent and also a huge portion. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. Red Hawk never disappoints! And it is nearly time of the year for lunch on the patio.“

“Ist visit. Service was good and pork cutlet was delicious. Evening was spoiled by the obnoxious women at the bar with her consistent very loud outbursts. Many customers were very annoyed. Staff should have spoken to her. Will think twice before returning.“

“Visiting from SC. Stopped after a long drive. I had the French onion soup and cheesy garlic bread. Both were good. My husband had the Chicken sandwich. He was not a fan. It was just an ok sandwich. Chicken did Not have any flavor. Slaw was okay.Wait staff was friendly. Fast service. Atmosphere was food. I thought it was a little pricey.“

“Good small town diner. Good food. Coleslaw is the best I've ever had! The downside is the waitresses are extremely loud, they will talk loudly to each other across the diner or to kitchen staff so everyone in the diner can hear their conversation.“

“They have a karaoke night on Fridays. It can be pretty fun. Starts at 10pm but the kitchen closes at 10pm. Go early, get some food and drinks, stay for the karaoke fun.There's a massive big shot burger challenge and if you can polish off the huuuuge burger and a side of fries in under 30 min it's free!“

“It’s Waffle House. If you come here with high hopes you are coming for the wrong reason! The food here has always been good for the price. They have a simple menu to choose from so you can enjoy fast food. It’s a bit dirty but not where you eat. The ladies behind the counter are awesome and fast. Would definitely return again.“

“So I did have a negative review up at first but I decided to take it down as they contacted me to make it right. And boy did they ever. They are remaking my order and I am just so happy to get to try the food for the first time again.! The owner is super super kind. And I will update this review after i go in to try once again. But she really does seem to pride herself in her business and seems to genuinely care about her customers.! 5 stars after my conversation with her. Kelsey you rock.! Thank you so much for offering to make this right❤️❤️“

“It's a family breakfast hub for us. Breakfast is decent. Service can be hit and miss (depends on how busy they are) but they are friendly and try to be accommodating. Like all places these days, they are understaffed a lot of the time, so a little patience and kindness goes along way.Parking: During busy times, parking lot can be packed.Kid-friendliness: Kid Menus, high chairs/boosters, offer coloring/crayons.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, one floor building. Restrooms might be tight.“

“Overall a good experience, slight hiccup with my order but it was quickly resolved which I appreciated. Food was decent and pricing was fair. Also our waitress was great. My only issue was how loud the music was when we got there. I know this is making me sound super old but the music was way too loud, and inappropriate for families. I just wanted to enjoy a meal with my wife, not go to a night club.“

“Came here to have a meal with family. We got right in without reservations at 430p on a Saturday. It was very busy. I got a panini double cheeseburger (with tater sauce and shredded lettuce) and a salad. Good choice. We had the nachos appetizer which was perfect. Everyone loved their dinner and we all had to take to go boxes. The fresh cut fries here are great.Kid-friendliness: We had a booth which worked great for the kids. Plenty to keep them preoccupied.“

“Drinks are good, food is decent, the bartender is really nice. Local watering hole worth checking out. Karaoke Thursday night, Trivia Wed, queen of hearts, happy hour till 7. Its hidden in the end of the plaza across from the library, they have a nice patio out back.“

“My husband and I stopped here around noon on a Tuesday and there was no wait for a table. We had never been, and wanted to try it. Our server was friendly, but must have had a large section because it took her a while to get to us to take our orders. I got the salad bar and the battered fish dinner. It was just okay. The fish is like frozen fillets that were fried, and were greasy with some parts that had a weird texture. The French fries were standard, the green beans were literally canned green beans microwaved and put in a bowl (no butter, no salt or seasoning), and the salad bar was sub par. They have a very basic selection, and the soups were nothing fancy. I do not recommend getting the salad bar only for your meal, it's not very substantial. My husband got the breakfast, biscuits and gravy, eggs, sausage patties, home fries. He said it was good, but the server forgot to bring him his sausage patty and instead he got extra gravy. We asked her for the patty and instead she came back with the roll I was supposed to get with my dinner. She did finally bring the sausage but my husband was waiting for 5-10 minutes to eat the rest of his breakfast. I felt like tables around us got more attention, and it wasn't like there was a wait for tables. There were empty ones around us. I would try it again, but would get something different, maybe breakfast. It's not anything to scream about, but is an option for breakfast, lunch, or dinner!“

“We had a party of 4 for the Easter buffet. Everything was tasty & hot! Service was very attentive. IMO, the only draw back was that it started @ 10, & they were not ready.. easy fix! For the price, it was a great variety. Will definitely be back if they have it again.“

“Alas, another empty pizza box. What do you think that means?Such a gooooood pizza (I went Andy Griffith there on ya).Tremendous service, cold beer, really good food.If you’re reading this the ? Parm sandwich is also out of this world. Especially during the Monday Lunch Special.Nothing but Goodness ?….“