50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carlisle

“My wife and I stopped by yesterday evening (Tues. Aug08), as we’ve driven by a few times, and always wondered what they were like.It is a tad small (not their fault obviously), but they do offer many varieties of products considering that. We ended up leaving with a couple of items from the oven, some calabrese buns, a cold pre-made sandwich, some peanut butter, salt caramel, and empire cookies.Both my wife and I agree that everything we purchased was fantastic, and much better than we anticipated from a small location, late in the evening. The bread, and cookies were still very fresh. The sandwich was very good, and the patty not overly dry.And more importantly, the young lady who was looking after our order, and who then checked us out, was absolutely wonderful! Very polite, personable, and friendly. A pleasure to interact with.*Owners, I noted the date here so that you can hopefully make this specific colleague of yours aware of how we felt about the service she provided us.Hopefully we see her once again next time (not if), we stop by there.Take care, and continue doing what you’re doing.Mario“

“Our server Nick was amazing it was so busy there but he was sure to make sure we had everything we needed and when we need too ups. Go in and say hello to Nick he’s very kind“

“Prior to attending a Supertramp tribute band show in Milton, we met with friends at East Side Mario's for dinner. What a pleasant surprise with the professional yet friendly service by Prisila. Food was up to the quality of service as well!Definitely recommend.“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Tony G's Pizzeria, and I must say, it was truly the best pizza I've ever had! Tony's warm hospitality made us feel right at home, and his exceptional kindness was evident throughout our visit. The service was top-notch, with friendly and attentive staff. The pizza was freshly made with high-quality ingredients and generous toppings. And to top it all off, Tony even treated us to a complimentary pizza! I highly recommend Tony G's Pizzeria for a delicious and memorable dining experience.“

“ASIDE FROM OUR SURVICE BEING VERY POOR. THE FOOD AND DRINKS WERE AMAZING ? AND WELL WORTH ANOTHER VISIT ?“

“The food was delicious and the staff was great!“

“It was amazjng defiently try it out“

“Drove from Burlington to try this pizzs....DEFINITELY DID NOT disappoint. It's the way pizza should be made:)“

“thank you for your delicious pizza and wonderful service. since discovering you, we have not made a frozen pizza at home. thank you!“

“Risposta is a home away from home, nonas cooking when Nona doesn’t want to cook, a real hidden gem in the 905. I’m honestly surprised this isn’t a Michelin star restaurant the quality and care that goes into every plate. On top of multiple visits with family, we recently had them host a larger party and they went above and beyond, all of our guests had a great night, many have returned with their families since. Highly recommend this restaurant, the fresh pasta and any seasonal dish you can try.Vegetarian options: Too many, almost anything can be modified for your needs.Dietary restrictions: Pats a great chef and catered to both vegetarian and gluten allergies for our large party.Parking: Ample parking in the lotKid-friendliness: Playground out front for kids to burn their energy before dinner.“

“We stumbled over Gino’s Pizza and it was a great experience. We ordered a medium to eat in, and the pizza was amazing. But what impressed me most was the service - to all customers. Not just the high paying orders. Staff was kind and considerate to everyone who came in. Whether to buy just a slice or a to buy pop and use the washroom. Well done Gino’s staff! Highly recommend“

“Great food great service very friendly staff Bita“

“Had lunch here with a friend, The restaurant itself is super cute and I love the decor. The staff were super nice. Funny enough we didn't realize it was vegan at first(idk how we missed the signs lol), & we almost didn't notice either. The food was great, we both got a slice of "pepperoni" with a garlic dip and it was amazing. The only thing about this place is that it is a little on the pricey side for most menu items but the single slice (which is a decent size) is a decent deal at $5.“

“Fast and friendly service. pizza is always perfect.“

“Been ordering from here for a couple weeks. It's priced wonderfully, and the sauce, cheese (as long as you order extra cheese), and the pepperoni is very delicious but unfortunately the dough is just SO dry and bland.The staff are great. Location is convenient. It's just that dough that ruins it for me.“

