5 Best Ice Cream Shops near New Oxford

“Great little ice cream shop. Loads of different flavors. Ice creams, water ices, novelties, snacks, agua fresca and more all great quality. My wife had the rum raisin ice cream which was excellent. I had something called a Michelagua...mango ice cream on the bottom covered w lime water with another scoop of mango ice cream on top. Then a mango popsicle is inserted and the rim is coated in a fruit syrup. The whole whole thing is then sprinkled with a salty spicy seasoning. Really different, refreshing and delicious. Good service, reasonable prices, great selection. Highly recommend!“

“One of the best ice cream places I've ever been to! Staff are always kind & let you try new flavors! The ice cream is creamy, soft serve but with streaks of soft fudge or Caramel and other mix-ins like cookie dough, strawberry, etc. Absolutely delicious! ?They also have options for dairy-free, sugar-free, etc.“

“The BEST ice cream place. The owner is a magician when it comes to creative (but never weird) flavors. Regardless of season there is always a reason to go but then again, who needs a reason to get ice cream? Well nobody but she has flavors for Easter, Christmas in July and Shark Week. My personal favs are the fall flavors (caramel apple, cinnamon roll) in a pumpkin cone. Then there is the epic creation of her husband "Marry Me". The renovated school house makes a perfect destination to get your creamiest decadent dessert. Her special for the recent solar eclipse was really cool too.“

“A friend and I went to eat here on a Tuesday for lunch. It was very full indicating that the service and food must be great. We waited only about 5 minutes to be seated. We received our menus, orders our drinks and food, and only had to wait 15 or so minutes on the food to be made. Fast friendly service for how busy the place was. Good food as well. Recommended.“

“We wanted an ice cream treat on are way home after touring Gettysburg. There are always high-end ice cream shops to splurge on but if you stop at York Street Treats you get great soft serve ice cream at a reasonable price. Our chocolate dipped vanilla soft serve cones were outstanding. Nice location, easy to get in and out with good parking. Best of all it is a very affordable. Stop by and get your soft serve at York Street Treat's.“