19 Best Ice Cream Shops near Lyndhurst

“I love their custard. My favorite is a kid sized turtle with whipped cream and a cherry. The hot fudge is always hot and that's important. Most places don't bother with the hot fudge actually being hot and that's just wrong on so many levels. The only thing I don't like about the place is the weird smell. Might be disinfectant, but whatever it is it's too strong.“

“Tasty ice cream, friendly staff and modern atmosphere. We had a cookies and cream milkshake and the seasonal cinnamon ice cream. Both were delicious but I did wish the ice cream was a little bit more frozen. The train around the top of the restaurant was cute. The tables all needed some cleaning and attention though.“

“Best place for teen-hangouts, treating your kids, family-treats and supervised dates. Their Ice creams are of superior taste and quality. Freshly and locally produced quality ingredients are their USP. I like there Pistachio and Banana flavours the most.“

“Thank you to the wonderful staff at Kake Kutters. I sent my husband to pick up some cupcakes (last minute) for our son's birthday. We thought they opened at 11 AM (they open at noon) and the open sign was on, he tried to open the door. When the employees came to the door, they politely advised that they were due to open at noon. He understood but they still asked if he wanted to come in to make his purchase. This was our first time patronizing this establishment, but will certainly not be the last. They answered every question and even engaged with me via facetime. The level of customer service was beyond superior. You've earned our support and will highly recommend this black, woman owned bakery and sweet shop every time. Oh, we tried the banana pudding, which was light and airy, plus not overly sweet. Definitely made from scratch. I'll be back for my husband's cake in a few weeks. Wishing you continued success.“

“Favorite Cleveland ice cream place. Friendly staff. If you want a strawberry ice cream that tastes like actual strawberries you will like their strawberry ice cream. Also recommend their mint chocolate chunk. It doesn't have green food coloring, but it still tastes great.“

“Fabulous & locally owned! They started many years ago on the westside of Cleveland. When I moved east, it was one of the many things I sorely missed, so i'm very glad they have branched out onto the Eastside finally. Their honey pecan is better than anything at Mitchell's. Now that Honey Hut is on the east side. I don't understand why there are still lines at Mitchell's. Highly recommended.“

“My daughter and her friend picked up a coffee gelato for me. It was Divine. Smooth and creamy without any artificial taste. I will be going back again and sometime the stack was wonderful so friendly that you felt like you were having dessert with your family.“

“I cannot tell you enough about this place. It is so good and the workers are very friendly and helpful. I've been there twice in 4 days. They have different cookies every week. They change them on Sundays. I have not been disappointed yet. I love this place.“

“Celebrating small business week, decided to try Pop Culture CLE. It is a small but friendly gourmet ice cream shop. The young lady behind the counter was friendly, knowledgeable and helpful with recommendations. The presentation of my choice was great, and taste even better. I would recommend this spot for families, dates or if you just want something beautiful, different and tasty. Oh and the prices are reasonable.“

“10/10! Amazing choices and flavors. When my family went here we always got the blue moon or Superman, the blue moon is to kill for! (Maybe an overstatement but still) The atmosphere is always friendly and there are no cons except bees but when it's summer and there is a lot of sugar that's to be expected.Kid-friendliness: Great options and taste for kids.“

“A great local ice cream chain! I visited here on the solar eclipse day and while the line was out the door, it moved quickly. I had been here before and got the chocolate peanut butter cup, which I found underwhelming. This time, I got the peanut butter fudge sundae with caramel fudge brownie ice cream. The sundae was reasonably priced ($7) with a good portion size, and it was delicious. The peanut butter and hot fudge were delicious, and the ice cream was rich and creamy, with plenty of hearty fudge chunks. I highly recommend Mitchell's if you are looking for good, local ice cream in Cleveland!“

“A great local ice cream shop. They have a huge variety of ice cream and drinks. Very popular in the evenings, when people like to sit under the large pergola.Wouldn't hurt to have a few more seating options. They take credit card, thank you!“

“Oh my. I didn't realize this ice cream place would be such a delight. And it's right around the corner! The flavors are traditional and unique. I had a Capaccino Crunch cone. Huge dips and amazing flavor. My new go-to place for ice cream.“

“Adorable cafe with delicious food and amazing employees! I've been there a few times, and it's always been a delight. I love the classic tiramisu, Hershey mochi balls, ube soft serve, and caramel creme brulee.The decor is so cute and pretty, and they have a big whiteboard and markers for anyone to use to write and draw. There's also some claw machines with some cure plushies. I tried them with some friends, and we all won stuff.The workers are all very kind, too. They're very welcoming and super fast with making food and drinks. I can't wait to come here again!“

“This is a very well maintained ice cream place. While the place is easy to pass up if your not familiar with it's location, I really enjoy the options of sitting at a bench to enjoy your treat with family and friends. More marketing sogne would really help with the 5th star.“

“Lots of ice cream flavors. All fun and unique. Staff is very nice and accommodating. Plenty of parking. The only real downside is that it's a bit pricey compared to your local dairy whatever. But your getting good quality ingredients and fun flavors. Portion is pretty generous, so not skimpy. So your gonna pay a bit more. Go for it. As a treat it's good and worth it. Plenty of parking. You can eat inside or outside. Tables are available.“

“One of the best local places to receive either a sandwhich or some ice cream. With PERFECT portion sizes, friendly staff, and an amazing atmosphere I would totally recommend this place to any person. (Definitely recommend the black raspberry choc. chip flavor)“

“Love Micky's. My only problem, I walk up there with my dog alot. Some times I eat my ice cream there with my dog, but if it's busy I like to take it to go. I wouldn't even be mentioning this if it didn't happen every single time... any time I ask for it to go they never hear me, always come out with out lids and no bag. It's just a bit frustrating, I'm an anxious person and I just wish I could be heard the first time and not have to have another conversation just to get my stuff to go.“

“The sugar cookies are Pavlovian!The staff is unusually nice/polite. Nolan has been there the last 2 times I've been there. He simply asked, "how are you doing today?" It caught me off guard cause it didn't sound/feel like typical customer service talk.If the cookies didn't draw me in anytime I'm in the area, the service/staff definitely would!!!“