19 Best Bakeries near Old Forge

“There’s a reason why nearly every place in the region that serves pizza (and doesn’t make their own dough) uses their shells. In fact, Agostini’s shells are the main reason why so many bars and restaurants are able to serve quality pizza in the region. They also make it easy to make great pizza at home. Very good and inexpensive.“

“Amazing vegan food! I love the desserts and I'm not even a sweets person. Her teas are amazing. She really adds a spice of love to her food. The salad is my favorite and the spicy mushroom tacos.Vegetarian options: Vegan & vegetarian“

“If I recommend it, their sweets are wonderful. But what I don't recommend is the poor attention of the girl with blonde hair or blonde highlights! Yesterday he treated me contemptuously and that is no way to treat customers. I asked her if she was okay because of the way she was treating me badly and knocking over the display cases, and she told me that I was okay. I mean, I feel like I disrespected her as a customer because I was placing an order with her. If she is not willing to attend to various requests, I will quit her job. For my part, I will not go to the store again while she is there. They have to be a little more careful when hiring people in their businesses and give them customer service courses.“

“Visited this location on a Saturday afternoon. There were a lot of customers since it was the weekend. The employees were nice and did a great job at keeping the crowd moving. I ordered through the app in store and received my cookies in less than 5 minutes. The space is clean and the cookies were great as usual.“

“Lynn Sandy’s is the best bakery in NEPA. Even at the busiest times they do it without an issue. We just picked up our Easter order. There was such a large crowd, but they kept it moving and every employee was kind and patient. Their baked goods are high quality, as is their staff and pricing.“

“I went to Black Cat Bakery to have a cake made for my surprise wedding as well as cookies made in the likeness to my three dogs. Everything turned out beautifully and they were delicious too. The girls that work there are super friendly. Try their whipped coffee too!“

“Such kind people!! First time coming here with my partner and we were in awe looking at everything they had! We almost couldn’t choose lol! Luckily the lady was able to read my mind and let us sample CHOCOLATE RUGULAH!! MY FAVORITE. Definitely gonna be back soon I recommend them for all your pastry needs!!!“

“The Drip Coffee House is conveniently located in EG with plenty of parking! Delicious bagels, pastries, parfait cups, and the Best coffee in town! Just a Huge variety of food options! Steve, Sarah and Staff are always Friendly and respectful! The Drip is a comfortable and clean Coffee Shop to invite your family and friends!“

“I purchased the Resist cake for my birthday. It was cannoli inside with buttercream frosting. Not only did the proceeds go to a great time in such a crappy time in our country’s history, but it was a tasty cake, too. Very moist and absolutely delicious! Thanks for being a part of my birthday and standing up for women’s rights!“

“My daughter ordered a cake for her sister's birthday and it was delicious. She ordered a dark chocolate cake with chocolate mousse filling and peanut butter icing and although we only served 8 people, the cake was large enough to serve 20. Very moist, beautifully decorated, and it was very reasonably priced...competitive in price with the local grocery store, but much higher quality. We will definitely order again!“

“Great old fashioned bakery with a nice selection of breads, pastries and cookies. The hard rolls (less than $1 each!) looked phenomenal as did the bagels. Since it was close to St. Patrick's Day, they had Irish soda bread and also hot cross buns available. There were also biscuits with raisins in them. They looked fine! Unfortunately, there is no seating in the store, it is simply a store. I could see this being a nice place to come for a morning bagel or hard roll with butter. They just aren't set up to do so. I got an eclair and it was excellent, large and had a great ganache frosting. It was gone quite quickly. They also had a nice selection of cookies, danish and turnover pastries. You can buy rolls separately or in a bag. They have dinner rolls, too. If you're looking for "Texas toast" this is where you can get that kind of bread. Other kinds of bread that they have: Multigrain, Rye (unseeded), a pulled(?) white, and others. There was much more than I recall. Definitely worth the trip. Prices were reasonable and I'm sure the quality is better than you'll find at a grocery store.“

“Bakery Delite is a HUGE bakery with the most variety of baked goods that I've ever visited (cakes, breads, cookies). EVERYTHING looks good, smells good, tastes FABULOUS! So fresh. Handicapped accessible building. A very big parking lot with a few handicapped designated parking spots. You will not be disappointed by the quality of service or food. A++Parking: Huge parking lot but only a few handicapped accessible spaces, and they are very busy!“

“The staff here was very nice, the cheesecake was delicious and very good texture! I would love to say that I will be back soon but I think 7$ a small slice is way too much. I’m surprised no one else mentioned that in their reviews. It’s 40$ for a whole cake at about 12 slices? That’s 84$ at 7 per slice so if you can only charge 40$ I think 4-5$ per slice is more reasonable and prob bring in more business! Also no one I mentioned it to even knew the store was there and frequent that plaza often. Maybe a large neon sign and an arrow would help stand out against the flashy nail place signs. Good luck in your business, you have a great product , yummy flavors and such creativity.“

“I was recently in the bakery and did not realize that my credit cards and driver’s license fell out of my purse. Either the owner or an employee drove them to my house!!! Restores your faith in humanity!! What a great gesture! Thank you again! PS…. The bread is fantastic!“

“Absolutely delicious cheese danish - so terrific I ate them all before I could take a picture because they were so so good. They’re cheap too! Everything is 1$ so who can complain?? Will be my go to shop for pastries while at the Southside Farmers Market!“

“Ordered cookies for a graduation party. The cookies were fantastic. Everyone loved them. They were freshly made and decorated perfectly. Pilgers’ Pastries was very easy to work with, great communication, honest, hardworking family. Thank you so much for making the cookies for our party. Totally recommend Pilgers’ Pastries.“

“Small bakery, big surprise! Nice lady behind a counter full of goodies. Packaged cookies, pies in the cooler, loaf-sized coffee cakes! Picked up two danish, one cinnamon swirl, and an apple walnut strudel (?) for $10! WHAT!?!? That's insane! Danish are buttery, strudel was amazing! I'll be back.“

“I'll note they are my cousin's so I will be forward, but the food I purchased was delicious, a bunch of sweets, Italian bread, and some pizza shells (crusts) and I devoured it all! Also vaguely remember a wedding cake for a family wedding when I was a child, there was an orange cream section and “

“Stopped a couple blocks away for lunch and happened to notice Ermie’s Cake Pops!I happen to know a 10 year old that absolutely loves cake pops. So I bought a bunch of different varieties for everyone to enjoy!They were absolutely delicious and everyone loved the cute figures & the decorations!I hear the hours can be hit & miss, so do call ahead to avoid cake pop disappointment.“