PB&J with Tay

Name: PB&J with Tay
Address: 5335 McCullough Ave, Olmos Park, Texas, 78212, US
Telephone: (210) 518-8299
Price range: $
Rating: 5

$ • Sandwich Shops, Comfort Food

Hours:
5335 McCullough Ave, Olmos Park
(210) 518-8299

Menu Order Online

Take-Out/Delivery Options

take-out

delivery

Customers' Favorites

Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich

Honey Bear with Bacon

Double Decker Delight

The Egg-Cellent PB&J

Strawberry Jelly

The Kitchen Sink

Pineapple Jelly

The Rocky Road

The Pooh Bear

The Hawaiian

PB&J with Tay Reviews

5 (105)

Write a review

March 2024

I can’t say enough about this special spot. We saw PB&J with Tay on The Texas Bucket List and made sure to stop by when we were in San Antonio. I brought my family of 8, and within five minutes after ordering, we all had our food. The selection of unique PB&J combos was amazing! We each ordered a different version to try. The standouts were The Double Decker, The Elvis, and The Rocky Road. It was a perfect twist on a nostalgic favorite. The bread was soft and fluffy, but perfectly...read full review

March 2024

This place definitely earns the five stars. As soon as I walked in Jeremiah greeted me like I was an old friend who’d been there a thousand times. Since it was my first time there he gave me a break down of the menu and had my order ready for me as soon as I was done paying. The atmosphere is great as it reminds me of my time as a kid, playing outside all day over the summer, and coming inside for a PB&J and a glass of milk. I had the Make My Tay and it was incredible, definitely...read full review

March 2024

If you can imagine the best PB & J plus extras of what you want added on from the menu, mind blowing. Your taste is like Wow! You feel at home, sitting around the table like you would at home with family. They have a table for a big group, yes!Parking: There is plenty of parking on either side of the building.Kid-friendliness: Coloring books, story books and board games.

More Reviews(243)