9 Best Italian Restaurants near Vineyard Haven

“First time that I dined there was this past weekend and I wasn’t disappointed. Service A+, atmosphere A+, meal……A++. My wife and I brought friends from out of town to Salvatore’s for dinner. Wow! On level with some of the best Italian restaurants we’ve ever been to. Outside “Garden” dinning was a pleasant surprise. Our server was very attentive but not too intrusive. The Classic Cocktails were on point. Pasta was definitely made in house and among the finest I’ve ever tasted. I enjoyed a “special” with mounds of fresh seafood over pasta. It’s worth a trip to this gem in VH no matter where you travel from. You won’t be disappointed.“

“So Laura and I stopped here last night after missing our ferry off the great island of Martha's Vineyard. It was a pleasant surprise as we both ordered a Caesar's Salad wrap with grilled chicken. Simply put it was the best Caesar's salad wrap I've ever had. We ordered the same exact wrap and they were very hearty wraps either a good proportion of lettuce and chicken. Lots of tasty grilled chicken and expertly wrapped. No spillage and quite satisfying. They have an adjacent bakery where they sell all kinds tasty looking sweets and also ice cream. Laura picked up a fresh French bread for our brunch today. Based on our impromptu visit last night I would recommend this great cafe. Salud!“

“Food is ALWAYS amazing, very fresh and everything feels scratch made. So cozy and chill, the prettiest lighting. One of the best Italian offerings in this town. The chef so graciously made his Stracciatella soup for my husband's birthday dinner, so outrageously good and so appreciated! We are so happy to continue to support this unparalleled small business.“

“Osteria La Civetta is one of our favorite restaurants! It's a cozy, intimate and romantic atmosphere, which we love. The lights are dim and the decor is unique. The tables aren't too close together so we felt like we could have a private conversation. They have a nice selection of Italian wines. I selected the Primitivo, which was pretty good. The menu is small, but still includes many great options. I had the tortelloni with butternut sage sauce. It was great! The pasta is all made fresh in-house. I also had the affogato for dessert and it was delicious. I highly recommend! We can't wait to go back!“

“Linguini Carbonara was unreal. My wife and I shared the pan as our meal and it was incredible! We are use to NJ/NY Italian and this is the first time we have ever said NH has great Italian food! Highly highly recommend and share a pan otherwise you will have a TON of left overs.“

“I live in Hyannis and I drove to Falmouth to try this place because I love Italian food so I heard they have fresh pasta. I will tell you don't regret to go. You will love it.The chef went to our table and he suggest the osso buco which was falling off the bone and I had panna cotta as deserve so good.“

“I really like the pizza here. Sandwiches are great too! Staff are all really friendly. I really like the inside for sitting to eat lunch. My only complaint really are the prices. If you get a large specialty pizza you're paying close to $30, and it is not that big. Again, it's really good and the crust is handmade, but it's steep compared to other places for the same quality in the area. Slices are a good deal if you catch the right day/special.Parking: Very limited parking in the front, limited and tight in the back.“

“Rocco's pizza is our favorite pizza restaurant on the vineyard. The veggie pizza is our favorite as well as the freshly made salads. The staff is so friendly, kind and pleasant. It's a great place to grab a slice at lunch or dinner, order pizzas and salad when you get together with friends, or sit outside and enjoy your food.Parking: There is plenty of parking. I have never had trouble parking when picking up pizza or eating it there.“

“Weve been their sister restaurant in Easton and loved it,this location did not disappoint either.Beautifully decorated in old Italian style,impeccable service and the food is top notch!Ceasar salad 1st,delicious housemade dressing.If you love lasagna,the meat version is a must get!If youre a seafoodie like me,the Seafood Saute was incredible,giant shrimp and scallops plus a ton of lobster meat with a cream sauce,asparagus and pea pods!Highly recommended!(check out Wifeys pix below)“