50 Best Italian Restaurants near York

“Visited all the way from Oakville last night & highly recoomend this place. The service was top tier & she was so kind & friendlyyyy 🙏🏻 i was bit skeptical if it would live up to it’s hype & glad to say it didn’t disappoint. Wish there was better parking so we could have stayed longer.

We love d the half & half juice & the pasta with aglio olio had the perfect sweetness to it. It really was cooked to perfection. Blesssssssss.“

“Uzma provided excellent service during my visit to Pizza Pizza. She was attentive, polite, and made sure everything was perfect. The pizza was fresh, delicious, and served quickly. Truly a great experience thanks to her professionalism and care.“

“Came here on a bakery tour with friends.

Tiramisu cup is excellent. I like that the lady fingers are dipped enough to have a coffee flavour but are not completely mush and have some texture to it.

The cannoli is delicious and packed with that chocolate chip cream. The lemon zest within really comes through and is refreshments.

The chocolate truffle is light and refreshing.

I would come here again and recommend it.

Parking: Smal 10 space parking lot infront of the store.“

“By far the most selection of vegan pizzas in the city and they taste amazing. I especially am a big fan of the vegan pesto base, and the diverse vegan meat alternatives options at hand. the best vegan garlic bread, especially when vegan cheese is added. they are in my top 3 choices and the second place I've come across with vegan pesto- that's a rarity! so many thanks to their great efforts at making amazing vegan pizzas!“

“I have visited the restaurant several times, and I can confirm the food is delicious, always well served, good portions (I have attached pictures, keep in mind some are half doses of the requested food). The customer service is excellent, super friendly and very professional.
I will be coming back, my go to restaurant.

Highly recommend.

Parking is available across the street, huge parking lot.“

“They offer an awesome range of fresh pizzas. Ekta was very friendly, she gave me nice pizza deal. Prices are reasonable and the spot is always kept clean. I got 2 pizza and they tasted delicious.
I wish they had a bigger dining area and parking. 😊“

“My partner and I stumbled upon Pazza and I’m so glad we did. It’s a bit of a 90s time capsule in the best way possible: charming, reliable, and full of character.

We shared a salad, a wood-fired Roman-style pizza (thin, crisp, with beautifully blistered edges), and a calamari appetizer that was super fresh and tender. We got a tartufo for dessert. We also shared a half-litre of wine, and my partner had a beer. The total, including a 20% tip, came to $115 which is exceptional value for Toronto.

The service was attentive, the specials were thoughtful, and the atmosphere was relaxed but welcoming. We didn’t try the pasta this time, but we’re already planning to come back for it.

Nice to see families dining in and clearly regulars who’ve been coming for years. Highly recommend if you’re in the area and want affordable, well-made Italian in a casual setting.“

“First class from beginning to end. We were lucky to reserve seats at the chef’s bar and see the detail and care that goes in to every dish. Great chat, buzzing atmosphere and fantastic food. A memorable evening ❤️“

“Second time there to having dinner with my husband by Dior’s retreat. Very thankful and grateful“

“The food is beyond amazing!! And they have a great selection of desserts as well. ✨“

“Just had to share my amazing experience! I tried the Massive Meatball and wow, it was absolutely awesome! 🤩 Seriously, one of the best I've ever tasted. If you're looking for something truly delicious, you've got to give it a try. Definitely a must-have for any foodie adventure! #foodie #meatballmagic #delicious“

“We had fabulous service. Our waiter Tim was fantastic. Very attentive and wonderful personality Would highly recommend going there if you are in Toronto“

“I ordered the wedding soup take out. $7.99 but the paper cup they give you is minuscule. Should be at least double the size for the price they charge. What a rip off. Too bad because I like there food overall“

“Wow it was so good experience the service was good the good was so good it was my first time there all I can say I do recommend to try it my boys meet the chef very friendly“

“I dined here this evening and the food was soooo good. I find that the quality between restaurants vary, but this location always hits!! My server, Ana was AMAZING. She was so sweet and her recommendations were great! I'll definitely be back soon!“

“Amazing service and amazing food every single time. H“

“I can never get tired of this place. I really enjoy their menu. Great atmosphere, great weight staff overall, I have a great experience visited the Sherway Gardens location first followed by the location by Colossus Both locations left me with great experience overall and will return again!“

“Amazing food from a family run restaurant, large portions with inspiration from Italy. Tony is amazing!“

“Amazing food! Will be back!“

“Exceptional food and Service every time .... Heart and Soul goes into each plate 🍴“

“Food is really great, clean and hygienic“

“The vibe and atmosphere was very nice. Most of the food items were enjoyed, except for the pork loin. Pork loin was deep fried, it was so dry that it's hard to chew. Items that we have enjoyed include the grilled calamari, and the pasta.“

“Excellent food and incredible, friendly service. Highly recommend.“

“Tout est vraiment très bon!“

“Amazing pasta and pizza!“

“I had a lovely birthday dinner date here, everything, from the food, to the service, to the atmosphere, was amazing. To start we got the peach bellini slush and strawberry aperol sour, both of which were tasty and refreshing, and did not taste like alcohol. For an appetizer, we shared a plate of fried calamari rings, which was scrumptious. The marinara dipping sauce paired well and the acidity cut the greasiness of the oils. Onto the main dishes, the vodka rigatoni was exceptional, and the portion was quite big! I loved the sauce and the small chunks of meat, although I did find the cheese on top a bit strange. The mushroom pizza also tasted great, however, I would probably recommend getting pasta over pizza here, since that seems to be their niche. For dessert, we ordered a tiramisu, which was exceptional, probably the best tiramisu I've had from a restaurant. NOTE: be careful when scooping the first bite, because we both choked on the cocoa powder, which was very funny. Overall, I absolutely loved my experience dining here, and I would love to come back with my girl friends on a night out, I feel like that would be an ultimate vibe. I also want to come check out their happy hour so I can try some of their drinks for $10.“

“Good food and service, nice atmosphere 🍷“

“Today we celebrated my father’s 90th birthday and there is no better place to celebrate than at Tovico! The food is great, the staff is very professional and make you feel very welcoming. Our guests commented that they would be coming back soon making us feel that they also had a great experience. Thank Riccardo, Tessa, Leo and staff for a great time. See you soon, Mary“

“Quite simply - this is truly a great neighbourhood retreat ! Staff are maxing and the owner Sina has a way of making everyone feel like they are a VIP REGULAR !“

“We went to Smoke and Mirrors Gastropub last Saturday with a couple of friends, and it was great experience from start to finish. The staff were friendly, attentive, and clearly passionate about what they do. The food was fantastic - creative dishes with fresh ingredients, nice flavours and beautiful presentation. Every plate felt thoughtfully crafted. The deserts were top-notch. It's rare to find a place that nails both food and service like this. We'll definitely be coming back soon -a real great find.“

“I have been living in Canada for seven years, and during this time, we’ve tried over 100 restaurants. When it comes to service, Padella Italian Eatery truly stands out as the best. From the moment we walked in, we were treated with warmth and genuine hospitality. The food was absolutely delicious, and the service went far beyond our expectations.
We’ll definitely be returning!“

“This ain't a sandwich, it's two meals in one.

The car park is a bit tight considering all the traffic but worth it to get in. The place was compact but had a tonne of character, with a proper spread of Italian goodies. The service was quick, wonderful and even made modifications on the fly just to up the flavor. That's some wonderful service.

I got the Joey D's specialty and man it's special. Those cold cuts were thin and stacked so they basically melted away. The olive spread was almost like a muffuletta, bringing that tang in there. The bread was soft but strong enough to hold everything together. Fresh veggies. Right amount of Mayo. Absolutely no complaints.

Definitely a spot to hit up if you're into some genuinely good food!“

“Great food excellent service very attentive even the owner came to our table super friendly and great atmosphere Drew M Albuquerque New Mexico“

“Great dinner. Definitely recommended“

“Via Allegro has been one of my favorite restaurants for many, many years. In 2022, they changed ownership, but the warm, family-like atmosphere remains as special as ever. Every visit is memorable, and last night was no exception. My girlfriend and I celebrated a milestone, and the staff went above and beyond to make it an unforgettable experience. Our server, Alex, made sure every detail was perfect (it’s the second time we've been lucky enough to have him). From the personalized reservation card on the table to the exquisite wine selection, served at the perfect temperature and topped up at just the right moment, everything was flawless. And, of course, the food was absolutely delicious. Thank you to Alex and Mohamad Fakih for making our evening truly magical. Via Allegro continues to set the bar for exceptional service and dining.“

“Best vegan food ever! Every time we visit Toronto, we stop for a great evening❤️“

“Went on a Friday night without a reservation. Put my name on a list and got a table for two after about 45 minutes (consistent with what the host said).

Service was great. Didn’t catch the name of our server but he was helpful during ordering, friendly, and the right level of attentive.

We got 4 dishes, and overall the food was excellent and very reasonably priced given the portion sizes.

