50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hinckley

“Really really solid pizza! They seemed a bit all over the place today but they were still really kind though! I'm definitely coming back for pizza time and time again. I'd also add that while I didn't get what I ordered the first time, the owner paid for it herself and owned up to mistake. Really solid people here.Parking: Good amount of parking. Nothing crazy but just glad to see they have it especially considering their location.“

“I am MiMi's new biggest fan! love the one slice/salad combo. Just tried the tortelini soup today. ITS AMAZING! Pizza is so good too. Salads are ALWAYS fresh. I'm there at least once a week. :) Thanks for a great local place that serves homemade food!“

“This pizza is SOOOOOO good. We got it quickly after ordering, everyone was nice, order was accurate and the pizza tasted amazing. It tasted good reheated too, and that's saying a lot because if you knew me, you'd know just how much I despise reheated pizza.“

“Beaucoup Bucks at Bucci's. Prices were kinda high for quantity not necessarily for its quality. We had 14 person bday party on a Sunday afternoon. Pretty busy in there. Nice ambiance but really kinda loud probably since it's so tight in there. We had 2 servers, & were great. They let us bring our own cakes in & servers brought it out w/ candles so that was perfect. My Buccis burger was tasty & a large size. It only came w/ chips so I subbed salad for $3 so it was $17 which was a bit steep. The bruschetta was good but the toastinis were super hard - all crunch & no chew so it exploded as you bit it. Not many of us ate them therefore. Others got the French onion soup & calamari which were unfinished so not sure they loved em. The steak was reported good but a pretty penny. My two cousins next to me got 2 apps 2 entrees & 2 sodas and their bill was $90! Wow. Although the kids meal chicken tenders was huge & a great value. Nice place & good food w/ robust prices.“

“It was "retail wine night" - always a great value for their terrific selection of wines. The food was superb. We had a wonderful time with some longtime friends. The quiet of the enclosed patio made it possible, given my hearing issues. Our waitress was friendly and efficient. Other customers were friendly and thoughtful, seemed to be enjoying their experience as much as we did ours!“

“I LOVE the gyros at this place. I love the lamb and beef gyro, spicy chicken gyro and Fish gyro. On some occasions the food does come out subpar but that doesn't happen often. If the price was a bit lower I would frequent this place more often than I already do.“

“I'm not sure how the food is. I live in another state, and we have an "A Slice Above" pizzeria nearby. I placed an order, and only realized that the order I placed was at this location. Idk why this number comes up when I google "A Slice Above" when there is one right up the street from me and this one is states away ..... But anyway, the employee was so nice about it. If I lived nearby I would support this business just because of the employee's attitude.“

“First time ordering from Big Star thanks to a pizza group I’m in on FB. Expansive menu including pastas, salads, burgers yes burgers, some Greek options and other Italian options. I can’t wait to order from here again. The person taking my order was super friendly. Pizza came out amazing. Ordered the New York style with all veggies and a side of garlic dipping sauce. Also Not greasy either. Crispy and balanced. So so yummy. Ordered the breaded mixed veggies as well. Delish breading. Recommend.“

“Friends from Richfield have raved about the pizza here, so we decided to give it a try. We are in agreement with our friends! The salad was crisp and cold and had just the right amount of cheese on it. Our pizza was outstanding. I've never had such a flavorful crust. Toppings were fresh and tasty as well. Wouldn't change a thing. We will be back.“

“This is one of the best pizza places in the area! We had the white pizza with artichokes and topped with ricotta cheese! It was so good! I could not wait to eat the leftovers! We tried the cheesy bread! Very tasty also!!! The rest of our group ordered pizza with pepperoni. Delicious!!! I could go there every day!!! It’s that good!!!“

“I only have one complaint. We have been calling this place for two days between my girlfriend and me. We have made 20 calls, when the phone ring it would just be music even called the operator to see if there was something wrong with the line. Finally my friend went up there to check and they’re closed until April 15, I wish they would’ve respected their customers enough to have had a message on their machine saying such. We wasted a lot of time that we can’t get back.Well that sounds like you’re making excuses. Why didn’t you just put it on the information that states your hours and you could’ve written right there Close till April 15, that would’ve been easy. Your attitude is disappointing. Sounds like disrespect for the customer and I do love this restaurant and I love the people that have waited on me.“

