5 Best Italian Restaurants near Islamorada

Italian Food Company Italian • $$$
82779 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Beef Carpaccio Appetizer
Chicken Milanese Arugula
Triple Chocolate Mousse
Mediterranean Octopus
Seafood Pasta Dinner
Rigatoni Alla Norma
Grilled Lamb Chops
Rigatoni Bolognese
Chicken Parmigiano
Meat Lovers Pizza

“Chef Rafael is an authentic Italian chef. The veal piccata was tender and perfectly flavored. The seafood risotto was filled with clams , mussels , shrimp and calamari were tender, sweet and delicious. I added shrimp to the mushroom risotto. I hated to see it end ?Our waiter Vinny was the cherry on top of our wonderful evening. It was a memorable family dinner made extra special by Chef Rafael and Vinny!Graci“

4.7 Superb409 Reviews
Island Grill Seafood • $$
85501 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

The Original Tuna Nachos
Homemade Key Lime Pie
Famous Tuna Nachos
Crispy Whole Fish
Fried Cheesecake
Spicy Tuna Roll
Coconut Shrimp
Conch Fritters
Steak Sandwich
Tuna Poke Bowl

“Food was excellent, and the service pretty good. The atmosphere wasn’t what we were expecting- we thought there’d be a view but for lunch, you’re on an open air porch that’s on the canal and there is not a view. It does look like they have seating with the ocean view but it wasn’t open when we came.Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly- they have a kids menu.“

4.6 Superb426 Reviews
Bayside Gourmet Italian • $
82758 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Grouper Reuben Sandwich
Meat Lovers Pizza
Antipasto Salad
Lobster Bisque
Hawaiian Pizza
Key Lime Pie
Veggie Pizza
Fish Dip
Lasagna
Salads

“Absolutely amazing, so glad we stopped here! Cutest little restaurant with classic arcade games and 80's paraphernalia up front, 80's music on the radio, the coolest menus in 80's looking folders, the outside area is creative, colorful and comfortable- from start to finish, the atmosphere is awesome! The food was mouthwateringly delicious. We shared the Mozzarella Caprese appetizer which was beautiful and so tasty. My husband had the Veal Saltimbocca (recommended by our waitress) and devoured it. I had the Cavatelli alla Vodka Rustica which was delightful! Topped it off with the layered chocolate cake. Yum! Highly recommend and we'll be back!“

4.7 Superb158 Reviews
Mia Cucina Italian • $$
81801 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

“Italian dining with a view of the ocean. We had spaghetti with meatballs, burrata, and garlic shrimp linguini. The handmade pastas were excellent and the sauce was outstanding. The Italian wine selection was nice, and will definitely be back.“

3.6 Good14 Reviews
Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge Italian • $$
90311 Old Hwy, Tavernier - 7.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters Rockefeller
Lobster Thermidor
Sauteed Escargot
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Piccata
Minestrone Soup
Beef Carpaccio
Fried Calamari
Chocolate Cake
Caesar Salad

“If not for staying here, would have never thought to come for dining. Husband was pleasantly surprised by a wonderful escargot, so delicious. We both had veal dishes and they were very tasty! Creme brulee on a dessert menu is the only time we order a dessert but this was not as good as we hoped for. On another night, we enjoyed Oysters Rockefeller, pizza, and martinis, all good. Bartenders Kaylie and Alex were great. Super experience, but would suggest a good clean up of the outdoor areas to make more inviting for a pricey restaurant.“

4 Good100 Reviews
Loading...
map Map