“Subs and Salads rock! I don't get pizza very often, but I'm always stopping in for a crispy chicken salad.Update: 4 years later, and still regularly here. It's been good!This place is always so clean. I don't question that the owners take pride in their restaurant.“
“My favorite place to get pizza wings and salad from…since I found this place I honestly will not even eat pizza anywhere else anymore let alone wings. They use a generous amount of sauce on the wings yet they are still crispy not to mention how delicious the pizza is every single time and to top it off their chicken Cesar salad is soooooo good literally mind blown by how delicious this place is. Usually a pizza place is only good at one thing or not good at all this place is good at making many different things. I love this place“
“Wow! Really good.They scratch make their own crust and they know what their doing. Perfect combination of crispy and doughy. Great sauce ,generous cheese and meat.Owned by a nice friendly gentleman . Don't deny yourself this westside gem.“
“Went to Natalie's for the first time last night. I truly enjoyed it. Just a wonderful evening of jazz, people, drinks, food. I will definitely be returning again. The only thing charging $18 for three wings. That's a little pricey. Next time I'll just get the big pizza, but Natalie is definitely a hidden gem in Columbus. ??“
“Pulling up to this place really made me feel like I found something special. Everything was enjoyable. All the food we tried needed a little salt. A tiny pinch of flaked finishing salt would really be that final step into flavor town. The patio is enchanting and the people are very kind. They also have great “
“If you like Joseppis, you would probably like Papa Joe's.Very similar menu offerings and quality of food. Papa Joe's crust is thinner and crisper, and the sauce is less sweet. Both are a positive in my book. The pepperoni cups and has a crisp edge. Nice. Could use a touch more flavor in the sauce, but all around a good pie.I really appreciated that the pizza looked identical to the ad pictures, not doctored like some brands.Good choice and variety of menu options. Good prices too.I wish there were coupon codes on the ads so they can be used online, but I can just call in my order next time if I want.Delivery time was quicker than expected (especially since we are on a weird street) and the pizza arrived fresh and still quite hot. Driver was friendly and delivery was smooth.Will definitely be ordering again and working my way through the menu. Subs are next!“
“Decided today was a pizza day. Headed down to Bazemore Pizza Co. They're located inside of the Pointe Tavern. I ordered a Ezzo's Pepperoni and Mushrooms pizza. Went down a back hallway where the kitchen is and met with the owners, Billy Bazemore and Todd Crow. Watched as they created my pizza. They only make dough for about 80 pizzas so they provide only the freshest ingredients for your pizza. They use a nice tomato sauce with SURPRISE actual tomatoes in it. So tasty. The cheese was perfectly balanced on the pizza, not just making a solid layer across it but a nice tomato cheese layering. The pepperoni and mushrooms were placed perfectly over the pie. Decided I had to have a slice before I left. OMG!!! The flavor of the ingredients were so fresh. The passion of these two guys surely shines through in their product. They also have wings that have a phenomenal taste to them, dip them in some ranch dressing and you will be amazed on how great they are. So if you want to taste the best pizza out there, come check Billy/Todd out. They're the real deal!!!“
“Ordered Pizza and Special Salad for my Birthday Lunch here at work, it was a short wait and pizza was still warm when it got here, the pepperoni is crisp and flavorful, the toppings were abundant and it tasted so good, I will jump on the band wagon and say that you have to try the Special Salad, OMG! It seems simple but so different and tasty! Definetly recommend this place!“
“*AWESOME gourmet pizza! This pizza is SO good I was planning my next visit before I was done eating!.. I tried their Pizza Challenge and finished in 8min got a free meal and a sweet T-shirt. Great staff and management. I was visiting from out of town but am definitely looking forward to returning!.. I got all veggies on my pizza but included a picture of their toppings. They also have excellent drink specials, tons of TVs and high ceilings...“
“We really like this place and go there often. We have had several things on the menu, and it has all been good. We especially like the gyros and the potato teasers.Friendly staff, and it's always clean here. Something for everyone on the menu, and we have picky eaters in our group.Kid-friendliness: Plenty of kid favorites available“
“Our family and friends all loved the destroyer pepperoni and works pizza for my sister's big 6-0 birthday party. Sorry forgot to take a before picture. The staff were awesome to work with and helped do the loading. A big kudos to the staff for a job well done.“
“Old world, New York style pizza with a Midwest flair. I love the pizza here, it's a comforting reminder of growing up on the east coast combined with really interesting topping combinations. It's our go to, favorite pizza in Columbus.“