“In the area for work and was seeking out GREAT pizza. I reached out to a popular pizza group I follow in my home city of Columbus. I thought about both but I needed more info/photos so I turned to Uber Eats and I was NOT disappointed!!! There was a deal so I ordered a pizza and boneless wings and both were AMAZING!! I ordered the ZACH style and boneless wings in mild Buffalo. I asked for garlic butter and ranch as sides. You can tell the garlic butter and ranch are homemade. The pizza was PERFECT!! Great sauce, great amount of toppings, nice caramelized crust....YUM!!! So glad I decided to order!!“

“Delicious pizza but the dining in experience isn’t ideal for a couple dining out. I would recommend this place for take out. There is constant ringing of the phone that you can hear since the place is so small. Also it can get super busy around 5 pm so be aware there may be a long wait time to be seated.Again the pizza is super delicious and I tried the regular and was very pleased.“

“First time at Pizzeria Cerino as my quest for NE Ohio's best veal parmigiana continues. My wife and I had a meeting out in Seven Hills and wondered in. Got there about 5:30 with no reservation and was seated immediately. Could have been a problem had we come a little later as it filled up fast. Place appeared fairly new, clean with a separate bar area. Food was good, really good. Dinner came with bread and we split a very nice house salad...plenty big enough to share. I had the veal parmigiana and wife had the bolognese. My veal was a solid as any place around town. My wife's bolognese was also very good. I prefer flat noodles instead of stovepipe for bolognese but it was excellent. Portions were very fair for the price and we both had enough for lunch the next day. Split a cannoli for desert. Solid enough. Service was good, friendly and unassuming. Kind of a shame it is so far away from where I live as this is the kind of place that I would frequent a lot.“

“This was my first time ordering. I went in and picked up my pizza and it ready when they said. The girl working was super friendly and sweet. I told her it was my first time and she made sure to give me menu and coupons so I can come back. The pizza tasted delicious and I will def be going back.“

“We did a catering with them for 60 people for the first time and won't be our last!Great food, service, reasonable price and food arrived fresh and on time.There was enough for everyone and plenty food leftThe Guac was really my favorite“

“I'd give 6 Stars if I could. Picked up 8 family pizzas and 8 double salads for a party the other night. Everyone loved it! Definitely recommend the plain cheese and the sausage/pepperoni combo. Crust was perfect. Sauce, cheese and toppings were all delicious. Salads with tons of cheese and Farinacci's signature Italian dressing with tomato, cucumber and black olives. Deb was friendly as usual and the restaurant was packed. Dine in or take out, this place is as good as it gets!“

“First, the beer is amazing. Second, the food is fabulous! I had the pulled pork sandwich, it was the best! My wife had the Mahi Mahi wrap she said it was amazing. We both got the coleslaw as our side and were glad we did. Third the atmosphere and service was great. We will be back.“

“Fratello's is our go to place for pizza. We moved into the area three years ago and have tried pizza from many different restaurants. Fratello's is definitely the best. The sauce, cheese, and crust is fantastic. We have also had their subs, Stromboli, appetizers, and salads that were equally delicious. In fact, their Italian sub is the best I have ever had. We vary between take out and delivery and in either case the staff we dealt with have been great. With specific reference to delivery, the food is always promptly delivered and hot. I give Fratello's my highest recommendation.“

“My fiancé and I are pretty picky about pizza, and this place is our go-to spot at least once a week. The sauce is good and it’s never too heavy or too light. The pizza itself is never too doughy or soggy, but we always get it well-done and it’s perfect every time. This little mom & pop shop is one of, if not the, best pizza joints in the area! Highly recommend!!!“

“Perfect place. Quality food + drinks, great prices. Service is always great, it's remodeled and so clean. Live music + Karaoke + keno/lotto + golf driving range this place is a favorite of mine and my family'sVegetarian options: Staff is attentive and flexibleKid-friendliness: family friendly environmentDietary restrictions: Staff is attentive and flexible“

“I only write reviews for places that are worth it, and this was one of them. I had a short break at work and needed lunch for the day. I was skeptical of a "drive-thru" pizza place. Between the claimed time and quality, I wasn't sure if it could match those claims. Fortunately I was proven wrong and it exceeded expectations. It was amazing how quick the service was and the pizza quality was solid. With the added bonus of the super cheap lunch special, this is definitely a place worth visiting if you're in need of a speedy pizza fix. Will be coming back in the future for when I need a quick, solid lunch.“

“I really think it’s the BEST thin crust pizza we have ever had! My wife & I split a Caprese & 4 young grandkids had a half cheese & half pep& cheese. Even the kids said it was the best crust they ever had! Watching the chef prepare & throw the dough was an added treat!“

“Got the family meal with meatballs, Italian sausage, rigatoni, salad, and bread. Meatballs are excellent, the Pizzeria salad was great, and the bread is to die for. The assortment of cookies for the desert was very good. Recommend this place for good quality food and fast easy takeout.“

