Custom Cakes near Monroeville, PA

“The cupcakes, snickerdoodles and chocolate chip cookies were good. The icing was more whipped than I'd like. It's a quaint shop; stocked well with so many choices; including gluten free items. Parking can be a little tricky, if an event is going on next door.“

“Approved by my first generation Sicilian dad! Got him a 1/2 pound of cookies (sesame and pignoli were favorites) for his birthday. Service was great and prices are fantastic. I can't believe I've been in Pittsburgh for years without knowing about this place- can't wait to go again!“

“I ordered a Neapolitan pastry and it was fantastic. A very refreshing and surprisingly light breakfast.The staff was very familial and treats their regulars with great care. If I'm ever back in the area I will definitely stop by again to sample some more. Strawberries seemed fresh and the cream was wonderful.“

“Cakes by Colby made what seemed like a difficult choice a super easy one! From moment one walking in the door, you could see the artistry in her work and where her specialties lay. The tasting was a delight, and if anything we ate waaaaay too much while were there, but it was all so incredibly good! Fast forward to the wedding day, everything went off without a hitch and the cake was absolutely gorgeous! She took reference images we provided and went above and beyond, it was elegant without being pretentious and truly lovely on top of being delicious as well. Our guests raved about it too. Can’t recommend Fran and Cakes by Colby enough!!“

“My 1st visit. And the Cinnamon Scone was the best. We also partaked on chocolate chip cookies, salted caramel cookie, apple streudel and brownies. Kim, A. Mgr was helpful and welcoming. All the staff were nice and could help with confirming ingredients. We will be back!!“

“Easy pre-ordering. Friendly staff. Lots of parking. Clean store. Lots of variety. Reasonable prices compared to other local ice cream shops. My cake was very tasty. The only things is less of a complaint and more of a suggestion but the custom cakes are sort of plain. Nothing that really makes the cakes stand out amongst the rest but it sure was delicious!“

“I will always LOVE Prantl's - a different location did my wedding cake! I was in this neighborhood, saw a Prantl's and knew I had to go in. I grabbed a burnt almond torte bar and a salted caramel cookie - and both were absolutely delicious. I will say, it seems everyone at this location was new and was being trained, as they were a bit slower to check folks out - having to call on others to get help. However, I'm hopeful those small things will be worked out with additional training!“

“Good ice cream, some of the best on Forbes. Pretty good price for what you get but it's still pricy. I got the Oreo Ice Cream and it had what I think was vanilla ice cream but there was some blue ice cream in there, I don't think that's normal but maybe I'm wrong.“