“Two distinct pizzas but one happy camper! In trying the spinach artichoke pizza (olive oil base; chicken) and the heartland pizza (red sauce; pepperoni/bacon), I can say that Brenz is a Jack of All Trades in the pizza game. 22 pizzas + a build your own option means that you're bound to find something that you like. Good crust and generous toppings. The only downside might be from a value perspective. At the 12 inch size, a lot of the selections were $19. If that doesn't intimidate you, a good pizza awaits.“
“Great little Italian restaurant. Family run for at least the past 35-40 years?❤️❤️Parking: Parking out front and on the side will fill up during peak hours. Behind the store is parking for a nearby shopping center. It’s a very small walk from restaurant to plenty of parking if you can’t find a spot up front.“
“Got family dinner deal with Fettuccine Alfredo, and upgraded the other entree to the Baked Spaghetti with Meatballs. And it came with bread sticks. Ordered it for take out. Food was ready when we arrived, hot, and tasted very good! Fast, friendly service.Parking: Large parking lot with plenty of spaces. Also has Drive-thru/drive up window.Kid-friendliness: (From previous observations) They bring food to the table, which is especially good for families or parents who have children with them. They have typical crayons and worksheets/coloring pages for kids to keep them occupied.“
“My wife has ordered delivery from here twice with no issues, which is a good sign that they know what they're doing when it comes to that. I had ordered a ham, pepperoni, and banana pepper Stromboli. I thought for 18 dollars was kinda high until I saw how big it was. You could definitely get two meals out of it, which is what I did. I almost got a sub instead, but I'm glad I got the Stromboli. It was good, and they give you plenty of marinara on the side to dip it in. My wife ordered a pizza, and I didn't have any of it(my wife ordered toppings i dont like), but it is the kind where they put the cheese on top. Overall, the pizza looked good, and as long as you don't have anything against the cheese on top, I'd give that a try as well as the Stromboli.“
“We ordered a large pepperoni and mushroom pizza, they said about 20minutes. Got there, the lovely ladies who were working the counter were very friendly and pleasant. Pizza was, as always, amazing, melty, warm, the crust was crispy biting into it but not sharp crispy where it hurts your mouth. The pepperoni seems like high quality and the mushrooms were fresh cut I believe.I absolutely love this pizza shop and would love to eat it all the time, I think it is reasonably priced for the quality product you receive.“
“Food is always good, plus they have my favorite beer - Ky Bourbon Barrel Ale - on tap. Our waitress did an excellent job, and the support staff stopped by several times. It can get a little loud, they may want to consider adding acoustic tiles in the ceiling to absorb sound“
“I was pleasantly surprised by Meister's. I recall reading other Yelp reviews from a few years ago that mentioned rude service. If that's still the case, I didn't experience it or see it with other patrons. I went during an Ohio State men's basketball B1G tournament game, and the sound was on which was appreciated. I also saw that they were a Browns backer bar, so it seems like they have local sports fans covered. Their six draft beers were priced well, but the main event for me was the deep dish pizza. I'm no stranger to this Chicago classic, and I (again) was pleasantly surprised at the quality. The bottom crust was a little thinner than you might find at some places, but to me this was an advantage. My one critique is that the Meat Lovers pizza seemed light on the meat, but there was ample sauce and cheese to satisfy. There were also daily drink specials, a pool table and dart boards, the latter located in a semi-private area with its own TV. I'd go back, and I'd even try their regular crust pizza which looked tasty from afar.“
“We come to Bella’s probably once a week just about for the wings and a house pizza sometimes. The wings are a nice size and always drenched in sauce. 10 wings for $9 that aren’t Wingdings can’t be beat. The pizza is pretty good but the house can sometimes have a lot of onions. I wish the buffalo wings came with blue cheese but oh well. Service is always pleasant and the food is made in a timely manner. One of my favorite parts is the Coca Cola memorabilia, it’s like walking into a museum. Overall, I recommend supporting a great family owned business with very affordable prices.“
“I ordered two pies online 1 1/2 hours before they opened without realizing it. I went to pick them up at 3:00 pm only to find they were closed. They opened the door to see what I wanted, and after listening to my situation, they asked me to wait while they prepared my order! The pies were the best I have had in Columbus! Thank you so much!!!“
“Stopped for lunch doing the pizza trail. Had a Supreme style pizza and it was really good. The only thing that was slightly sweet was the sausage. Good thing because I don't care for sweet pizza and like fennel in sausage. It could've had more cheese on it but it was a smaller pizza with several toppings. Overall, I suggest it and would have it again if in the area. Definitely give them a try.“
