New American Restaurants near Crystal Lake, IL

1776 Restaurant American • $$$
397 W Virginia St, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Apple Braised Beef Rib with Bibb Lettuce and Blue Cheese Parmesan Crisp
Charcuterie Board
Parmesan Gnocchi
Mashed Potatoes
Wine Selections
Apple Fritters
Mushroom Soup
Creme Brulee
Duck Breast
Beignets

“Five stars all around for this wonderful restaurant! As first time diners we weren't sure what to expect as all dishes are gluten-free, however every dish was delicious and satisfying. Our party started with 2 very tasty appetizers of Mussels and Cheese Curds. We then enjoyed the House and Seasonal Salads, both having a wonderful honey mustard vinaigrette. For an added touch, the Seasonal Salad was topped with goat cheese. I can't say enough about our entrees. Not only were the presentations well done, all tasted as wonderful as they looked! The Skate Wing with Snap Peas was a mild white meat fish, with caper brown butter sauce. The Short Rib was perfectly done and topped with brown sugar glaze. The Hanger Steak, ordered medium rare, had a roasted peppered chutney, charred on the outside, and two roasted whipped sweet potatoes. Our meal was topped off with the Julian's Frozen Custard dessert and espresso. The restaurant itself is somewhat small, with a cozy and charming feel to it so reservations are a must! Our service thruout the evening was exceptional so kudos to the attentive staff. A final note there is additional parking across the street so take advantage when the main lot is full. Will definitely be dining here again!“

4.5 Superb278 Reviews
The Quarry Cable Park & Grille New American • $
5517 Northwest Hwy, Crystal Lake

“I've attended and hosted many events at The Quarry over the years. It's a beautiful space where I've made many memories and met new friends. Several years ago I hosted a surprise party for my sister's birthday and the Quarry staff made everything so seamless so all I had to do was show up with the guest of honor. They are so thoughtful and accommodating and really know how to throw a good party! I HIGHLY recommend this venue. I've also been here for drinks after SUP yoga or a nice longe bike ride in the summer. It's so fun to enjoy a nice drink in the sand and the fire pit is such a nice touch. The prices are a little high, but it's to be expected with such a unique venue with tons of free amenities like live music, sand volleyball, and baggo. Totally worth it in my opinion. Also, their themed events are always so much fun with awesome decor, live entertainment, pop-up booths, and delicious themed drinks. My favorites are the Galentines event, the Speakeasy, and the Mother's Day event.“

4.5 Superb30 Reviews
Cafe Olympic American • $
90 N Williams St, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Homemade Cinnamon Rolls
Breakfast Potatoes
Chicken Rice Soup
Corned Beef Hash
Classic Benedict
Grilled Cheese
Sausage Gravy
Vegan Pancakes
Homemade Soup

“My kids and I love this place! It’s the only place in town where my dairy free family has zero issues eating great food. It makes my life so easy! Plus, the outdoor seating is perfectly situated so that toddlers can eat and watch trains…it’s perfect for us! The food is great! The staff is just awesome! We’re big big fans and will be. Ack again and again.“

4.4 Superb113 Reviews
The Village Squire (Crystal Lake) American • $$
4818 Northwest Hwy, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Fish Fry Friday Special
Prime Rib Grinder
French Onion Soup
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala
Gyros Sandwich
Roasted Garlic
Sampler Platter
Baked Potato
Greek Salad

“Great food and staff. Love going here! Kosta is an amazing server! He is on top of everything no matter how busy it is. He makes you feel like you're the only table he has. Friday and Saturdays are busy but if you get there at the perfect time, there's no wait!“

4.3 Superb117 Reviews
Montarra New American • $$$
1491 S Randall Rd, Algonquin - 4.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Duet of Beef Tenderloin Tips & Pecanwood Bacon Wrapped Jumbo Scallops
Pistachio Crusted New Zealand Rack of Lamb
Crab & Artichoke Crusted Scottish Salmon
Lump Crab & Artichoke Stuffed Mushrooms
Pistachio Crusted Rack of Lamb
English Sticky Toffee Pudding
Red Wine Braised Short Rib
Seared Lamb Rack Lollipops
Caramel Turtle Cheesecake
Crab Stuffed Mushrooms

