Rookies Cookies

$ • Cupcakes

310 Pearl St, New Albany
(812) 948-8858


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Rookies Cookies

What a wonderful, amazing and delicious experience. I tasked Rookies with a last minute order, that they had no business accepting. Not only did they accept it they made unbelievably awesome volleyball cookies for HHMS 8th grade team!!! This was an awesome ending to the season. Quick!! Great customer service, and some of the best cookies ever according to the team. Thank you Rookies Cookies for your 5 star performance. Buy local!! Will definitely be back.

5/5 would recommend, they did sheet cakes for our wedding and everyone raved about them. Personal favorite is the Italian cream with cream cheese icing, and you could never go wrong with their thumbprint cookies! They matched our wedding colors perfect! Will be back in the future for sure!

Stopped in for a quick treat while shopping downtown. Lady behind the counter was so nice and told all about what they make and sell there. Custom cakes, cookies, and treats. Family owned and operated since 1939 and well know for their melt in your mouth Little Flower Butter Wafers. Be sure to try a sample one of those - so good. I will be going back again soon.

More Reviews(48)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 9AM - 4PM
Wednesday 9AM - 4PM
Thursday 9AM - 4PM
Friday 9AM - 4PM
Saturday 9AM - 2PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.