21 Best Pizza Restaurants near Prospect

“Family owned and operated. Nicest people. Good food, especially the pizza and subs. Prices are a tad high, but what isn’t anymore. Highly recommend!!Dietary restrictions: They’re great about letting you substitute items out. ? Wheelchair accessibility: It's a drive-thru! Hahaha“

“We ordered from here for the first time since we were driving through, and I can’t believe it took us this long to try Sporty’s! It was amazing! Had a stuff crust (large) for the three of us and we barely touched half of it! Plus two gyros that had some amazing Tzatziki sauce! Love the food, and love the prices. Will def be back very soon!“

“We saw Berwick on Facebook and decided to check it out. I am glad we did the absolutely amazing. From the customer service too the food I truly can't say enough about this place Also I'll mention we are from Columbus it was just over an hr drive. It was beyond worth the drive. This trip will happen at the least once a month. Berwick please keep doing what your doing. I will add the Nashville hot with a stuffed crust is out of this world. To end this review I truly can't say enough amazing things you guys absolutely Rock.“

“Tubby's has the best pizza in town. I love to get anything there from a basic pepperoni and mushroom pizza to one loaded with nearly everything except anchovies. Their subs are off the charts delicious, too. It doesn't matter what you order here, it will be delicious.“

“Pizza is awesome and the garlic bread is great as well. The best part about pick up is drive thru. Also, here's something that's genius and underrated, the homemade ranch with is awesome by the way, comes in a container that is not circle. It's way easier to dip your entire slice which is great. Definitely recommend trying this place“

“Amazing little family and veteran owned joint. Fabulous food that caters to dietary restrictions. Genuinely kind and caring owners and staff who do all they can to not only serve up fresh and delicious food but also help out their community. Cannot recommend this place enough!Vegetarian options: There is a whole menu for vegan and dairy free options, and as a vegan myself, I was highly impressed with the variety.“

“The best Deep Dish pizza I ever had! I always get the Pepperoni deep dish pizza. Its only a take out location. No dine in. The pizzas are cut into 8 squares I believe and each one is a pretty big portion. The curst is nice and crunchy, which is what I look for on a deep dish pizza. 100% recommend!“

“The wait was around 30 minutes, which is reasonable for a Saturday evening. Everything was very delicious. We had arancini, then I had shrimp scampi. We're going to finish with crème brûlée. The staff was diligent about cleaning up finished dishes.I definitely recommend this place.“

“A great family-style restaurant in Magnetic Springs! So glad to see a new business in the area. The food isn't fancy, but it was delicious and the prices were very reasonable. My wife and I had sandwiches, which we both great! The pizza we saw looked wonderful as well - I'm gonna have to try that next time - and I will definitely be going back!“

“Fast, Friendly generous, and delicious! I appreciate that they have'nt raised prices, as alot of others have. I was surprised! I go all ready for sticker shock, as thats what I've had to get used to in the past few years! Left satisfied, and without buyer remorse for once.“

“Local sports pub with plenty of TV's to watch the games. Tried the pizza done the "Scoreboard way" (loaded) & it was VERY good! Service was a little slow at first, but our server was present without hovering later. Worth checking out if you're in the area.“

“A favorite of mine it has good pizza and subs. The wings though are the top thing I like to get. Biggest issue with the service is that they are usually so busy.Parking: Usually very busy on Friday and Saturday nights. Parking can be a premium.Kid-friendliness: The place is great and horrible for kids at the same time. It is great in that the food fits their style and they welcome them.It is horrible in that they are usually packed and the tables are jammed that it can be hard to move around with child carriers.“

“Second time here. Nice atmosphere. Friendly waitress. Pizza didn't seem the same from the first time but still decent. We hadn't been there for awhile. The appetizer size was a little disappointing for the price but was OK. No immediate plans to return but won't rule it out in the future.“

“Absolutely love Pizza Brothers. It's been my go-to for twenty years whenever I'm in the mood for pizza for myself. Their crust is airy with density, their sauce perfectly balanced between sweet and savory, and cheese has that nice mix between homemade pizza and knowing you couldn't duplicate it yourself.“

