11 Best Italian Restaurants near Lancaster

“Great pizza and wings! Just got done eating from Captain Tony's, and I have to say the pizza and wings we had were amazing. I went to this pizza place years ago and was not very impressed. But, there are new owners operating it now and they have made some great changes. This is some really good pizza, so do yourself a favor and give them a try!“

“This shopping center/strip mall has gone through hard times and now it seems it is back with many business creating activity and buzz. It is good to see the spaces utilized by all kinds of business from restaurants to a great hobby shop, Harbor Freight, and a great Bin Store.“

“If you are tired of eating those nasty big pizza chains and want a real pizza this is the place. We take the 25 min drive to get our fix. We typically order the same pizza and its always consistent. If you haven't tried this place is definitely worth giving it a shot.“

“Another pizza review!!! This restaurant has been around since I was a teenager and we came back to see that it's not changed one bit...except for the outside is now an atrocious color...but that's a different story for a different time...the crust is still awesome, crispy without being a cracker. And the cheese is perfect not salty so you know it's quality. And the sauce is the perfect blend of spicy and sweet...we love this restaurant and keep coming back every time we visit town...“

“I am sitting inside the blend of traditional family style and part sports bar eaiting some of the best Italian food I've eaten in a while. Its a must try if your are in the areaVegetarian options: If the ingredients are here they can make it for you“

“Loved visiting. It was a spur of the moment kind of thing, but my fiancé and I popped in for a bit. The waitress was sweet and always checked on us. The food tasted really good! We both ordered Gyros (lamb) and I ordered a side of the Prosciutto Salad.“

“For a little place in a strip mall, the food here is remarkably good. The calzones are delicious and tonight we tried the pasta primavera with white sauce and the baked cheese ravioli with meat sauce. We've also had the antipasto salad in the past--really good. Their portions on the pasta are large especially for the price. We'll definitely get more than one meal out of them. The primavera had a good variety of vegetables & the sauce was tasty although very rich. The ravioli are large and stuffed with seasoned ricotta. The meat sauce is remarkably good. It the antipasto salad has a good variety of meats, cheese and veggies. Love their house Italian. Only added some freshly grated Parmesan. Definitely restaurant quality for everything we've tried.“

“De Ann was off tonight, and I miss her, but Kristin, the other half of Team Awesome, took care of me. Gino's, please, please keep these two beautiful people happy and behind the bar. I pray management realizes what gems they have in these two. Kristin is on top of her game with the old fashioned charm (see what I did there) and De Ann makes everyone feel as if they're part of the family. And then there's Olman . Keep your crew happy. Pay them well. Keep them on staff and let their light shine!!!“

“This is a fun place for families to hang out, it is indoor, is is a good size and has lots of seating. There is an arcade area with many fun games, the food is good and the service is great. They also have party areas and packages at great deals.“

“Great Italian food ? for a chain store. It's a hit and miss on if you're going to get fresh bread with your salad or if they are hard as a brick. My goto is the eggplant or lasagna. Lunch is the best value for your money as it's normally about 6 dollars cheaper than the dinner price and it's the same size serving.“

“Great pizza! Great customer service! Their pizza sauce tastes delicious, way better than processed-sugary sauce. AND they have calzones :) Just amazing! Give this place a chance and you'll never go back to any other fast-pizza joint again“