15 Best Italian Restaurants in Tyler

“I love Mario's! Mo, Veronique, and Afshin take great care of their customers. They support the community. They have great live music that still allows for conversation. But it's the Surf and Turf that takes Mario's to another level.“

“The food is so fresh and tastes soo good every time“

“We really enjoyed our meal.
Very busy, but server was GRANDTASTIC.

Parking: Had Handicap spots. I always look for them.

Kid-friendliness: Several kids and parents dined there.

Wheelchair accessibility: Had nice wheelchair ramps“

“Lasagna Crab avocado appetizer Limoncello cake Children’s build your own pizza“

“This is the best pizza I've ever had!! The slices are huge and the price is fantastic. Chef Cole made my pizza tonight and I am IN LOVE!“

“Went with some friends Saturday night and had a very enjoyable meal. Loved the bread and dipping sauce. The waitress was very attentive. Will definitely be back.“

“Good atmosphere, very friendly and capable wait staff. And the food was good.Not authentic italian grandma made good but good. I used to frequent a restaurant where the owner was from sicily. The recipes he made were authentic traditional Italian dishes and simply amazing.“

“Oliveto's lasagna is simply divine! From the moment I took my first bite, I was transported to culinary heaven. Each layer was perfectly cooked, with rich, savory flavors blending seamlessly together. The sauce was robust, the cheese perfectly melted, and the pasta cooked to perfection. It's evident that Oliveto takes great care in crafting their dishes, and their lasagna is a shining example of their culinary expertise. Their staff is super friendly. I can't wait to go back for more! 💯“

“We decided to have our Family Reunion Lunch at Roma Italian Kitchen & Bar in Tyler, and we could not have made a better choice! By far, Roma, and all of their staff, exceeded our expectations. We had 57 hungry diners and, with 2 servers, we never had to wait for prompt service and attention. Joey and Launa always seemed to be there when we needed them. They were very polite, attentive, and accurate in their execution of our food and drinks. The appetizers, entrees, and, deserts all tasted wonderful and fresh. This is the best Italian restaurant in the Tyler and surrounding area! Huge shout out to Joey and Launa, along with the Restaurant Owner, Zee, who made sure our entire group was well-cared for and satisfied. We 100% recommend Roma Italian Kitchen & Bar as your #1 choice for Italian dining in Tyler! Thank you all for taking such good care of us!“

“The presentation was stellar. The food and service were perfect. Scallops are the hardest to get right but they did an amazing job. The olive tapenade before the meal is worth the price of the meal! Subdued atmosphere is great for date!“

“Overall, a great place. The owner and his family are very friendly. Wonderful wine selection! We’ve greatly enjoyed each visit!“

“Excellent fresh pizza!! My favorite in Tyler!“

“It's my favorite Pizza Hut location in Tyler! Cleaner than the rest, and the staff are on the ball pushing those orders even on weekends. I've never waited much longer than 18 minutes or so from the time I order to the time they put it in my hands (I usually wait and/or carryout). My only criticism so far is the ease of getting in and out of the location on Broadway. It's kind of on a hill, easy to miss the turn if you're not paying attention, and you have to be real careful of the 50+mph southbound traffic as your leaving. Not going to knock them for that, but just be alert if you're visiting here during rush and dinner hours.“

“Staff and food are always great!!! ❤️ Catered my daughter’s wedding!“

“We've always only had a positive experience at Little Caesars at Three Lakes. Today was another day. We were told by Peyton L of a special to save us money on what I was already ordering. Erin at the window was nothing but professional. Thanks, guys!“