“We had brunch on Sunday, overall everything was good, except the coffee was not hot and it appeared they had some difficulty coordinating the dishes as the waffles were not hot when they were served, although they were tasty. We had reservations and were told when we arrived that we could either sit at a hightop or sit outside. Since we did have a reservation, I would have expected to have been offered a table especially since one of the members of our party is in her late 80"s. We chose outside although it was warm it was windy, and with the music speaker above our table we had a difficult time conversing with each other, not ideal.“

“I've been eating this pizza since they were at the Great Northern mall food court back in the 70's. I still love it! I'm a westside resident. The few New York style pizza places I found near me were lousy. These pies are GOOOD! The garlic pie, broccoli tomatoe add bacon, or my favorite 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 mushrooms are delicious! Meatball sub is good too. Get ya some, you won't be disappointed. Oh, the dining room is now reopened too. They sell slices. Have some pizza, head over and take a hike at the Metropark trail & burn some calories off and enjoy some nature.“

“Maybe I am biased because I have been getting pizza here since a child ..... But I have lived in several states. And I can promise you there is no pizza that even comes close to what you will find here at Romito's Pizza West in Independence ...Unfortunately, this applies to every other Romitos pizza that you will find that is not Romitos Pizza West in Independence ...So please don't be fooled by the name on the sign because in this case it's all about the location ...It's all about the people ...It's all about the hometown atmosphere ...It's all about exceptional service ...Of course it's all about the food!“

“Best deal around for a sheet pizza. Always fresh. The sauce is great. Not an overpowering tomato flavor. Nice and subtle. Tastes homemade. It's a go-to for a quick and affordable family meal with leftovers to spare. The cheesy garlic bread is awesome as well. Highly recommend.“

“The chicken shawarma was dynamite (I mean it... This is shawarma like no other. The sauce is so packed with flavor, the chicken is juicy, the pita wrap is crispy all the way around... It's amazing), the lentil soup and hummus were delicious, and the service was great. We had zero complaints, and want to go back right now.“

“We came here a couple of years ago, and the food and service were terrible. We thought we would give this place another try. We came here on a Wednesday evening, and there were plenty of seats available that scared me at first. But my fears were very short-lived.The server was pleasant and attentive, and the food was good, and it came out hot. The menu is fairly extensive. Everything from salads, pizza, subs, calzones, and more.I had the Backstage Classic Woogie. It had pepperoni, sausage, yellow peppers, and 5 cheese blends in a rolled calzone. It came with a side of pizza sauce. It was a really nice blend of flavors. Our group also ordered a pepperoni pizza and an Italian Cobb salad.The pizza was really good. And way better than we were expecting. The Cobb salad was loaded with a lot of Italian goodness.We will definitely come back again.“

“Thanks to my husband discovering this gem of a pizza joint I can’t help but want their delicious food about once a week. I love their BBQ chicken pizza and garlic Parmesan wings, but everything else we’ve tried has been just as delicious! Double edged sword bc I found the best place around, but I’m wanting to eat it all the time. Must try!!“

“Ladies day out, and Cafe Arnone was fabulous! The owner super friendly, knowledgeable and patient as this was our first time. We did the gelato flight, totally worth it! You can tell it’s made with love! I had the spicy Sicilian (wow) the Tuscan chicken, pizza and gluten free egg sandwich, made up our table, with coffees, latte, teas were VERY happy and satisfied. Worth the trip. Clean restaurant, and restrooms.Dietary restrictions: So many things that are gluten free, our friend enjoyed cake and sandwich, alsode-caff. espresso“

“The pizza place has pretty good pizza but the sauce on the pizza is a little sweet and if you don't like sweet sauce then you will probably not like this pizza much especially if you are like me I don't like sweet pizza sauce it tasted like a bag of sugar but other than that it was pretty good my wife liked it and that's the most important thing“

“I have been eating at this pizza shop for 40 years of my life it is the best pizza the best chicken parm the best sausage the best crust that I've had and I'm Italian and I eat a lot of places thanks to Bill and Bill for 40 years of great customer service and “

“This place is nice and the food is good. But my only issue it’s a little bland . Not sure if they need to add salt or what but just lacking flavor . But great atmosphere cool people and floor smells and taste good , just a little bland for my liking . Will come back“

“Have only tried the salad and pizza so csnt speak on other items. The salad is really good. White pizza is outstanding. You do have to get the pizzas well done or they tend to be a little doughy. Don't understand the low reviews but this place is a solid choice with giant pizzas. Also the byob option is a nice touch.“

