33 Best Italian Restaurants near Beech Grove

“The food was decent nothing to write home about for the price paid. The portion sizes are ok nothing overly large or small. The service was good. The atmosphere is just there. I think for the money spent I would go to a few other places before coming back here.“

“Great experience! Unstuffy atmosphere, superb food, and really nice server, Eileen, all added up to a phenomenal experience. With a large group-everything was seamless. Appetizers were somewhat familiar but kicked up with a little (delicious) twist or sauce. The wine paired nicely with everything--a Super Sardinian blend (think Super Tuscan) bold but smooth. The Caprese salad was boosted with farrow--comfort food salad. Everyone was very happy with their main course (pasta dishes or the short-rib entree). Excited to go back so we can all try more of the menu.“

“Carlos was amazing! I had the butter cake and sherbert! And my friend had the cheese cake I know it's strange but we came out for desert. It was an amazing place. The music is a vibe and it's a place to visit........ I will return at a later time to indulge in a meal.“

“Went with a friend for Devour Indy and was quite pleased! Our waiter, Jay, was attentive and helpful giving suggestions. The octopus appetizer was by far our favorite part of the meal, but everything else was great, too. Will definitely be back!“

“We ordered Garlic Bread, Eggplant meatballs (forgot what it was called on the menu) & Calamari for appetizers & they all were delicious. So were the pizzas we ordered for dinner. And the Tiramisu was definitely one of the best I have had in Indy so far.“

“We were In town for a baseball tournament trying to find a place to have dinner for our sons bday that’s tomorrow and randomly found this place and let me say best place I’ve ever been the owner came out welcomed us and made our son feel so special on his bday thank you so much again highly recommend best calzone and soda I’ve ever had !!“

“We went to Iozzo’s last month for our anniversary dinner. It was a truly memorable experience. The food was fantastic. Nice outdoor patio with a lovely fountain ⛲️ Our server, Jason, was terrific and very attentive. Chris, the manager, repeatedly checked on us. Now one of our all-time favorite restaurants. We plan to get back in the coming months. William Whitton Shirley Broyles“

“Phoned in order. Arrived at told time for pickup. Pizza just coming out of oven. By the time I payed, it was on the counter. Could not make it all the way home with my car smelling like pizza. At the first stop sign I grabbed a bread stick to snack on. Got pizza home, looked wonderful, & tasted wonderful. Best pizza on the east side. Give them a try. PS. They are about the only business on that corner, so plenty of parking!“

“For starters the counter man was very very sweet and nice and very helpful and friendly the food was wonderful I can ask for a better Pizza the slices were huge very much so worth the money definitely go hit up the New York slice in Greenwood “

“We came for Devour on a Saturday night. We were able to make a reservation and get in quick when we couldn't get in to another restaurant and boy was I thankful we ate here instead! A local family ran restaurant with wonderful service and even better Italian food. I texted my whole family saying we need to come here. Will be back! I recommend The chicken piccata and the meatballs were SO good.“

“Ordered carry out lunch just prior to 3pm. Picked up my house salad and deep dish personal sausage pizza about 25 minutes later and it was great. The personal pizza is of similar quality to the regular sizes and all that for a little over $12.“

“This small family run pizza joint is amazing. Thin crust pizza that is wood fired with just the right amount of burnt crusty edges. Took two friends who had never been and they thought it was out of this world. Always a stop for us before a BU BBall game.“

“I went there because I craved Chicken Piccata. *I recommend it, btw*Cons:-It can be a little bit of a wait, but that's because they're busy, not lazy. And it was nothing ridiculous, just don't expect to walk in and get a table.-Parking was tight (but everywhere seems to be in Indianapolis)Pros:-Friendly and attentive staff-Didn't feel rushed or pressured (I'm a slow eater)-Prices were reasonable (esp for what you get)-Drink was well made10 out of 10. I would visit again if I lived there.“