Giant meatball (5/5) - amazing, sauce was spot on, very generous portion
Pearled couscous (3.5/5) - a bit underdone and one of the mussels tasted off, otherwise flavor was great
Ossobuco: (4.5/5) - creamy and decadent, would order again
Beet salad (4/5): Not a big beet fan but this was still good, would have liked a bit more goat cheese

Atmosphere was nice and lively. Music and general volume was a touch loud, but not impossible to hold a conversation. This would be a fun place to share a meal with a group of 4-6.“

“They had amazing food! Their pasta is absolutely incredible I would definitely eat there again! Service was amazing and it was just an enjoyable time! Their desserts taste amazing as well!“

“My husband and I recently visited this restaurant on a whim. It's safe to say, that we had a great time, the staff were amazing and always attentive. The drinks and food were delicious! I highly recommend you try this place out if you're looking for somewhere quiet to have dinner or drinks or if you're just looking for somewhere new to try!“

“Westend Grill – Always a Hit!

I’ve been coming to Westend Grill for a couple of years now, and it’s one of those places that never lets you down. The food here just hits the spot every single time.

The chicken wings are perfectly crisp on the outside and tender inside — and that honey garlic sauce? Absolute perfection. Sweet, sticky, and addictive in the best way possible. The steak pasta feels like pure comfort — creamy, rich, and packed with flavor in every bite. Then there’s the Angus beef burger, which is simply next-level — juicy, smoky, and built just right. And the chicken parmesan? It’s got that real homemade Italian feel — golden crust, melty cheese, and just the right tang in the sauce.

The place itself is spotless, the vibe is relaxed, and the team always makes you feel welcome — like you’re part of the regular crowd.

Westend Grill has mastered the balance of great food, clean atmosphere, and genuine hospitality.

One small request though — please bring back the Chicken Skewers Sauté! That dish was legendary and is truly missed.“

“We selected this restaurant based on its location but not knowing anything about it. We were very happy with our choice and had an amazing evening. The starters we chose were burrata with beets and carpaccio di crevo. Both were very good. We then had linguine con asttice and upon the server's recommendation, lamb. These dishes were flavorful and beautifully presented. What made the night even better was the fantastic service. Marty from Sudbury was amazing! He made solid food and drink recommendations along with engaging in great conversation. After trying a number of restaurants on College St, this one is our favourite. We definitely will be returning!“

“Great food great atmosphere 👏🍷“

“Food is great and reasonably priced ,great drinks and the staff are excellent ,well trained and have a laugh with you .The manager made me a Caesar (cocktail) and converted me …. Will definitely be back“

“Excellent food. and very friendly staff. The mushroom salad, veal marsala, and the short ribs were fantastic. We highly recommend this restaurant.“

“nice restaurant. food was good. my half rack of lamb was good although I have had better at that price. it was sitting in a very salty sauce..the waiter took it back and put my food on a clean plate without the sauce. didn't even offer to pay my espresso for the trouble. a little crowded as well. my amarena ricotta cheesecake was the highlight.“

“Thanks for another fantastic evening. We really enjoyed our meal the food is always exceptional. The restaurant was really busy and the service was still outstanding. Well done everyone. 👏“

“Awesome Italian Restaurant. Authentic friendly staff. Great lunch or dinner options.“

“My husband and I recently had a fantastic experience at Ciao Roma, which stands out from the typical pizza joints. The unique pay-by-weight system allows you to sample multiple varieties of pizza without committing to a full slice or pie. This feature adds a delightful twist to your dining experience.

We tried four different types of pizza, and each one was phenomenal. The crust was wonderfully crispy, and the flavors were vibrant and well-balanced. Additionally, we indulged in a sandwich filled with prosciutto, arugula, and cheese, which was equally delicious.

Overall, Ciao Roma exceeded our expectations, and I can't wait to return for more culinary adventures. Highly recommended for anyone looking to enjoy a diverse pizza experience!“

“Ostaria Giula has the most amazing staff our server was Giancarlo he was super amaziOstaria Giulia hang with great recommendations. He was very knowledgeable about all the food and was able to suggest dishes for food allergies. I was so excited to go to our first Michelin star restaurant to celebrate a birthday and an anniversary. I was hoping to be able to meet Rob Rossi but I didn't just meet him, he was aware of our celebration and he took the time to come and great us .....I am a foodie so I was truly star struck. David Minicucci went above and beyond getting us a perfect table and ensuring we had a wonderful celebration. Thank you all at Ostaria Giulia from the chefs to servers and bar tender and the wonderful sommelier who suggested the perfect wine. We had an amazing time that I will remember forever. BRAVO!!!!!“