Carmello's

$$ • Italian, Seafood

Hours:
400 Twentyninth Pl Ct, Charlottesville
(434) 977-5200

Customers' Favorites

Carmello's Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
3.8 (62)
Restaurantji Rating

My very first review on any restaurant. Mostly cause I've been really wanting to check this place out and it was such a huge disappointment I thought others may benefit from what I have to say. Set reservations so I wouldn't have to wait. A couple walked in ahead of us with 730 reservations as compared to our 715. We were seated. They received their drinks and salad long before we received a drink offering. Same waiter, tables side by side. Our first drink were placed on...read full review

Restaurantji Rating

We had wonderful experience. The food was good, ambiance was exceptional. Our server Mike gave us complimentary dessert. They did not rush us although we came towards their closing hours. Thank you very much.

Restaurantji Rating

I was beyond impressed with everything: the handmade pasta, Mike who did everything in the dining room including provide wonderful service, and the atmosphere. I thought the prices were reasonable and quantities borderline obscene (not a complaint, who doesn't want a handmade pasta coma?) I'm so thankful we stumbled upon this gem. Thank you for a wonderful evening!

More Reviews(247)

Ratings

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday 5 - 9PM
Wednesday 5 - 9PM
Thursday 5 - 9PM
Friday 5 - 9:30PM
Saturday 5 - 9:30PM
Sunday 5 - 9:30PM
Updated on: