6 Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

FigLeaf Brewing Company Brewery • $
3387 Cincinnati Dayton Rd, Middletown

“I tried the Vienna lager and a Dunkel. Both beers were just right in the sense that they weren't overly hopped which is an issue I have at many breweries. I don't really like IPAs and the bitterness. These beers were sweet,flavorful and crisp. Pizza was pretty good, thick crust but crispy and made with freshly prepared dough. I just had their cheese pizza. Overall I enjoyed the experience, may have to stop in again sometime.“

4.5 Superb63 Reviews
Steel City Pizza Pizza •
1330 Manchester Ave Suite A, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

OMG Becky Look at That Pumpkin Pizza
Bavarian Soft Pretzel Sticks
Garlic Knots with Meatballs
Focaccia Bread Sticks
Build Your Own
Blast Furnace
Margherita

“A really great pie and the best in the area. The worker, who presumably was the owner, was very nice and appreciative. The pizza is a wood fired Neapolitan style. It has great char, a good undercarriage, slight crisp, zero flop, and good flavor but was hoping for a bit more in the sauce. Definitely recommended and a bonus is the brewery next door. For the Portnoy fans, I rated this a 7.4 but unfortunately this business isn't available in the app to post a review but I'll keep an eye out.“

4.7 Superb44 Reviews
Shaddock's Pizza and Drive Thru Pizza • $
4713 Central Ave, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Cheesy Garlic Bread Large 6
Steak Sandwich
Pizza

“Finally gave this place a try and it was great. Ordered a large pepperoni and the cheesy garlic bread. The large pizza is LARGE, and there's a ton of cheese. It's square cut but the slices are good sized, given the pile of toppings. Bread was quality too, heavy on the garlic which is a positive.“

4.1 Good44 Reviews
Cassano's Pizza King Pizza • $
1201 Jackson Ln, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Large Deluxe Pizza

“Pizza is really Good and with the house made garlic butter that you can use on anything even bagels. There cheezy garlic bread is the bomb. The price for pizza is on the higher end. But the appetizers are decent priced. They also serve bottles of beer here.“

4.1 Good30 Reviews
LaRosa's Pizza Middletown Pizza • $
4900 Roosevelt Blvd, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Fried Mozzarella Cheese Sticks
Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Spaghetti Meal Deal
Double Pepperoni
Hot Garlic Bread
Calzone Toppings
Boneless Wings
LaRosa's Steak
French Fries

“I recently visited LaRosa's for a pizza night out with my uncle, and while the pizza was undeniably delicious, I was a bit disappointed with the service.Let's start with the positives. The pizza at LaRosa's is top-notch. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. It's clear that they take pride in the quality of their ingredients, and it definitely shows in the taste.However, I can't give a full 5-star rating because of the service. While the staff was friendly, there were some noticeable issues with the speed and attentiveness of the service. It took quite a while for our orders to be taken, and even longer for the food to arrive at our table. Additionally, We had to wait for a table for around 20 minutes.Despite these service hiccups, I would still recommend LaRosa's for the fantastic pizza alone. If they can work on improving the efficiency and attentiveness of their service, it would truly elevate the dining experience to a whole new level.Overall, I give LaRosa's a solid 4 stars. Great pizza, just be prepared for potentially slower service“

3.7 Good77 Reviews
Rapid Fired Pizza Pizza • $$
3583 Dixie Hwy, Middletown

Customers` Favorites

Mac N Cheese Pizza
Build Your Own
Taco Pizza

“I’m absolutely impressed with how quickly this staff member served multiple customers ALONE. There is only 1 employee working at this time (11/27/22 @ 1:00pm) she is outstanding under this amount of pressure. I’ve been standing in line for 45 minutes watching her work as fast and hard as she can. Although I’m dissatisfied with how the company is treating her but I’m hoping she is getting paid properly for working by herself instead of closing the store for the day.“

3.8 Good29 Reviews
Loading...
map Map