“Mountain of praise for Montarra The experience was very pleasant. This was our second time here and, to be honest, we only returned because we had a gift certificate. But we were pleasantly surprised and delighted. Service: Excellent. Both wait staff and hostess team seemed very engaged, from when I made the reservation to when we stepped into the restaurant and even when we left. Our waitperson was efficient, polite, and knowledgable. Food: was really outstanding (we had bouillabaisse and a special risotto dish with scallops). The menu was varied and interesting - I often gauge a restaurant by looking at the menu and having a difficult time making a selection because many items looked good. I liked that they had a quality menu with several selections that seemed creative. The quantity of items was also just right. Not too many, not too few. Other: When they took my reservation, they asked if it was a special occasion. I said it was for my husband's birthday. They asked his name - I didn't really know why but told them. When we were seated, I realized why. They had printed a special version of the menu with a happy birthday note to my husband. It was a very inexpensive, clever, and simple, yet meaningful step. We were impressed. We would definitely return - even without the gift certificate.“

4.6 Superb94 Reviews
Hart's Garage American • $
2401 US-20, Hampshire - 11.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Sandwich
Fried Pickle Chips
Bacon Cheese Fries
Avocado Egg Rolls
The Garage Burger
Cheese Curds
Brioche Bun

“I gave this place a 4 star and that's only because Chelsea came and saved it from being a 2 star. Our original server was atrocious and had no idea what she was doing. We got sat at our table and another couple got sat right after us. The other couples server came right away and took their drink order and also gave them some tickets for something. We sat down at 540. That time is important to the next part of my story. So after about 15 minutes our server finally came and took our drink and Appetizer order. After another 10 minutes our drinks finally arrived. At that point we hear a bunch of commotion. They were apparently announcing that they were doing a raffle from the tickets they were handing out. I said I had no tickets, and OUR SERVER said, "you had to be here before 6pm". I said we were here before 6. She said I don't think you were. I said that table behind us sat down AFTER US and they got tickets. So how is that possible. She said we'll I'm sorry its the owners rules. Really? She was the one who couldn't be found for over 20 minutes. As they are doing the raffle I see the guy coming with our Appetizer. I said hey that's ours. He said I have to verify first. Really? You don't know table numbers? After running around and waiting for OUR server to finish the raffle we weren't even part of, She finally tells him it's ours and he brings it to us. It wasn't cold, but it wasn't hot either. It tasted really good but would have been better hot. There was alot of bad this server did before Chelsea came to take over. Everyone there seems clueless and ran around trying to figure out what to do. Chelsea should be a trainer since she was the only one that could deliver. Looking at previous reviews that seems to be the continuous problem, bad staff. Keep Chelsea or you will have to close your doors with poor service. The food we did get after she took over was very very delicious. So very good. These days service means everything and if you keep this poor server you won't last, even if your food is phenomenal.“

4.5 Superb62 Reviews
Cary Ale House Gastropubs • $$
208 W Main St, Cary - 4.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mac and Cheese with Brisket
Buffalo Cauliflower
Thai Coconut Curry
Chicken Tenders
Pulled Pork
Pub Burger
Sliders
Rooster
Salad

“Had a great time stopping in for lunch on a Sunday. Tasty spicy Bloody Mary. So happy they bag interesting vegetarian options!!! This made my vegetarian friends happy and me because I picked it! Buffalo Cauliflower was just lightly battered and peefectly cooked with a good plate full. The chickpea curry was yummy and I had grilled chicken with it. The desserts looked yummy but not this trip. Next visit we will try the beer and desserts!Vegetarian options: Offered tofu as alt protein!Dietary restrictions: They are a scratch kitchen so were able to accommodate a few changes due to allergies“

4.5 Superb60 Reviews
The Black Bear Bistro American • $$
107 S Main St, Algonquin - 4.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Flourless Chocolate Cake
Grilled Calamari
Beef Wellington
Mushroom Soup

“Excellent atmosphere!! From the food, to the service, and soft music. Was a perfect date night. It’s a nice quaint place and very unassuming. Not very fancy but the food is AMAZING!! Can’t wait to come back. If you’re adventurous & like exotic meats, whatever the special is, GET IT!! Family owned business and extremely knowledgeable and friendly staff. Put this one on your list!“

4.4 Superb54 Reviews
Meat & Potato Eatery-McHenry Fast Food • $
400 State Rte 31, McHenry - 7.16 miles

Customers` Favorites

Seasoned Curly Fries
Chili Cheese Bowl
Waffle Fries
Loaded Fries
Kabob Dinner
Italian Beef
Baked Potato
Greek Salad
Pot Roast
Meatloaf

