10 Best Ice Cream Shops near Fort Erie

“Was visiting the area while looking for a property for a client. Treated ourselves to ice cream. WOoooooWWWWWW. Amazing premium product. Can’t wait to be back. Lovely sweet ladies working and very pleasurable experience. A MUST if driving in the area.“

“Delicious Perry's ice creams & custards, Dole whips, customizable sundaes, best milkshakes in town. Any ice cream can be made into a milkshake at Nicky's.Nick himself is a hands owner, friendly, welcoming & eager to please his customers.Nick has free popcorn at all times as well as free books for anyone to read & take home! Giant back patio, dog friendly, reasonable prices for largeservings.“

“the decorations inside are also cute, love any led sign. friendly and fast service. i purchased cakes to gift to my friends and they all LOVED them. i believe i got an assortment of whatever they had that day (red velvet cookies, and cream are some i remember off the top of my head). personally i am obsessed with their banana pudding because i think it tastes just like the pudding from magnolia nyc. a little far of a drive but i would say it's worth it (from amherst) just for their banana pudding. i usually get to go but would recommend sitting down in one of their booths if you have the time!“

“Big parking lot! Lots on the menu too choose from they even have a ice cream nachos consist of vanilla custard topped with chocolate syrup cookie crunch, sprinkles and so much more!! I got a Perry's dairy-free peanut butter cookies & cream with big pieces of cookies soooo damn yummy! On a sugar cone nice & crunchy! The service is quick too you order in one line and pick up at another. Location is great too, the ambiance is outside and they have tables or a grass area to sit at, if you have a blanket but definitely a must too check out.“

“My partner couldn't stop singing the praises of beef on weck. We were in Niagara Falls at the end of September, and we came out here based on the reviews. We did not realize that they are about 10 miles from downtown Niagara Falls. It was so good, we came back the next day. They are extremely well worth the drive. A nice simple place, you can order outside in the front of the building, or inside. They have seating both areas. Everybody was friendly, and the prices were reasonable. They have won awards for their beef on Weck, and I can see why. You can get it with anywhere from 2 1/2 ounces for a lighter eater,, to a whopping 8 ounces of roast beef. The roast beef was tender and wonderfully flavored, the jus that they dip the top half of the roll in was heavenly, and I loved the kummelweck roll with the caraway seeds and salt. I can see why my partner is always singing the praises of this sandwich, and why it is a mainstay of the Buffalo area, For dessert, both times my partner had the frozen custard. The first time, I had the canoli ice cream. Delicious! It actually had pieces of canoli in it. The second time, I had the custard, and it was creamy and delicious. Much better than your standard soft serve. They are closed for the season, but they will reopen in March of 2024. . The next time we are in the area, we would stop by in a heartbeat. Thank you!!“

“I had accidentally placed an online order at a wrong location. I was totally stuck not being from the immediate area. Justin the manager understood my situation and handled it quickly for me.Customer service like this is RARE these days. That man deserves his kudos.“

“Utterly charming. I've lived on Grand Island for five years and have only just heard of Casey's Cabana. It's a very nice little hot dog/burger stand on the Niagara River, with seating on a dock. It has a delightful "river rat" atmosphere.They offer much more than burgers and hot dogs, however, and they have ice cream, as well. Best of all, the staff is very friendly and welcoming. It doesn't hurt, either, that the prices are ridiculously low. It reminded me a bit of Reid's in Lockport, only with a much nicer riverfront location.A very nice alternative to other similar places in the area. I'll be back again and again. I only wish I had discovered this place a long time ago.“

“This is such a cute place, we tried the wine and Gelato pairing event and we loved it. The place has a chill vibe with beautiful decor and the Gelato is very tasty. This is a versatile Cafe style place offering drinks, small bites, and of course a lot of gelato choices. It has a nice amount of seating, both tables and at the bar. We really enjoyed our time there and can't wait to experience the next pairing event.“

“Just an absolutely beautiful storefront on Delaware avenue and Victoria boulevard. Smackdab in the middle of this lovely little village. This place has the best local candy/sweets by far, maybe even in the whole country. That sponge candy though!“

“I visited Forno E Gelato on 3/8/2024 to check out what they had since we were early for our reservation at Frank Primo's next door. The gelato case was well stocked and there were several enticing items in the pastry case. As I asked whether they made Italian almond amaretti cookies, Rachel, the owner came in and we had a pleasant discussion about them, she looked them up on her phone on the spot, and forwarded to the pastry chef for consideration. I recounted my fond memories of visiting my sister in Brooklyn and enjoying almond amaretti, which often entailed extensive negotiations for the last one! Anyway, I purchased pistachio amaretti and Grandma whites cookies for later, and consumed salted caramel gelato (made by Forno E Gelato) at the end of dinner at Franki Primo's. The salted caramel gelato was excellent, with a nice ribbon of caramel through it. It's my favorite flavor, so I have a lot to compare it against. Forno E Gelato's salted caramel was in the top 3 best ones I've ever had (in competition with Siena in Snyder and a place in Italy)! The pistachio amaretti were also excellent with the perfect soft chew and great nutty flavor. Grandma whites cookies were good with a slight anise flavor, and just not a cookie I would normally gravitate to or rave over anyway. I'll definitely be back for the salted caramel gelato, the pistachio amaretti, and (hopefully) some almond amaretti!“