“First time we went to the restaurant. Our server was knowledgeable about the menu and made excellent recommendations. Our food came out promptly, was hot and well-prepared. Everything was tasty! The reviews on the restaurant were spot on and I will pay it forward to and recommend to others.“

“It's 12.30am and I am eating this pizza.?I found this restaurant yesterday while at Aldi on Emerson. After reading about the sweet pizza sauce, the fresh crust, and the great reviews, I ordered a pepperoni pizza, but wasn't super impressed with the flavor and the sauce seemed be very minimal. I reached out to give them my feedback and the staff member (I'm awful with names )was so polite and offered to have their best staff remake the pizza. When I arrived, she let me know that the manager made it personally and requested feedback from the staff before presenting it to me. That showed me that they truly do care about customer satisfaction and that the staff works well together and supports one another. Will DEFINITELY be back. My remade pizza was great and flavorful! That's why I'm eating at past midnight.?“

“John was an amazing server who made our first experience in the restaurant for our 10 year anniversary great! We were very happy with our food and our drinks. Definitely a great spot for date nights. Will be going back for sure! The shrimp cocktail has an over abundance of horse radish and it makes it really hard to enjoy, so if you like that dish ask for side of ketchup to go with it.“

“Ordered from here for the first time recently. Really good and crispy thin crust with quality ingredients. Staff was friendly and helpful. Been looking for another option for pizza near me and this Marcos store is definitely high on my list.“

“My husband and I won the Valentine's Day meal for two through Do317.com. The staff was extremely kind and accomodating, even knowing that the $60 meal was free for us through the contest. Our waiter was also still very attentive, easy to talk to, and welcoming. Our food was EXCELLENT. They even ended up covering our entire check, including our wine--we were pleasantly surprised! We could not have asked for a better experience. We will definitely be returning!“

“Looking for Italian lunch this past Saturday. Had never heard of this place & decided to try. It is a delightful place & food was absolutely delish!! Nothing fancy, very simple, & staff is wonderful. I'm on a mission now to tell folks about this charmer & I definitely will be back. The tiramasu is some of the best I've ever had!! Thank you for a lovely experience!!“

“Im not a review leaving type of guy, this pizza deserves it though. I’ve never had a deep dish this good. All of the ingredients complemented each other. The crust was a soft slightly charred packed full of flavor. We will definitely be back.“

“This is a great family restaurant. We go at least once everytime we visit family in New Palestine. Tenderloin is fabulous. Biscuits and gravy is delicious and huge. Everything I've had has been enough to share.Kid-friendliness: The staff made us feel welcome to stay near closing time while my little niece ate and chattered.“

“Stumbled across opening day on a trip through town and what a delight!! Tasty sandwiches and great flatbread pizzas. Beautiful (and ample!!!) outdoor seating options along the canal with plenty of shaded tables (and indoor seating too). Such cheerful and helpful team working --seems like they enjoy working there almost as much as we enjoyed eating there. And s'mores at the table Kid-friendliness: Tasty, good quality kid choices and outdoor seating for the kid win. Bonus of s'mores if they eat their whole sandwich ?“

“This restaurant was beautiful, the staff was super friendly and was quick to serve us and refill drinks. The bread was melt in your mouth delicious. My pasta was pretty good, but the fettuccine had an interesting after taste to it like Asiago cheese has which is my only complaint.“

“My husband and I chose to eat here for our Valentines dinner 2024. Service was great, food was great, it wasn't very busy when we arrived (we eat dinner "early") so that was great.I chose the Johnny Trio (it basically had sirloin, chicken and some raviloi). My husband had the spaghetti. We had mozzarella sticks for an appetizer and Tiramisu for dessert. I would recommend all of it!“

“Vongole E Vino was a perfect starter, great flavor, and presentation. For the main dish, Osso Buco, with mushrooms and pea risotto, did not disappoint. Music was on an enjoyable volume, a speakeasy place. Lighting, service, and facilities on point. This place it's being run from somebody who cares about their clientele experience. Definitely will come back.!“

