28 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sanibel

“Excellent pizza! My first time eating a Captiva pizza! Yummy“

“Love island pizza! All the food groups a flavors to make everyone happy!“

“Our beach wedding was torrential downpour rained out 😭. Robin to the rescue! She pulled it all together and we were able to gather everyone and do our vows in the loft where our reception was scheduled to be!!! It was perfect and the food and service was amazing! Everyone had a great time! Thank you so much to Robin and the entire staff!“

“Stopped here for breakfast on a bike ride through the island. Place was super clean, the employee was kind and helpful and the food was great and well priced. I ate outside on the patio and enjoyed the breeze and the passers by. They sell lunch, too, so I’ll have to go again. I recommend this place.“

“Well for starters the escargot, raw oysters, and oysters Rockefeller were out of this world. Both the red and white clam chowder were like perfection in a bowl. My entrée was the baked stuffed shrimp and hands down AMAZING. Our waitress was YO and she knew everything about the history of the restaurant to the menu. I was very interested in the collection of oyster shells on the walls and she explained that as well. TEN STARS !!! I recommend to anyone who loves fresh seafood and visits Sanibel Island.“

“Great food that is affordable“

“Great pizza, the Detroit Style was cooked perfectly.“

“Papa Joes catered our vow renewal and the food was amazing! everyone was asking where it was from! Superb service and delicious food and affordable! customers for life!“

“Great pizza, servers were awesome, definitely worthy of a return.“

“Just a couple tables available to sit at , but the pizza was delicious deep dish pepperoni and bacon. We enjoyed our dinner.“

“Been in many times for dinner & Happy Hour(s) 🤣, but finally made it in for lunch and we continue to be impressed with all that is Paradise Pizza! You guys do it right and you definitely put patron satisfaction high on the list! Meatball Sub and Spaghetti & Meatballs were great! Wonderful cocktails too! Best pizza in Cape!! Always a pleasure to hang with the PP crew! C'ya again soon. 🍕🍸🥃❤️“

“We had a special celebration last night and the food was incredible and so beautiful in presentation. Wonderful service, elevated atmosphere. Unforgettable deserts. It's now one of my top favorite restaurants in the area. Highly recommended!“

“We ordered Uber Eats and had a wrong meal. I called the store and Tyler, the manager, without hesitation, apologized and prepared and PERSONALLY delivered the correct meal. We are business owners and understand that mistakes happen, but the way he took care of this situation was beyond what we expected and I can’t rave more about this restaurant and their team. Tyler, great job and thank you for outstanding service!!“

“Loved the pies!! So goooood!!“

“terrible owner who thinks they can call their customers liars when they get sick off of their food. CROSS CONTAMITION IS HAPPENING! my wife took 1 bite of their pizza and threw up 3x and 2 shits AND her stomach started to hurt within 5 mins! left a review on their Google and the owner wants to call us liars. You don't just get sick like that if there is no cross contaminated food. Gloves are not being changed enough, hands are not being washed enough, utensils are not being cleaned enough or well for that matter and who knows what else. already reported this business for food safety concerns. my wife is a cook, serve safe certified and takes cooking VERY SERIOUS and she instantly knew it was cross contaminated, but again the owner thinks people lie about something like this for no reason. 2+ years of this being a favorite pizza spot to now being the absolute worst we have ever dealt with. also, we have ordered the EXACT SAME PIZZA FOR 2+ YEARS... Cecilian pizza with ONLY BACON & PEPERONI... never once has it ever had CHUNCKY CANNED TOMATOS, CHUCKS OF GARLIC, COOKED SHREDDED LETTUCE HIDDEN UNDER THE CHEESE but owner wants to call us liars about it and says it's always been that way... we know what we eat, clearly this struck a nerve with the owner as it should.... YOU GOT SOMEONE SICK! DO NOT RECOMMEND AT ALL!“

“Mark is a great bartender during the day- Cristina, however, will completely ignore you after 6. She walks around like she does not have a care in the world and customers are not her job. If we did not come before 6 for the most part we would not patronize this place.“

“Pizza Parma in Cape Coral is the most authentic feeling Italian restaurant in the area. The menu is amazing, the facility is spotlessly clean, and everything from the table lamps to the napkins to the bottled water is first class. The best thing though, is the service. You are warmly welcomed and the knowledgeable staff goes overboard to make sure you get exactly what you want and that you are satisfied. On a 5 star basis I give Pizza Parma a 6“

“We love BackStreets fun atmosphere !!! The location is right downtown and they recently did a remodel. The staff and guests are ALWAYS friendly and welcoming. The bar food is really good (I recommend their wings and cheesesteak ). They regularly have live entertainment both inside and outside. And BONUS, they support the community in multiple ways. FIVE ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ STARS HIGHLY RECOMMEND“

“I love the pizza at Poppy’s ! You have to get there and try this pizza!“

“Best Pizza in the Cape by far!!!“

“Fantastic dining experience!“

“We eat here every week. Best pizza in Florida. You can buy by the slice or the whole pizza. Staff is so friendly . The small pizza has 8 good size pieces so 3 of us were full. The large is really big. It's so good we haven't tried anything else!“

“This place was festive with a very positive atmosphere. The food was really good, especially the crab. The service was very quick. Our server was inspired and really made the whole experience, that of a friend you haven't talked to in a while and just immediately reconnect.“

“Amazing chicken kabobs!! Best food on the island“

“Everything about the pizza was great…the amount of ingredients, the cheese, the sauce and the cooking time….service was great as well especially considering how busy they were ….we will be back before we go home“

“We usually swing by for our standard pepperoni pizza, which is decent but nothing to write home about, so imagine my surprise when we popped in yesterday and found a new face behind the counter—a super friendly short lady who was a breath of fresh air! She told us they had cheese, pepperoni, crazy bread, some cheesy bread, and wings all hot and ready. I was blown away; I’ve never seen such a variety! I decided to go for the cheese pizza, and wow, it was fantastic! Whatever changes they’re making, I’m all for it.“

“Always good food good service and brownie dessert rocks“

“Honestly this place is amazing I loved working here and having fun with my family members and I can’t wait to come back to work“