12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Middletown

“Went today and enjoyed- pepperoni pizza delicious 😋“

“We have had one of the best pizza nights in a long time! Great friendly staff and pizza! Good job guys!“

“I door dash a pizza and it was horrible looking, cold, and had onions on it 🤮I had to drive to the verity location to see if they could fix it although I knew I would have to go through door dash. When I came in and explained what happened and showed them the pizza, they immediately started working on a new pizza and let me know what all I needed to do to contact door dash. Lucas the manager and employees were so nice and very helpful!!“

“My sister and I go to this location quite often after church on Sunday afternoons and we always have good experiences with everything. The only thing I could suggest is when someone orders garlic bread or breadsticks that the waitress ask if they want cheese on them. They come with cheese which I don’t like and it’s not the same if I have to scrape it off. It seems like those items would be plain unless someone asks for the cheese. They did make me a new order of garlic bread recently but I don’t like them to have to waste food. I just have to remember to say no cheese!“

“crust was awesome! a little salty lime Cassanos“

“Last month, Shaddocks enter the MIDDLETOWN’s FOPA PIZZA SHOWDOWN. We want to share just some of the judge’s notes on the competition. QUALITY: Genuinely good ingredients, textured to tease the tongue and sooth the appetite. APPEARANCE: Hidden within, is a tasty, hardy portion of deliciousness. Looks like a pie, but tastes like an amazing pizza. SAUCE: A mixture of savory and sweet. A uniquely flavored twist. TASTE: Sweet N’ Savory, hardy and delightfully flavorful. A burst of tantalizing goodness you can’t get enough of.“

“I’m leaving this five star review because I had an issue with DoorDash the first DoorDash driver stole my food from this establishment after I noticed after like an hour that multiple drivers had kept being reassigned. I called the manager and he said I handed it to a DoorDash driver, and then it all made sense, but he took the initiative to remake my food and was gonna have it delivered to me by one of his own drivers that’s great customer service and fantastic management in the end. DoorDash ended up owning up to their drivers theft. They reimburse the restaurant and they reimbursed me which is rare for DoorDash to do anything right but this place deserves five stars and kudos to the manager for offering to do the right thing and they have really good !!!“

“The pizza is good but every time I order extra cheese there’s hardly ever any cheese on there and there are dry bubbles on top I hate that“

“I bet my Pizza Hut is better than yours! 😉 the last time I ordered from Verity location, I was late picking it up. Janet took one look and had it remade when we did arrive so that it was fresh! Every delivery shows up sooner than later (I'm sure my location helps a bit) but everyone is courteous and efficient!“

“IF YOU HAVEN'T BEEN YOUR MISSING OUT I GOT THE STEAK POTATO BOWL AND NACHOS DELICIOUS WHEN YOU HOME AND ORDERED OUT BUT YOU CAN'T TELL HOME COOKED FOOD IJS IT'S DELICIOUS SUGGEST HEAD THAT WAY. 😋😊🥔 THANKS!“

“We got jets pizza tonight. It was BOMB! We got the square Detroit style pizza and wings, well done. Great customer service and an oddly amazing AI ordering system. 5 stars. The pizza inside was soft, doughy, and fresh, while the outside had crunch. The wings were flavorful, but not just the sauce, the chicken itself tasted good. The people at the restaurant were super nice, but we're just visiting from California, so that may be subjective (lol). We did take out and it was still amazing after the drive. I highly recommend this place.“

“The service at this store is top notch!!! It is always very clean, the staff, are always smiling and fun, and my food has always been fresh, made correctly, and never disappoints! Thank you, for maintaining excellence!“