10 Best Italian Restaurants in Morgantown

“Stefano's is a hidden gem you'd never expect to find under a bowling alley. The ambiance instantly transports you away from your worries, with a cozy, elegant atmosphere that completely belies its location. Every meal we've had there has been exceptional, but the standout for us has to be the Chilean sea bass—perfectly cooked, flavorful, and just melts in your mouth. We always start with "the meatball" appetizer, which is rich, tender, and simply delicious, setting the stage for an incredible dining experience. And their cocktails? Impeccably crafted, with a blend of classic and inventive choices to suit any taste. If you're looking for an unforgettable Italian dining experience, Stefano's is a must!“

“First time there yesterday. Had the meatballs with ricotta and the Italian sandwich. Both were excellent!! Clean shop and very friendly staff!“

“wonderful place to play.. Great staff, Great food, Wonderful atmosphere“

“Typical chain restaurant quality. It was busy since it was right before Christmas I suppose but there was no wait to be seated. It was what you expect from Olive Garden. Food was served warm. No complaints. Server was absolutely adorable and attentive. Service really makes a difference in chain food places like this.“

“We enjoy dining at the Lakehouse. Some of our favorites - steak salad or hoagie, burger specials, and the Cajun Alfredo.“

“Always excellent service, but on my visit this evening Phil went above and beyond. Fantastic cauliflower crust pizza, amazing river views from the patio. I love the many skylights dining room during a good storm. One of my favorite spots to treat myself.“

“Had to edit and retract my previous statement. I ordered a whole pie, two toppings. Extra Cheese and pepperoni (after baked). When I opened the pizza I asked if it was extra cheese, and they reassured me it was.. I don't think it is ( see photos labeled sweated pepperoni).. great deal for slices The best tasting pizza in Morgantown PERIOD.“

“Ate at this location today for the first time. Nice, clean, atmosphere. Very friendly waiter/waitress, Stacey and Grayson. They worked together very well to make sure we had everything we needed. Excellent customer service!!!! Especially from Grayson, he was young & young kids usually get a bad rap. They gave us menu suggestions. Food was prepared quick & tasted great! We Will absolutely return here again!!“

“Casa is a staple of Morgantown eatery, whether it’s this location or downtown. Their pizza always leaves me cheesin

Edit: Their pizza is good, slightly greasy but the crust has a nice crunch, the sauce isn’t overpowering and the cheese is nice and flavorful.“

“First review I’ve ever posted about. We went for brunch. Knowing it was the first brunch that they had had in our memory we knew that things could take time are be a little messy. No big deal. The food was GREAT!! Service was GREAT!!! It took a little longer than we figured to get our food but we knew this going and never complained once to anybody. We got comped our food for 5 of us. They didn’t have to. Great place to go eat and will be going back. We have been here several other occasions and always had good experience. Keep
Up the good work. Waitress was Natalia if I remember correctly. She did a great job.“