“Today we were in the area and decided to stop in for lunch. It has been a year since we left a review. The dining room is the same and very clean! The person who took our order was really nice and professional as always! I ordered the 1/2 slab of ribs it came with a side salad, a 6" piece of corn on the cob, and fries which I upgraded to the baked potato for $1 more. The baked potato was quartered and a huge potion size so definitely worth the extra $1. The 1/2 slab of ribs had about 7 bones... so you got a decent amount! My husband ordered the Italian beef and added Provolone cheese for 65 cents which was well worth it! I posted a video for each of our food items. We loved our food and would definitely order it again!“

4.3 Superb71 Reviews
Sideouts Sports Tavern Sports Bar • $
4018 W Roberts Rd, Island Lake - 7.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bloody Mary Mimosa and Breakfast
Rancher Steak Wrap
Burger with Fries
Ultimate Nachos
AYCE Fish Fry
Giant Pretzel
Cheese Pizza
Hobo Skillet
Big Pretzel
BBQ Ribs

“Sideouts is an awesome place to eat, drink, bowl or watch live music! Huge outdoor patio with tvs, music, baggo, violleyball and so much more. The food is excellent, the pizza is some of the best around! Summertime they have car shows, bands in the sand concerts, and many other events. You gotta check this place out!“

4 Good92 Reviews
Liquid Blues Bar • $
126 N Benton St #2, Woodstock - 8.87 miles

“Great little place ! Amazing music memorabilia covering the walls ! Terrific atmosphere..pool tables ...gaming in the back...many music choices available...Bartenders Christen & Ralph were accommodating as well as entertaining... And you gotta try the pudding shots ...OH YEAH just love all the Lava Lamps too!“

4.2 Good18 Reviews
BROKEN OAR MARINA-BAR & GRILL Bar & Grill • $
614 Rawson Bridge Rd, Port Barrington - 6.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Burger and Fries
Friday Fish Fry
Hangover Burger
Cuban Sandwich
Fried Pickles
Mac and Cheese
Tater Tots
Hamburger

“Outstanding place to visit with the family. We would boat all through the summer, and one of the highlights would be to stop by the place with the family and enjoy their hospitality. Busy place. Great food, reasonable prices, the music the service are outstanding and just overall a great place to hang out with friends and family. They always have some sort of event happening and we went for the downstairs artic bar and WOW! What a great setup! Highly recommend it!“

3.9 Good128 Reviews
Iron Horse Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $$
3965 W Algonquin Rd, Algonquin - 4.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Iron Horse Bison Burger No Bun
Sloppy Joe Grilled Cheese
Boneless Barbecue Chicken
Chips Salsa and Guacamole
Chipotle Shrimp Alfredo
Iron Horse Quesadilla
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Bacon Wrapped Dates
Italian Beef Wrap
Goat Cheese Pizza

“We went for a late lunch this past Saturday with 8 of us. Traveled from Wisconsin to have lunch with my nephew.I wish I caught her name, but our waitress was fantastic! Super friendly and attentive. The bartender was also very nice and made some good drinks (according to my family). The place wasn’t very busy and we didn’t feel rushed at all, which was nice.We got fried pickles and chips & guac with salsa for apps and loved them! The kids pizza was huge and actually very good. I got the carne asada tacos and a cup of chili. I can honestly say that the chili was some of the best chili I’ve had and the tacos were amazing. My mom got the pulled pork sandwich, she loved it and it was packed with pork! Everybody loved their meals.It was nice they had high chairs available and a changing table in the bathroom! Definitely kid friendly with the crayons and paper as well.Will definitely be making the trip again!!Kid-friendliness: High chairs available, crayons & paper, changing table, low tables“

3.9 Good56 Reviews
Village Vintner Winery & Brewery Brewery • $$
2380 Esplanade Dr, Algonquin - 5.59 miles

“We have been members of the Vintner since before they started the restaurant and we have never had any complaints!!! I have had many great experiences here with Janet and Bob! If you like connecting to people and a great time this place is awesome!!“

3.7 Good103 Reviews
Main Street PourHouse Bar • $$
214 Main St, Woodstock - 8.91 miles

“My husband and I have walked past this place every single week for 2 years and each time I would say, we should try this place. So we finally did. It's definitely a dive bar - nothing special about the atmosphere. The 2 times we've been there, there was a hint of pinesol in the air. But friendly service. And the food - we only had tacos - is outstanding! The barbacoa is delicious - slightly spicy. Unless you're my husband and then it's too spicy. But yummy! The pastor is equally as delicious. We also tried the chicken tacos which are very good, too. Each taco is meaty and flavorful. Definitely recommend. On Tuesdays tacos are on special - but for the amount of taco you get, no complaints in pricing whatsoever on the other days. Definitely recommend.“

3.5 Good19 Reviews
Loading...
map Map