“So far the best pizza I’ve had in Hamilton! Definitely will be ordering again!“

“Always consistent Za. Only time I got “cheesed” (ha) was when I ordered delivery cause I was tired after working a double and only live like 5 blocks aways so figured itd be quick; but instead I waited for other pizzas to be cooked then they drove 20 minutes passed me, made 2 stops, then came back so my food was cold and ended up taking over an hour and 30 mins to get after ordering when I live down the road and on route to their other stops.“

“Heard this pizza joint was under new management and taken up by a bunch of young lads; we came by to grab dinner for the family and were met with such warmth from the guys working there. The pizza was amazing, ample toppings, cooked to perfection, and the wings were very good as well! My folks loved the food; s/o to Denny for hooking us up! Thank you.See you soon :)“

“I asked the order taker if the Pizza slices were halal, just to be sure as they had a big HALAL sign on the window. However, I was told that the Pizza slices are not halal, and they only make it halal when ordered a whole pizza and you need to specify whether it's halal pepperoni/toppings etc. So please ensure you are asking for Halal toppings specifically.“

“Great pizza and really good wings too brampton location is number 1 spot for pizza and wings“

“Always great food and service! Was our first date location August 2011! Eat local ❤️“

“1st time trying this pizza!Feel the toppings could be a bit more generous as well dough cooked well done.I don't eat out often maybe 4 times a year at most.Would recommend the pizza it was not greasy with good taste.Service was excellent with a chill environment.Staff member on shift was professional in both appearance and demeanor,Polite spoke good English.“

“The food here is always good . But this time around , it was just too good to be true. We requested our bread sticks to be customized and they did it and did it so perfectly well. Hands down , the best pizza place in Milton. Highly recommended .“

“1st time there since 2019. Our server (Kaylie?) was attentive, sweet and friendly. The white wine sangria was to die for!!! I'll be back.“

“I decided on the chicken Parmesan pasta and the margarita pizza, and both dishes were absolutely delicious! The chicken was tender and flavorful, making each bite a delight. As for the margarita pizza, it was easily one of the best I've had. The crust was thin and crispy, with just the right amount of cheese. The fresh tomatoes, basil, and mozzarella were perfect.“

“Beautiful restaurant, great service, great food. Brussel sprouts are amazing!“

“friendly..quick..price....options....dips and dressings are just too good.“

“We were here for the first time on my birthday and we were thoroughly impressed! The food and drinks amazing and our server Kate was so busy but was able to give us amazing service !! We will definately be back.“

“Shy's always impresses in their quality and atmosphere. We headed there with friends and had a Celiac allergy at the table. The staff alerted the kitchen and ensured that all parties had that knowledge. Apps, main dishes, desserts - the food is phenomenal and the service is up to the task. Can't recommend this place enough!!!Dietary restrictions: Those if you with gluten sensitivities - this place is for you!!“

“The best mom and pop pizza in Hamilton hands down“

“While the pizza shop had a cozy atmosphere, I found the service a bit slow during peak hours. Additionally, while the toppings were fresh and flavorful, I felt that the crust could have been a bit more crisp. However, the staff was courteous and accommodating, and the variety of pizzas on offer was impressive. Overall, a decent spot for a casual meal, but there's room for improvement in terms of speed and texture."“

“A wonderful experience tonight at goodfellas. The bread bowl Gnocchi and bread bowl salad made the experience so unique and delicious. The bread was so incredibly fresh! Right out of the oven taste!!A wonderful experience tonight!! Highly recommend enjoying a nice dinner out. And our waitress Maria helped top our experience:) her recommendations were on point!!“

“The new management is really nice and provides excellent customer. I went in for the first time in a while just last week and I got to meet the new managers, they were very friendly and helpful with their customers. The best part is, all the meat toppings are now completely halal!“

“Girls at Barbies Formals always order a couple pizzas at a time. The supreme was excellent .“