“I have been wanting to try Josie's Pizza Hilltop for a long time and finally got to have it. Ordered the Garlic Bread with Cheese and Sauce with a Garden Salad with Marzetti's Dijon Honey Mustard dressing. The salad was great with the dressing. The Garlic Bread with Cheese was the cheesiest garlic they have ever seen along with the most pepperoni on the Old Fashion Pepperoni pizza. I had the Combination pizza with Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Peppers, mushrooms, and onions; but did not see the Pepperoni and Sausage. Overall the Pizzas were delicious and worth going back to Josie's again soon. The service was great and talked with 1-2 employees about couples coming to Josie's Pizza Hilltop as a Sunday night tradition. It is a small place but with some seats, but there is a table that can accommodate 12 people to a table that can be used for a birthday party or family gathering. I will go back to Josie's Pizza Hilltop soon for the Old Fashion Pepperoni pizza.“
“LOVED the focaccia bread they brought out before dinner, the oil they brought to dip it in had rosemary and other fresh herbs in it. Dinner was yummy! Good Italian, nothing out of this world but a safe bet if you’re wanting something tasty.“
“Definitely the most underrated pizza in the Columbus area. Thin, crisp, and perfectly proportional between crust sauce and cheese. Also wayyy less greasy than the majority of places out there which I appreciate! I like getting the regular cheese pizza with extra sauce. Highly recommend!“
“5 STARS FOR NATASHA - EVERY TIME she answers, she provides top notch service and is fast and accurate while also being SOO friendly and personable.. She is just excellenttttttttttt and deserves to be recognized! Natasha brings her A game and deserves a BIG raise as such a HUGE asset to Flyers Pizza!“
“This is my second time having it, and my fiancés like 50th ?. He grew up next to it and decided to show me his favorite food from his childhood. Their food is SOOOOO good. Better than any papa johns, donatos, anything, they’re so good and all of the staff is just incredibly sweet. Thank you for amazing food and customer service everytime we’ve visited. We got the sub n crust.“
“We got a pepperoni sausage and banana pepper pizza. It was the first time we ordered here. I am very picky about my pizza! This was the best pizza I've had in a long time! The sausage was so good! The pepperonis tasted like actually meat instead of fake like a lot of places! And they are not stingy with the cheese like a lot of places! The only complaint I have is we got a large but it was more like a medium. Other than that it was perfect and will definitely be our new go to pizza place!!“
“I love Planks On Broadway! This place has been around forever. There is one on Parsons Ave., one on High St., but my favorite one is in Grove City! A great place to meet up with friends and hang out. Everyone is welcome...Come sit with us at the Community Table! Great food and Great drinks as well as Great prices! Try the Reuben, or come in on Tuesdays for 1/2 price Pizza!“
“Wanted to try another pizza spot who will not be named (just look at my reviews if you wanna see where to avoid) and i got the worst pizza i have ever eaten, i didn’t even finish a slice of that abomination. Now i’m sitting here at home hungry, angry, and disappointed. Enter Grandad’s Pizza. I got a personal tater tot pizza and personal pep and bacon to share with someone else and I am beyond satisfied. if there was a second coming of jesus christ i’m sorry to say i just ate it.“
“Absolutely one of my favorites.Currently I get banana peppers and pineapple!!! My new favorite toppings duo!! Their pepperoni is amazing! Meatball sub and Michael Angelo sub are also excellent. I haven’t tried anything that I haven’t really enjoyed!“
“Ok Pizza place.Tried their ny-style pizza first. Pepperoni and Banana Pepper. Good pizza. Good crust and flavorful dough. Simple pizza.Tried their mid-west style pizza next. Peperoni and pineapple. There was way too much cheese. And their dough was underbaked. The bottom was crusty, but the upper half of the dough was clearly undercooked. Would not get it again.“
“Such a fun place to hang with the family for the afternoon. We went with our teenagers and their friends and got two lanes. Recommendation for parents - 1 hour bowling is plenty. Food is great and our waitress was very attentive with great service.“
“Our group stopped in and got 3 Large double pep pizzas and 1 being half cheese.1st time and I have to say, best pizza I have had in at least 20 years. Current favorite and I can't see this place losing that spot any time soon. It's a shame we live an hour out.“
“03/21/2024Another absolutely amazing pizza here tonight! Crust is perfectly crunchy, sauce was plentiful and tasty! Service was spot on! Love this place!We had a great pizza and service tonight! The pizza we had was delicious! The service we got was excellent very friendly and attentive! We saw the sign out front said "special large one topping $11.75"! We were very excited for that deal! Our large Pepperoni and two diet cokes were 22.36? We asked what happened and with a straight face the server said "well you have to ask for that"!(the special )I asked if the pizza was different and no "you just have to ask for it"! We continued to set and watch the game and the owner came by. He was equally friendly and talked to us for some time. He offered to adjust our bill but, we had already paid. The pizza was worth every penny we paid and we will go back but if you want a special price you must ask for it!“
“The BEST pizza!!! If you’re looking for pizza on game day, this is your place. Nothing more I want in a deep dish pizza, great flavor. It’s not cheap, but it’s a decent, price, especially for the flavor you’re getting. They have a good variety of options so you’ll find what you’re looking for!“