“South of Chicago has the best combo I have had outside of Chicago. The food is so good I dont even miss my home state of Illinois. The service is great and the atmosphere really feels like a Chicago diner. Go get a cheesey beef and sausage combo with hot peppers. Itll change your life.“

“A City Market must try!I recently dropped by for a meal. My first choice, a shrimp po’ boy, was sold out. The lady behind the counter was quick to recommend the chicken sandwich. Her enthusiasm is certainly admirable. After re-reviewing the menu, I ultimately took her advice. Topped with a unique flavored coleslaw between French style bread, it was nothing short of delicious!A staple eatery in the good ol’ City Market that’s well worth trying!“

“My children and I have been to this location twice in the last 3 months. While we had similar experiences this last time the food tasted like the B team made it(Tuesday). The first time everything exceeded expectations (Saturday). This most recent visit was good, just not great as I know it can be. The seafood ravioli cream sauce was broke and very oily. The meatballs were not as tender, even the sausage texture and seasoning seemed different. Not horrible but not as good. Still worth a try and good value but missed the details on the food this time. Service was great and upbeat both times. The building is beautiful inside.“

“I visited three times this week. I called initially to see about placing a placing a delivery order to the library, I was informed they only had carry at at this time. Drivers were limited.I read the reviews. So after reading about the Lasagna Pizza and the grave reviews I decided I would go once I left the library.I walked in and the server told me that I could sit anywhere I like.I had an excellent first time experience. I had Lasagna Pizza and a spinach salad.My waiter checked on me frequently. I could rave on him all day long. He and the gentleman cleaning the tables need a raise for their services.Since I know they did not have delivery. I went ahead and did a carryout order the next day. I could not get enough of the Lasagna Pizza. The lady who took my carryout order told me it would take 15 to 20 minutes. I walked to the gas station, returned to the Jockamo, and then walked too wherever I wanted to go to next.The third day. I walked in. It was a little busier than my first experience. It was not overly crowded. I asked to sit at a table on one of the walls rather than in the middle of the room where I was being asked to sit.I was told no due to setting arrangements. I could have chosen to leave, but I decided to stay. I could read the greeters face and tell she thought that decision was out of her hands.I wanted to try something different. Therefore, I ordered the Lazy Boy Pizza. The waitresses and waiters worked as a team. I was checked on often. They have a great team going.A lot of times when I visit an establishment. It is to continue working on business projects. That third day I arrived at about 6:30 p.m. and left at around closing time. I asked for items as I packaged up to leave. The lady behind the counted pleasantly handed them to me.The seat that I had desired in the back of the room in which to work. No one sat at that table the duration of my visit. It was empty in a half full room. Where people request to be seated if a table is available and does not take up too much space matters.“

“Unlimited soup, salad & breadsticks had increased by .50 in a couple of months, but still a reasonable lunch price for freshly prepared food with great service & atmosphere. Olive Garden never disappoints—at least at this location. Excellent service too!“

“I was in Keystone Crossing, Indiana for a work trip. The Fashion Mall was 5 mins walk from where I stayed. I decided to try this artisanal pizza spot, and I was not disappointed. Service was great, pizza was yummy. They have outdoor seating which I enjoyed as the weather was perfect. This was first time eating pizza with a heavy portion of arugula, and I loved it.“

“This place never ever disappoints. I've eatting at a lot of pizza restaurants and places and this place is hands down the best in the city. The customer services is above par. This place makes you feel like home and with the smell of fresh baked dough that has a aroma all its own. I'm definitely coming back..Kid-friendliness: The chairs are plastered with comics super heros and all kinds of cool art and images the back patio is fenced in so the kids can play in safety it's a refreshing piece of mind for a parent“

“The first time I ever ate here, the food was good; I liked the Chicken Carbonara mainly because the chicken had a lot of flavor. The carbonara sauce was delicious, only four starts because my kiddo didn't like the pasta; it's a little overcooked.The bread sticks are like 2/5 “