Palermo Pizza Sarasota

Name: Palermo Pizza Sarasota
Address: Behind Pinch A Penny, 7515 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota, Florida, 34231, US
Telephone: (941) 312-5410
Price range: $$

CLOSED
$$ •

Behind Pinch A Penny, 7515 S Tamiami Trail, Sarasota

Palermo Pizza Sarasota Reviews

Write a review

August 2022

I recently moved to Florida from NY. Desperate to find a pizza place as close to NY pizza as possible, I stumbled upon Palermo. Hands-down the best pizza I've had here in Florida so far. Regular slices were thin and crispy (without tasting like cardboard), lotsa cheese and a nice amount of dark/spicy sauce. Very flavorful! Haven't had the Sicilian yet but am looking forward to trying it out. Btw, their ice cream is beyond delicious!!! Definitely give this place a try. A+

August 2022

Wow!!!! The Best Pizza in Florida. The happiest moment followed by sadness. I finally found the perfect crust with the freshest ingredientsand sadly one more day to closing. On the bright side they have homemade ice cream and will be opening a shop here in Gulf Gate in the next few weeks. Another win for me please support this Boston guy who knows how to make it the natural way. If you want to taste the real Pizza stop by Sunday July 31 between 4 pm to 9pm and taste the real crust...read full review

August 2022

My family and I tried Palermo's pizza tonight. We had pizza and calzones. The food was very excellent. Pete, the owner, even let us sample all the ice cream flavors before the pizza came. All the staff was very friendly. It's off the beaten path but worth the drive.

More Reviews(245)