“Best Pizza in the world, I stop at Jets in Mooresville everytime I go to Florida, then I went to Jets in Westlake, then I found one on Pearl Rd in Middleburg Hts. So I bought 3 deep dish pizzas and took the back to my race shop, now all 5 of them are sold on Jets being the best pizza, just like I told them. Sure wish they would put a shop in Medina or Wadsworth Ohio! Thanks Jets!“

“This was our first dinner on our trip to Cleveland and it was perfect! We had two pizzas, a salad, wings, fries, and a giant cookie. Everyone there was so nice and helpful!! The food was fantastic and the pizza was even good the next morning (cold for breakfast).“

“Master Pizza really is a cut above the other pizza places. The pizza always tastes really good and is fresh and the crust is good too. It is even good leftover. The building is very clean and well lit. The employees are very polite and professional. This is really the only pizza place that we use. When we have parties at our house, we get pizza and wings delivered and everyone loves it.“

“OMG! What a wonderfully unexpected surprise! While visiting a family member in the transition Center across the street, we decided to eat at the closest restaurant - Fatbob's Pizza. My wife had a calzone and I had a small meat galore pizza. Let me tell you that it's probably the best crust I've ever enjoyed for a pizza. The meat and sauce on the pizza were exceptional! The marinara sauce for the calzone was out of this world!The employees were very polite and helpful. We even we're offered cups of sauce for our to go containers.We will certainly stop there again when we are in the area.“

“We stopped in late on a Sunday night for a quick bite with our daughter because it was the only place near our hotel that was open. The staff were so nice, especially Anastasia and Rick, who gladly treated our daughter to two bowls of different flavors of ice cream! It meant a lot to us to have a happy kid as we’re on a cross-country drive to British Columbia! Hope to be back the next time we’re in town. Thanks so much! -Erin, Chris, and Rosie“

“We had not ordered from Tommy's recently and it is beyond me why. The pizzas were delicious with the right amount of cheese, to sauce, to toppings! Their antipasto was also a pleasant surprise. Fresh mixed greens (no iceberg) with nicely portioned meats, cheese & veges. Everything was ready when they said it would be, friendly staff. We'll be back.“

“Been here many times. Service is always good. Food normally is 4 to 5 stars. It was a little off today, meatballs and sauce, normally exquisite tasted like store bought. The fried mushrooms were chewy and not crisp. We will definitely be “

“The food is so delicious!. One of our favorite restaurants, hands-down!. The calamari is the best around!. Their hand breaded chicken tenders are absolutely amazing, and their homemade cavatelli and meatballs are literally over the top!. Love this restaurant!.“

“We visited a few weeks ago. Right away the atmosphere was warm and welcoming. The staff was super friendly even though they were swamped. Our food was Amazing! The pizza was the best we’ve had in a long time. The spaghetti was so good. Their bread was the first Italian restaurant we went to in Akron Medina area that the bread had Flavor!!! Even busy we were not rushed. Overall a great and relaxing place.“

“I ordered 2 sheet pizza,s for a family reunion, as it was an Italian reunion, all the food was Italian, people bought pizza from other places, but kudos to attillo,s ,everyone loved yours and said it tasted most like grama,s ( who is no longer with us) it was all gone. Thank you for making our day special. ❤?“

“I really like their pan pizzas but our thing to order when the grandkids are over. And I always get at least one double pepperoni. But my last several orders the pepperoni has been extremely spicy that the kids won’t eat it. Did you change vendors? Perhaps you can offer a spicy and a mild.“

“Love this spot! The beer wall has a very good selection for all kinds of beer drinkers. The food is really good as well. Love the atmosphere and the patio. Highly recommend stopping here for a drink and some food! First time here but we will be back for sure!“

“This review was from a couple years ago and although I can't remember exactly why for the three-star review, there had to have been something that happened or was it right.I have edited this review to a five-star not because of your free Pizza (which is appreciated) but rather because about a week ago while we were having a particularly busy day we ordered online for a curbside at our local D's, the staff was nice, prompt, made our order correctly and showed an interest in us as people.As compared to an order we just had delivered from Hut tonight (which arrived with toppings incompletely topped and regular cut vs square as requested, albeit a minor issue) I must say that Domino's is currently the better choice.“

“They always do a fabulous job on our pizza's and salads. The food is great quality and always delivered hot. We order from them at least 1 time per week at Baskets Galore. Our team loves their food. The Orlando Pizza is one of our favorites. And their salads are second to none!“