“Staff are incredibly lovely! I came in looking for a hot and ready pizza, and had the pleasure of being served by Dave who was very friendly! He informed me that there were none available at the time of my arrival, however would have one prepared quickly for me. Service was quick, staff was wonderful - definitely recommend coming here if you’re looking for a budget friendly pizza!“

“Best pizza in Hamilton on Barton street. The staff were super friendly and the pizza was delicious with lots of toppings. The large pizza is very reasonably priced, it’s $18.50 tax included. You can’t go wrong going to this place for pizza and “

“What a great place. We are from out of town and were looking for something authentically italian while in Hamilton. At first glance it is a bit sketch due to the area and being on one of the main streets in the downtown area, but we were pleasantly surprised once inside. It is quaint and not the cleanest as the washrooms could use a little love, however the food and the service was fantastic. We had the ceasar salad (amazing - the bacon bits and croutons were still warm!), Manicotti and Tagliatelle Alfedo with shrimp, both extremely light and flavourful. The house wine was lovely for a house wine and the flat bread they bring at no charge was fresh and delicious. We will definately be back!“

“I’ve been ordering from this Dominos location for about 4 years now once a month and I absolutely love it. They always have amazing deals/coupons and even though a medium deep pan two topping pizza w/dipping sauce, including taxes, delivery fee and tip can be around $30, it’s absolutely worth it. I get light Alfredo sauce instead of regular tomato sauce and have feta cheese and bacon w/ Ranch dipping sauce. I’ve got so many friends and family loving this pizza. The staff is always friendly. The delivery is approx 20mins and they have a tracker to watch your order and delivery route. I only order pizza from these guys at this location. Keep up the amazing work. I also want to add that a couple times my pizza came, I notice a smiley face on my box. They recognize regular customers and it’s nice to see.“

“The chicken parm was amazing! And the white wine sangria went so well with it. Great place to catch up and have a nice meal with friends.“

“Amazing authentic Italian Small dining room, get there early Never had a bad meal there Whenever I’m in town it’s on the list“

“The staff are very friendly and accommodating. They read my funny requests and complete them as requested. Very nice people.Vegetarian options: Very nice and fresh.Dietary restrictions: I have Crohn’s disease and most of the time the vegetarian pizza I order may one of a handful of foods I can tolerate.“

“I ordered a medium poutine and cheeseburger with everything on it. The poutine was the best flavour I've had in a long time. It reminded me of the poutine my grandmother used to do when she had a restaurant in Newfoundland. Cheeseburger was tasty. Good prices, excellent service. Definitely coming back to try the pizza and for another poutine!“

“I’ve ordered from Weston several times! My typical order is a XL Pepperoni Pizza with extra sauce, it never fails to hit the spot! Always consistent and fresh.Service is also wonderful! Not many places like this left, with good consistent food for an affordable price.Reminds me of pizza days as a kid, in the best possible way! Give it a shot :)If you are feeling crazy, throw in an order of spring rolls they won’t disappoint you!“

“outstanding food and atmosphere. seriously; mouthwatering ingredients combined into magic that you can eat in a beautiful dining room or on a heated patio“

“I order pizza from pizza pizza .it was an amazing experience .pizza was too hot and delicious.I recommend everyone to visit there .“

“This pizza store is absolutely fabulous my coworkers and I at Queens Garden long-term care love it“

“Excellent service and amazing food“

“Great pizzas and fresh good quality ingredients“

“Definitely unique pizza taste, i will say i love the cheese they use i always add chedder but i forgot to ask for light sauce...there sause leaves a bit of a spice kick on the after taste but i find if i ask for light sause u barley notice it!! Ive always ate there cheesy bread and its amazing!“

“Today was the first time trying this, and the first thing I noticed when I entered was how clean their store is, there’s no left over spills or splashes on the walls, pizza toppings on the floor, etc. the overall facility was clean and tidy!The pizza, where do I start, I ordered the Honey Heat and added Italian sausage. I ended up eating the entire Medium sized pizza, it was so damn good. As someone who likes spicy, but not burning this was perfect. Very well made and staff is extremely polite.I would share a photo, but there’s nothing left lol“