“Although i was missing some wings and had little sauce last night, when i called back today i had the best customer service. The employee was extremely kind and made things right immediately. Thank you for being one of the few places with this excellent service!! I wish I knew who the employee was but it was a young girl working night shift. She deserves to be in management position bc i cant say anything but great things about her! Please look up my order and see who put my credit on my account to make things right and give her kudos and let her know how thankful i am for her kindness. Its so sad to say, but good customer service these days are hard to come by. Theres very few that still have it and your location is beyond lucky to have an employee that cares ad much as she does about not only the business establishment itself, but their loyal customers as well ensuring they have a good experience and very empathetic on issues that im sure was purely a mistake as they were s bit busy. Thanks to her this location has became my favorite and by far and will always order here for now on. Please please. Please give this young lady the promotion and kudos she deserves!“

“Our daughter's Girl Scout troop offered Wildcat Pizza as a cookie booth location so we went with her and another troop member to work the booth tonight. It was snowing quite a bit and the place had a bunch of carry out and delivery orders! The staff were super kind to the girls, checking in on them often, and even buying a lot of cookies themselves. We ordered some pizza and garlic bread which were fantastic- the old world "cupping" pepperoni was perfectly crispy and the taco pizza had wonderful flavor with a little kick. Quick service, very attentive and kind staff, clean place. Definitely will come back to try more!“

“[CHECK OUR PROFILE FOR MORE]Hello everyone and welcome back in today’s review we are going to be reviewing HUNGRY HOWIE’S after enjoying a nice brunch today.Our review it’s based in multiple visits to the restaurant to be fair with our star’s review so we are going to grade it with honesty.What makes HUNGRY HOWIE’S so special and unique in comparison with others?:1. Waiting it’s just normal for a call for pick up or delivery.2. Great customer service.3. Food is great.4. Nice and clean facility.5. Free parking lots.6. Wheelchair access.7. Friendly service and they are always happy to serve.8. Not dining in.9. Pick up or delivery.If this review was helpful please hit ?? button and follow us for more.We Accept Tips, Invitations, Rewards, Blessings or a lot of Thanks by Rating our Reviews and Following Us.Blessings ??“

“My husband loves their Italian sub, and I love the fisherman's platter. Who'd think the best fish dinner I've ever had would come from a pizza drive-through? For carb conscious folks, the flounder in the Fisherman's Platter is thick and tasty and you can easily get the breading off all the different items. No need to season the bare fish -- they do something to give it flavor. Unfortunately, their walleye is too thin to peel the breading off. Salads are also generous and yummy.“

“I used the app for ordering and paying for my order. App is manageable. My order was ready exactly when it said it would be. Nice! I was going to use the drive-thru pickup window, but the line of cars wrapped around the building. I picked my order up by walking inside. I should've had faith but I didn't. Because by the time I had walked in picked up my pizza and walked back out to my vehicle, the line had already moved all the way around. Excellent job Donato's! The pizzas were perfect. Good staff. Pleasantly surprised.“

“My son and I were looking for a different pizza place to order from than our usual. I hadn't had east of Chicago for years and he never has had it. So he really wanted to try it. From placing the order to pickup everyone was very nice. We got the pan crust and it was excellent. The sauce was very good. We used a coupon the price was very good for 2 large 3 toppings was only 28.00. We will definitely be ordering from here again soon. Only problem I had was when trying to order on line the only option for payment was credit card. They should have a pay at store option. It was not a big deal though. Just called in the order. I usually do not like to call in an order due to back ground noise, but there was none when I ordered. I could hear him clearly.“

“Personal Perspective from a lifelong Marion resident: Seems like the better place for pizza in Marion Ohio. The pizza crust is awesome hot out of the oven, then my opinion is it becomes somewhat tough when it's cold which can lose points for the toughness in texture. Sauce is good though. I think slightly sweet like most Ohio square cut pizza places. For Marion it's a good solid recommendation. I don't eat in, but the pizza appears to be much better looking dining in too so don't pass up if that's your thing“