19 Best Italian Restaurants near Fairport Harbor

“First time ever trying Rego's... I got the Lola bread and definitely will not be getting it again. Pizza was good but definitely not the best I've had. :-/ Was kind of disappointed especially for the price. But staff was excellent so I guess that makes up for it - lol.“

“We came to visit historical sites in Ohio and wanted to eat Excellent food. Nonna T’s restaurant was perfect! Not only is the food amazing but the service was top class! Thank you for the friendliness“

“I am shocked I've been getting pizza from this place for since they came to Chesterland and then they moved to an x Pizza Hut building good pizza friendly people BUT today I order online it's a pickup I go there to pick up the pizza person bring some pizza to the takeout window it's the wrong Pizza I said told him then he says well no your wife called and ordered the salad it says I don't have a wife I'm not married then he starts getting irate with me and he starts calling me names and he tells me that I was not to swear I didn't swear at all with this guy I thak that back once he started calling me names that's when I got irate took my money back took and I will never ever go back to bada bing in Chesterland again“

“I just had the most amazing hot sub with Turkey & Ham. The family that owns Maxim’s is friendly and give great service.“

“Always amazing food and service. It was so busy tonight, but everything runs so smoothly. Even Frank, our chef, came out to check on us. Always great service from Dominic, Ava and Toni!! Can’t wait to go back. The pork chop is the best!!!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian options are available“

“Huge portions, great-tasting food, and a family-run business.“

“This place was absolutely wonderful. We had tried two other places previously, and couldn't get a table. The owner was so kind and caring, taking the time to make recommendations about the rest of our stay, and the food was simply amazing. It felt like we were family even though we had just met. I don't often leave reviews, its rare anymore that a place leaves that big of an impression. This one definitely did. If you are in the area, you would be cheating yourself to not visit.“

“Everything!! Amazing quality“

“went for lunch this past Wednesday. Service was super. I had the chicken Alfredo and it was delicious. I will definitely go back.“

“fast service,,,great food“

“Delicious spot in Downtown Willoughby! You cannot go wrong with anything on the menu. Their bread is so soft and delicious we always finish it within minutes of sitting down. Tonight we ordered my favorite appetizer the Fried Ravioli which is always a hit. My husband had the Italian Sausage Sub for his entree which came with crispy fries. I ordered the Spaghetti Geraci Sauce which came with a house salad. The house Italian dressing is great but you must try the creamy Italian dressing! The pasta was perfectly cooked and the sauce was amazing as usual! Come check this place out!!!“

“Our first time trying & we ordered take out, everything was amazing!! We ordered a lot to try a bit of everything and I highly recommend the inferno Alfredo pasta, firecracker shrimp, and Ebony & Ivory for dessert. We’re excited to dine in next time.“

“All meals were good go our party of 4. I had the Veal Parmigian, it was excellent. I had it along with the spaghetti the next day and it was just as good reheated. That's a mark of excellent food.“

“Alas, another empty pizza box. What do you think that means?Such a gooooood pizza (I went Andy Griffith there on ya).Tremendous service, cold beer, really good food.If you’re reading this the ? Parm sandwich is also out of this world. Especially during the Monday Lunch Special.Nothing but Goodness ?….“

“Love it there. Outside bar is the best“

“Went back after a bad experience and the owner making a point to make it right with us and I’m glad I did the gift card that was given was a little tricky for us and the employee to figure out but she did an amazing job making sure that she got it to work and she was very friendly and caring in the whole interaction we got a large pepperoni and eating it as I write this review I can confidently say that I will be back thank you for making it right with us you definitely earned some new customers!“

“Place is a bit small, so I wouldn't recommend bringing a party of more than five people. They accommodated my party of seven as best they could, but the space just isn't there--not that I'm gonna penalize them for that, though. Food was wonderful, cocktails were strong like I like them to be, and the lobster tail was the best I've ever had in my life. That missing star, then? Well, we were kinda left hanging till all of our party of seven showed up--I introduced us as a party of seven when it was still just myself and my wife, and we were left standing and wondering if we'd been forgotten about even when we were at five people total, still waiting on 2. Just saying "We're getting your table ready and we'll seat you once you're all here." would have been just fine. But particularly when you're seating parties of three or four that came in _after_ us....some assurance that we're not being ignored would have been nice.“

“Best pizza in town. Excellent service. Very friendly staff.“

“I kept my daughter's 26th birthday here and the service was excellent! The food was great and the staff were very helpful. I couldn't ask for better service from my server. She was phenomenal! The staff brought out the cake and sang happy birthday to my daughter and made her evening very special. Thank you guys!“