21 Best Italian Restaurants in West Chester

“We had heard of this place and decided to have our anniversary dinner here. It did not disappoint. My husband had the crab cakes and I had the lobster ravioli special. The food was excellent and was matched by the service. The calamari appetizer and the melon- prosciutto appetizers were superb and the desserts were a great finish. The wait staff is helpful. Pleasant and attentive. We will be back.“

“Had a wonderful dinner there the other night while I was in town visiting family and friends. A nice table for two with plenty of light. The meatball appetizer was yummy, but be ready to share! I ordered the risotto special, which came with shrimp and a lobster tail, and it was delish. Wish I had saved enough room for tiramisu! Out waitress was very attentive and knowledgeable! Highly recommend!“

“My husband and I celebrated his birthday at Dolce Zola. It didn’t disappoint! We enjoyed our pasta dishes. The sauces were delicious and the fresh pasta perfectly prepared. The Caesar salad had a bit too much dressing on it so next time we’ll ask for less. BYOB sealed the deal! We’ll be back!“

“Santinos is our new go to spot thanks to Nicole! She makes it such a welcoming, homey environment.. she truly remembers her customers and makes sure they are taken care of while you're here! AND she makes the most incredible (orange) cosmo! Great food, great drinks and even better company! Highly recommend!“

“Their cheese pizza is the best. They have few veggie options. They are a fast paced place so be ready to move quickly. Don’t take offense to that. They are just trying to move the crowd along during busy hour. We have order them for large kids party and they have always worked with us to accommodate. Would recommend to go here just for their cheese pizza. Their Greek salad is good.“

“Was there for lunch this week. Food was really good and very plentiful. I had the pork sandwich. Very juicy and tender. My wife had chicken tenders and fries. Nicky prepared and presented. Our one friend had a meatball sandwich with fries and the other had a chicken but. We all left with boxes of leftovers.The service was slower than expected but a group of 12 came in right after us and had not called ahead.Have been there twice before for dinner and enjoyed both times“

“Liberty Bell sandwich is delicious. My son always get the Anakin Solo Sandwich. It’s our go-to when my son and I are on our own for dinner. Like a tradition… “Tonight it’s America’s Pie” We always say we’re going to try another sandwich but never happens ?. Friendly. Consistent. Delicious. And always feels quick when ordering pick-up.“

“Today, we had my sister's Bridal Shower at Fellini’s Cafe. Anthony & his team were wonderful from beginning to end. The venue was exactly what we needed for about 30+ ladies. Our food was absolutely delicious with plenty to take home! Tons of space for backdrop & ballons as well as specialty tables: gifts, favors, desserts, and mimosa bar!!! Thank you for a special day?“

“Dropped in here for brunch while on a bike ride. Got the mimosa brunch board for 2. That included 2 mimosas and enough food for two to share. Plus some aperol spritz. Great experience from the time we were greeted by the host till the time we left.“

“Special Monday drinks and cheesesteaks with Amigo Dan. It’s hard to find Cheesesteaks and Alcohol on a Monday. Amigo Dan thinks he is a Pizza Expert so we went to Mercato and got a Mercato Pizza and Old Fashions. We liked Mercato’s. We liked our server. We liked our Old Fashions very much. I liked all of the ingredients that make the Mercato Pizza and just did not like them together as a pizza. The egg freaked me out.“

“The food was really good and the server was friendly and helpful. They had outdoor dining with live music which made for a great evening. Will definitely come back. Only downside was that their last seating was 7:45, we got there at 7, and they were packing up tables before 8 so we felt like we got the bums rush out of there.“

“The family that owns this restaurant is awesome and they go above and beyond to produce quality delicious food. Every time I’m in the West Chester area and I’m craving a cheese steak, wings or pizza I choose Vanos!Parking: Plenty of spots to park.Kid-friendliness: The whole family owned establishment has a friendly inviting atmosphere and is ran by great people.Wheelchair accessibility: Definitely wheelchair accessible!“

