25 Best Seafood Restaurants near Key Colony Beach

“Outstanding service, food and drinks! Went there for my birthday dinner and it was great! We will be back soon!“

“Great view of the races,cold beer @ beautiful bartenders“

“AMAZING!!!! Had dinner as a last minute decision, and we were completely impressed with Barracuda Grill. We all had the special, lobster scallop and shrimp linguini. Salads were great, entrees were top notch, and the staff were really friendly. Highly recommended.“

“Ate at Castaways last night with friends. The food was amazing - fresh fish, great preparation, good choices and creative options. Prices were good for the quality of food and service. Our waitress, Tami, was super good. Knowledgeable, friendly, attentive and helped us through the options to make great choices. Highly recommend it.“

“Diners, drive-ins, and dives was not wrong. This place is definitely a place to stop! The chicken and smashed potatoes that Guy reviewed does not disappoint. Portion size is enough to eat and take some home. The potato is not smashed though. It's a full baked potato. Buffalo shrimp tacos with beans and rice were awesome! Lots of flavor! Next table to us had an awesome looking poutine. (French fries smothered with spices and cheese.) Over 30 beers on tap including IPAs as well. Great for beer lovers. Beer could be colder though. Small and separate dining areas. 2 indoor areas with a few tables and 1 covered outdoor space with larger group picnic type tables. A destination to try several times.“

“Been coming here for the last 3 years and we love this place the food is awesome and our server Kris is the best we ask for him every time we come“

“Great vibes- great food!!!“

“Love this place! We’ve been coming here many times throughout the years and enjoy the atmosphere and delicious food! Our ONLY issue here has been one specific, rude waitress. Today was the 2nd time we’ve had her as our waitress. First time (last year) she attended our families, we noticed she was rude, but gave her the benefit of the doubt, figuring she was having a bad day. But today, she was being extremely rude, unprofessional and seemed annoyed. She treated our kids poorly and treated the adults like kids. I’d still recommend this place, but please be aware not to have TANIA as your waitress!“

“Flew down for lunch last week. Staff at KMTH recommended this place so we tried it. We'll be back!!! Service was really good. Conch Chowder and Johnny Rambler with blackened Mahi were amazing! So was the Key Lime Pie. My new "hundred dollar hamburger" destination in the Keys. Looking forward to the next visit.“

“Absolutely amazing dinner! From the service to the appetizer to the drinks and dinner! I will definitely be back. Our server was Elizabeth, she was super sweet and knew how to explain/recommend the dishes. I drank the Billionaire Margarita (delicious) and my husband ordered a wine bottle. I had the lobster tails with mashed potatoes and broccolini it was to die for. I will definitely come back and I enjoyed my dinner very much!“

“Had a good meal tonight. Ordered the broiled mahi. Very good but a very SMALL portion for what you pay. My son had the sirloin steak which he said was very good. Had key lime pie which was a bit on the sour side and more like a pudding. All in all was a good visit. Staff was good and accommodating.“

“We had a wonderful meal, great service they were very busy but fit us in at an outside table. They made a special mac n cheese for my son. Really appreciated how they went out of their way and all the food was fantastic!“

“Great food chilled atmosphere, fab spot for breakfast or lunch“

“Breakfast was delicious. The catch of the day was grilled perfectly, the hotcakes were fluffy, and the home fries were deliciously seasoned. The topper was the service, which was on the spot throughout. A+++“

“We came for Mother's Day brunch. It was a beautiful location, the food was good and the service was pretty good as well. However the value per person for what the buffet actually was , was NOT worth it. It was almost 70$ a head, which we knew before hand, but for that price we were expecting a lot more good options on the buffet. It was mostly breakfast stuff. Had we known the buffet had such little options , we would have went elsewhere. Would like to come back and try their normal every day menu , however the Mother's Day buffet was extremely overrated .“

“Our waitress, Nara, was absolutely fantastic. She was attentive and very sweet. And per some of her recommendations, our meal was also fantastic. Our filet mignon's were cooked perfectly and delicious. Thanks to the chefs as well. Great overall experience.“

“Great view of the races,cold beer @ beautiful bartenders“

“I stopped in for a quick drink while my family was taking a tour at the nearby turtle hospital. The bar and the adjacent area overlooking the ocean/gulf was beautiful. My bartender, Jacklyn was really nice and friendly. I saw her answer multiple people's questions about the resort and things to see and do in and around Marathon, Florida. Great beautiful relaxing place for an afternoon libation and if you're lucky maybe Jacklyn will be on duty.“

“I got the smoked fish dip and it was a 10 , delicious“

“The food was really good! Buffalo Shrimp was awesome!“

“It was our first time eating there,,service was lacking a lot,,we had to ask for refills, she did leave a pitcher of water then. We ordered the lasagna dinner that comes with a side salad so we ordered another regular salad since we were splitting the meal. The side salad was pitiful, it came on a coffee saucer it looked like,the regular salad was a good size. For $24 the side salad should have been the same size as the extra salad. She brought our food and we sat there waiting on the bread,,,she comes back by and informed us bread was extra,,,really, I’ve never had a meal at any restaurant where you had to pay extra for bread, most will bring you more if you eat what they served you the first time. The upside was the lasagna was good.“

“another awesome dinner, tonight we sat at the bar. did was great as usual, and the service was awesome. thank you“

“Stopped in for a quick drink. Ended up staying for dinner! Fell in love with our bartender Jay and his sidekick Caroline! Food was great! Drinks were amazing and the sunset... beautiful! Loved the canon blast at sunset! Even had live music! -The virgin Key Lime Daiquiri was SOOOO GOOD!“

“Great lunch stop when headed down to Key West. Highly recommend. I may remember to bring my swimsuit next time and just stay nearby!“

“Great food! Great atmosphere! Catch your fish and get it prepared right here! Real nice Clark!“