15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Nicholson

“We recently did an order for a birthday party. We got a variety of pizzas and each one was great. Everyone at the party thoroughly enjoyed the pizza. Hot wing pizza was my favorite! We called a few hours ahead and the food was hot and ready at pick up. Staff were very friendly and respectful. Great pizza shop for a small town.“

“great hoagies. a variety of items for last minute items quick service“

“Just love the place.Food is excellent“

“We enjoyed the wing bites and the pizza! great prices and great service!“

“Fantastic & accommodating people! On Thanksgiving day, hours after the main event meal was over, my 5-year-old was hungry. We were renting a nice lake house at Acre Lake for the holiday, so although we had TONS of Thanksgiving leftovers, there was nothing other than that for him to eat.I remembered the pizza at Acre Lake Store nearby was good, so I tentatively called to see if they were open. They were! Although they were only serving Thanksgiving dinner, I hoped they could maybe sell me something he would eat. The woman on the phone that I spoke to was extremely helpful, & suggested a few things. We ended up getting bread, cheese, & butter to make grilled cheese for him. Evening saved! She even added a bag of macaroni, which he ate as well. Great experience, nice people - above & beyond experience.“

“I'm typically not one to complain and we have order numerous times without issue, however tonight's order I feel needed to be brought to management attention and this is the only way I know to do so. We could not get the two orders of cheese bread sticks because they did not have "the stuff" to make them. I would have at minimum appreciated a call to offer a substitution or to place an additional order as it was being counted on as part of our meal. It was not busy and we were the only order so I can not even give that as a possible excuse. Additionally, our pizza was not even cut! I feel as though the 15% tip on a takeout order, at minimum deserves your attention enough to cut the pizza. Though we will order again, if this becomes a routine thing, we may have to take our order to one of the other equally close places.“

“just because it's the only spot in town doesn't mean you're settling! get ready for a good time! a friendly reminder that local bars have charm and charisma you just can't find anywhere else. they got a pool table for groups and a gambling machine for the solo visitor. and an electronic jukebox too! chairs and tables inside, and a fireplace warming the place in winter, make a cozy, intimate gathering place for all members of the local community. the great food is made upstairs and handed down to the bartender through a hole in the floor. wing nights can't be missed. tables and chairs and smoking being a social activity makes hanging outside fun and relaxing. excited to see they do carry the much anticipated arizona hard iced tea in all three flavors! highly addictive i must say.“

“We LOVE their pizza and order quite often. Last week, our pizza wasn't what we ordered. They compensated our whole order this week after I called to tell them of the error instead of just comping the pizza. Thank you so much Vincenzo's! Definitely recommend!“

“Awesome to hit Js pizzeria and then hang out at lake Winola“

“I ordered 3 medium pizzas and 2 sides. When I got there they had only made 2 pizzas. I asked about my 3rd pizza and they realized they didn't make it, do they took the food back to keep it warm, made the pizza and gave it to me for free.Great customer service here!“

“Staff was super friendly. Had chicken bacon ranch pizza and was very good! Also had mild wing bites and they were very good as well! First time here last week. Have heard good things about their wing bites and hot wing pizza. Maybe next time. ??‍♀️“

“The food is great. But the lady at the front counter is extremely rude & bothered by anyone that isn’t getting a premade hoagie. Second time that I have been there & she was rude. I don’t think I will be getting lunch from there again.“

“Will definitely be ordering again !!! Pizza was fantastic .“

“Super excellent food. The only thing better than the food was the service. Our waitress, Corrine was very accommodating. Even though they did not have a specific cocktail we ordered, she improvised and it was better than we expected. We give 5 stars ! We'd give 10 but the app didn't go that high ! We'll be back !“

“Great food and good service, never been disappointed with food or service.“