“I always enjoyed the previous Black Cap in Red Lion and have patiently waited for the new venue. I decided to go to the NEW Black Cap now on N. Franklin in Red Lion a few times before I share my review. I was not disappointed! Very nice menu and GREAT BEER list. I just love their lager and hefeweizen beers. We have tried several menu items, and we truly enjoy the smash burgers and the grilled cheese sandwich. Last night I tried the beef stew soup which was very tasty. We have been treated extremely well during all our visits; service was excellent even when the Black Cap was at capacity. It is always a great night when you get great food and great service at a very nice local Brewing Company. If you are in the Red Lion area, please drop in at the Black Cap Brewing Company for some great food and beer.“
“03/15/24 Arrived right at 11:30 for a 'girls' lunch .... promptly seated... 1 person had their chicken salad sandwich lunch special - no problem to exchange roll for a small bed of lettuce and choose different side dish to accommodate special diet needs. Chicken salad was delicious! .... Other person had the French Onion Soup - also delicious! ... incredible value. Good atmosphere... Very clean... Friendly service.“
“Found this place while in town for a gymnastics meet. Great place, nice atmosphere and friendly, helpful staff. Great selection of beers on tap, IPAS, stouts, sours, lots of choices.And the food was wonderful. Started with cheese curds and a Flatbread, then the Nashville (kinda) Hpt Chicken Sandwich. One of three best I've had, perfectly cooked, crispy, and hot but overall a well balanced flavor.“
“As "Two young retired old folks with white hair" we love to traverse the back roads from Lititz to find food and especially brews. I'm a barleywine girl and its hard to find. LOVED EVERY beer today and the brats & sauerkraut, and the Nachos were amazing!... and the barleywine!!!... Thank you!!Cannot wait to come over to Columbia again and have a flatbread lunch on a Friday afternoon... Mike you are the best (probably because of your beautiful bride...she also gets amazing kudos) Thanks for making us feel welcomed. Every time we visit...“
“The first Brewery I was ever at way back in the day. Still one of my favorites to grab a beer or two. If I'm not mistaken one of the first in York, PA if not the first. Pregamed here with my brother before my bachelor party, turns out my relationship with this place was stronger than my marriage. Anyway, great place to stop for a few before catching a York Revolution game across the street. They don't have a kitchen but they do team up with food trucks at times in the parking lot. Great selection of merch available. The owners are some of the nicest guys around. Some of the tastiest beers around.“
“Open spaces. Table seating. Private booths. I was a little shocked by the size of the room tbh.Absolutely authentic cuisine. My order was a to-go burrito w/guac no sour cream. Great hospitality, compassion, leadership-suited deck come meet the aces!I offer up Juarez, MX (founding of the burrito) better have a check-in because this cuisine’s got something that might have a person reconsider their definition of burrito. Go strong! Stay long! I know their bar serves nicely so bring your friends! Muchas gracias! Gratzie!:) Salud.“
“As my wife and I travel we are always looking for live music, good wine or beer and delicious food. The beer was superb. Awesome IPAs! The Nobles played last night and they were very good. The food from what I heard was new to them and it was good. I could see some improvements as they grow.“
“Perfect place to have good food and great beers. Stopped in after a day of hiking and the staff was friendly and helpful. One of the few craft breweries that have off street parking. We will definitely return to try more craft beer flavors and food assortment.“
“My husband and I were in town visiting from North Carolina. We came out to Gift Horse Brewing Company. I really enjoyed the relaxed, laid-back feeling of the outdoor bar area. All the bartenders were all really great, I enjoyed the conversations I had with them. My husband loved both the beers he tried. Great place!“
“The ambience was well played, pizza was good but, could've used less flour on the bottom. We had to sit off of the bar, the bar tender was on point and personable, deserves a raise. We had the grain salad with falafel and the falafel was not dry, the farro was cooked nicely, it could've used more feta. All in all we will return“
“I have been coming here regularly since they opened, so have probably been here 25+ times. Their brews are good as well as their panini sandwiches, sliders and small bites such as cheeses. The Gouda cheese tray is pictured. I guess I ate my sliders too quickly to take any this time. They use all locally sourced ingredients, which is a plus. They used to have music here a lot, but it seems in recent years the owners may be focusing more on their expanded locations to Lancaster and ironspire. They have added to the rear area of their brewery recently as well as added additional outdoor seating for warmer weather. When it’s nice, I like sitting outside here, although that may invite some Columbia characters to stop for unwanted chats, so be aware of that.“
“Noise level a little loud but not to where we couldn't hear each other. Service was on point. Very knowledgeable and attentive waiter, but not annoying. Food was great. We all had the pizzas. Dessert was fantastic too. We will be returning when we are in the area again.“
“Just discovered this place while going bowling, what a pleasant surprise. The actual bar room is beautiful, as in the wood design everywhere looked very fresh. It's newly built and you can tell it's brand new. It's a cute little place. We were the only ones there at the time, and the bartender spoke to us, and could tell if we did or didn't want to chat, so that was nice. They don't have too much of a selection, but what they have is good enough. Pretty average priced drinks. They partner with Allegro Winery incase you're not a brew person (I am not, so I really appreciated the wine). You cannot take your drink out to bowl though, you have to finish it inside of the bar!“