“Seven years ago, I stumbled upon a quaint Italian restaurant, the Fiorello Cafe, which left an indelible mark on my gastronomic memory. Recently, I had the pleasure of revisiting this culinary haven, and it was as if no time had passed – the experience was just as enchanting.The moment you step into Fiorello you're transported into a world where traditional Italian warmth and modern elegance coexist harmoniously. The ambiance strikes a perfect balance between cozy and chic, making it ideal for both casual lunches and special occasions.Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the food. The lunch buffet at is nothing short of amazing. Each dish is a testament to their commitment to quality and authenticity. The ingredients are evidently fresh, and each recipe brims with flavors that are both robust and refined. The meatballs were my favorite.The selection is wonderfully diverse, offering something for everyone without overwhelming the diner. Every dish is executed with a level of skill and passion that is palpably evident in every bite. The buffet format, surprisingly elegant and constantly replenished, ensures that each dish is as fresh and inviting as possible.What truly sets this place apart is the remarkable consistency in quality. It's rare to find a restaurant that not only impresses on the first visit but also maintains its high standards over the years. This consistency, coupled with the inviting atmosphere and the exceptional food, makes Fiorello a place that doesn't just feed the body but also nourishes the soul.The Fiorello Cafe is a shining example of what an Italian restaurant should be. It's a place where every meal feels like a celebration of Italian culinary excellence. Whether you're a first-time visitor or a returning aficionado, this restaurant is sure to leave you dreaming about your next visit.“

“Solid cheesesteaks, love the rolls, they don't skimp on the meat, but take a name down with every order so you don't mix them up and read the order back to the customer. I ordered a buffalo chicken cheesesteak and got a buffalo beef cheesesteak, another time I ordered 2 cheesesteaks and you thought we ordered 3.“

“The man running the cash register is a real creep. He publicly crucified the girl who took the order wrong and embarrassed her. She misunderstood. Next time just fix the issue and don't humiliate people.I've lived in West Chester a long time now and have found many OK pizza places. This is by far the BEST pizza around!!!!“

“The pizza is delicious and the prices are very reasonable. The salads are large and also worth the price. There is a great variety of food, drinks, and appetizers, so there is something for everyone. My children will only eat from this restaurant. The service is fast, friendly, and always with a smile. Thank you, and I look forward to coming again soon.“

“I love to stop in Sabatinos because of the variety of pizza slices. The biggest problem I have is which slice to choose! All of the slices are delicious. Sabatinos is also our go to pizza when we are visiting my father's house as it is the closest pizza place to his house and one we can all agree on that is delicious.“

“Love this place! Staff is super friendly and the service is excellent. Pizza is always spot on and they have added so many new items! I love the new rib-eye cheesesteak on the sarcone’s seeded roll with cooper cheese- best cheesesteak in town, better than steaks W. Chester!!“

“Started going to Enzo’s in 2009 while being a student at West Chester University. This is a place I took my parents due to it’s quality. 14+ years later the food is still top notch and I highly recommend their pasta dishes. You will be taking some home (largest portions I’ve received anywhere!) The gentleman behind the counter who appeared to be the manager was cordial and provided that Chester County customer service! Much appreciated!“

“We had a nice dinner last night. Everything enjoyed their meal, drinks and dessert.Rigatoni, Cubano, Tuna special and others that I cannot remember.We also ordered the flourless chocolate cake and personally I am a fan of chocolate but I didn't like that cake. I would not recommend it.“

“Brothers pizza gets the job done. You know it’s good when you consistently ask for a box for leftovers. I’ve come here a couple times during soccer practices. The basic large cheese pizza and garden salad are intensely satisfying. During the summer the wait staff are pretty young, but super friendly and attentive. Server had some of her friends come in to eat while we were there. Was funny overhearing them chat about friends and school.“