Brooklyn and The Butcher

$$$ • Seafood, Cocktail Bar, Steak House

148 E Market St, New Albany
(812) 590-2646


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Recent Reviews

Ambiance was nice. Great decor. That’s it. When they came to serve the food they served across the table instead beside you. Kinda weird. I got the Oscar 75.00ish. A small quarter of a tomato, 7 oz filet with crabmeat with bearnaise sauce and asparagus. Nothing was hot. Luke warm at best. My husband put butter on his steak and it did not melt. There were shells in my lobster and I am not so sure there was bearnaise sauce. Very disappointing and we will not be back. My full review
Brooklyn and the Butcher is just another overpriced restaurant wanting to cater to the "in" crowd. They charge for every little thing and it can't possibly be justified because the food falls flat. My meal was fine and I was pleased though not with the 6$ charge for a small ramekin of the topping I ordered, I thought it would come smothered onto my steak so as to be visually appealing but it was still a decent meal. My husband on the other hand, bless his poor unsatisfied soul, full review

The steak was not impressive, an okay cut of meat but no flavor. For the price I would expect to be able to eat it with out needing steak sauce but it was very bland. My wife ordered a steak well done and it was completely dried out. I would happily pay for a good steak but will not return to this place. The price was way to high for the quality.

More Reviews(340)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 5 - 9PM
Wednesday 5 - 9PM
Thursday 5 - 9PM
Friday 5 - 10PM
Saturday 5 - 10PM
Sunday 10AM - 2PM
5 - 9PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.