“I love the large chef salad with extra meat and cheese, and the small pepperoni, sausage and extra cheese pizza. I also love the deal on the cans of pop. I have been a customer since 1997 when I worked at Mount Carmel West hospital. Sometimes they can tell that it's me by what I order. From AngelWheelchair accessibility: I'm glad that it's wheelchair accessible because I have trouble with steps.“
Pizza • $
“Thank you to Flyers!!! They value their customers and their input. We had some issues with our recent orders multiple times and they reached out to me to find out what the problem was.Very unusual to feel valued by a restaurant in today’s world. I appreciate your customer service and food always tastes great“
“A nice surprise. Found this place with a friend for lunch last week. I’ve been back for takeout twice already. Meatball sub has a hold on me! Service is great. Friendly and attentive. Great menu with lots of options. Great atmosphere. I would definitely recommendWheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp“
“The gentleman who took our order at Casa di Pizza went above and beyond to take care of us. He was very attentive to anything we needed at the table. We were eating with two little kids and he took the effort to make sure they had everything they needed as well. The pizza was very yummy! We had the double double. The only comment was the pricing for the pizza was different on each of their posted menus, hard to make an informed decision when the price is different. But would go back again!“
“Great pizza with the perfect amount of toppings! The staff is friendly, and the pizza comes out in a reasonable amount of time. Crooked Can, where this is located, is a great place to go as a group or an individual. They also have live music.“
“We all agreed that we had one of the best pizzas we have ever had tonight at Todd's! It was so good! The crust was thin and crackery crisp, the tomato sauce was mild and delicious! The pepperoni was perfectly mild, with just the right amount spice. Absolutely delicious! We don't live near West Jefferson but cannot wait to get back here! The garlic bread was equally good as was the house salad! The staff was friendly and our server was great! I do not understand why this place was not lined up out the door!“
“Best pizza in Columbus. There is a review below where someone says "The crust was perfect" and then gives 3 stars on their review. This place is epic. Don't pay attention to the South Park Yelper reviews giving anything less than 4 stars.“
“This was my first time to Jet Pizza. I went to pick up an order of 4 corners for my Aunt since I was in the area. I ordered 8 corners for my son and I. I was impressed normally, I'm a thin crust pizza kinda lady well, I may have to change my stance. Those corners had everything from crispy edges, and not overly or under sauced, and a pillow soft center. All the wonderful qualities of a good pizza. I ordered the Eugene Supreme toppings. When I'm back in the area and have a hangering for pizza, this is where I will be headed.“
“Absolutely love the pizza they are one of the few places in town to get beef pepperoni and beef sausage. They are always friendly and the store has a large selection so i am pretty sure you can find what you need, and it's clean.Dietary restrictions: They offer beef pepperoni and beef sausage“
“Very good pizza. Lots of things to choose from including appetizers, subs, pastas and salads to name a few. We have also in the past ordered their family size spaghetti dinnersStaff is always friendly and helpful. Inside is always clean and well tended to. They also have dine in with decent seating.Some other bonuses to me that they have.... They have a nice sized parking lot. They sell 2 liters and energy drinks which is appealing when grabbing something to take home to the kids before going back into workParking: There's always plenty of spots close to the building“
“This Donato’s has been specifically good to our family. They provided both our older children their first employment experience and were a good organization to work for. The food is always as well done as Donato’s can do. They handle a lot of parties and large orders, so if you need to feed a lot of people, quickly, they are great.“
“This was the best deli I ever had in Columbus, hands down...... This was amazing and fresh, and the service was amazing. So I want everyone to know this place is the truth and you won't be disappointed....The price is another subject , because how can you get a meal for so cheap and so good. Turkey bacon sub w fresh cut fries and a side of pasta salad 8.10 ...Glad I found this place .“
“Today my husband and I ordered from Flyers in Hilliard, as we frequently do. Our front door didn’t close all the way after my husband got our pizza from the delivery driver, and the wind blew it open further. Our driver Autumn went out of her way to text me to let me know it hadn’t shut because she didn’t want our pups to get out. Though they are very good dogs and don’t typically run, I am so appreciative of her doing so! Also, with it being Super Bowl Sunday, I expected it to take a little longer than normal but we received our order very quickly with no issues! Thank you for the outstanding service!“
“Fast and hot delivery of our food to the table. Must have been a surge of customers just before we arrived. Bartenders managed to keep the pace, cooks were going as quickly as the ovens would finish the dish. Everyone was staying calm and respectful. Nice crew. Thanks.“