14 Best American Restaurants in Belmar

Sonny's Grille American • $
821 Belmar Plaza, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Sonny's Famous Italian Hot Dog
Rocky's Philly Cheese Steak
Chicken Sandwich
The Jersey Shore
The Rambo Burger
Fried Pickles
French Fries
Cheeseburger
Chicago Dog
Pulled Pork

“I bring my family here all the time. They have excellent dogs at a reasonable price. Haven't been disappointed yet.Parking: Large lot. There has always been a spot available near by.Kid-friendliness: My daughter loves going. She likes the food and always has a good time looking at the decor.“

4.8 Superb56 Reviews
Hoagitos Sandwich Shop • $
807 Belmar Plaza, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Fubar Fries Travel Channel Feature
Forbidden Chicken Sandwich
Southern Comfort Sandwich
Fubar Fries with Cheese
Fresh Cut Fries
Risotto Balls
Nashville Hot
Pork Sandwich
Dude Ranch
Hamburger

“From ownership/management to the cooks to the people taking your order, Hoagitos is the epitome of what a great local business is all about! They’ve been killing it for as long as they’ve been around, and always continue to get better and better every time we go there (which is often ?).Also- FUBAR fries. Don’t think- just do it!“

4.7 Superb54 Reviews
Mike's Giant Submarines Sandwich Shop • $
700 8th Ave, Belmar

“When I ate at Jersey Mike's around the corner their tasted like paper. I took it and placed it in water and it dissolved. Their was nothing on my sandwich. Their prices may be cheaper but you are getting less than a SUBWAY SANDWICH. Mike's was the second original store. The point Beach store owned by Pete Cancro decided to franchise but Bobby Pable who owns the Belmar one stayed original. Bobby has been there now for over 42 years. Bobby is one of the nicest people you will ever meet.The staff comes with years of professional experience. Great personalities. I now live in Florida. I grew up in Belmar. When I visit, I always get their famous cheese steaks.Jersey Mike's can use all the celebrities they want just like subway it will never deter me from going to Bobby Pables shop.?????“

4.7 Superb40 Reviews
McCann's Tavern Bar • $
1704 Main St, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Steak Bites

“We just discovered this bar. It was recently refreshed - Clean, comfortable, and bright. Forget the old McCann's. Yay! A real happy hour - 12-6 every day. We're eating through the menu. So far, everything is excellent! We've had the wings - so fresh and hot. Quesadilla was hot and a generous portion. Shepherds pie to die for. Maryann is awesome.“

4.7 Superb29 Reviews
Side Door Eatery Deli • $
1709 Main St, Belmar

“I have been coming to this hidden gem for years and only getting around to letting the world know about it now. Owner operated family eatery with great fresh menu selections served up with a side of good ole fashioned jersey sarcasm. Clever and witty and always giving, Lori and Richie will welcome you with open arms and accommodate best they can. Current covid climate keeps them as a "take out" only but, that hasn't kept them from serving up the best breakfast and lunch! Call and order or trot over in person to get your grub on. Mask up! It's respectful not political ?“

4.8 Superb13 Reviews
Beckman's Deli Deli • $
704 10th Ave, Belmar

“This Food Is AMAZINGGGGGG! I Got The Breakfast Platter & WOW. Breakfast Potatoes Are Seasoned to A T . The Eggs Are Great & Cheesy & The Bacon ?? TOP TIER & Crunchy !!! First Time Customer & Now I Will Never Go Anywhere Else.“

4.4 Superb10 Reviews
Wall Country Kitchen American • $
2510 Belmar Blvd i5, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Bacon or Sausage & Eggs
Pork Roll and Eggs
Sandwich

“Love the place old style, very classic, familiar and vintage at the same time, the service was espectacular, the only waitress I saw (Zaidy i think was her name) was amazingly nice and sweet, food was 8 out of 10, great flavor/ presentation but the potatoes were extremely greasy and the maple syrup wasn't the authentic one.“

4.2 Good21 Reviews
Anchor Tavern Bar & Grill • $$
713 Main St, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Fried Pickles
Anchor Nachos
Steak Bites
Wedge Salad
Baja Bowl
Sandwich
Burger
Fries
Wings

“Took a daytrip to Belmar and decided to check out Anchor Tavern. The bartender Lindsey was friendly and accommodating. She recommended the wings which were cooked perfectly with their house bbq. 10/10! Manager Emerald made me feel welcomed and was very pleasant to talk to. Great service, great atmosphere. I imagine the Anchor is the place to be in the summer time. Check it out!“

4.1 Good106 Reviews
801 Craft Kitchen & Spirits American • $$$
801 Main St 2nd Floor, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Halibut over Polenta

“This beautifully decorated space is a true gem. Cocktail menu is imaginative and the food wondrous! The menu is not overwhelming large but well curated featuring dishes which change seasonally. Our first visit was for a birthday and four of us were thrilled to be seated at the chef's table. Two of us dined last night and sat at the bar which offers a full menu. So between us we have tasted most appetizers and the halibut, pork, pasta, short rib entrees and cannot think of one thing we would change. It really should be noted that the staff there is among the most pleasant, kind and professional we have ever encountered. The bartender and servers are so informative and friendly and the chef is hands on and ensures the diners are having a very special experience! We are looking forward to our next visit!“

4.1 Good49 Reviews
Boathouse Bar & Grill Bar • $$
1309 Main St, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Is Blackened Steak Bites
Longboard Burger
Loaded Nachos
Potato Skins

“I love the Boathouse, I just wish that I could bring my children here, we stayed veiled and we were held back and could not go forward. Excellent food here I highly recommend it.Vegetarian options: Delicious vegetarian menu , all of the dishes are very goodKid-friendliness: Kid friendly atmosphere“

4 Good27 Reviews
Klein's Fish Market Seafood • $$
708 River Rd, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Steamed King or Snow Crab Legs
12 Oysters Half Shell
Steamed Lobsters
Boom Boom Shrimp
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish and Chips
Waffle Fries
Drunken Clams
Fish Tacos
Crab Cakes

“I thought this place was way overpriced. I got the clam bake which I expected to be a whole mess of seafood for $60 but was 1 lobster and maybe 3 of each, clams, muscles, scallops and shrimp.The food was delicious and the service was good. The atmosphere is great with the water views. It was kind of cold where we dined though at this time of year. It gets a little loud with the bar and a band.“

4 Good99 Reviews
Jacks By The Tracks Bar & Grill • $$
703 10th Ave, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

The Cheese Burger with Pork Belly
Pasta with Butter
Charcuterie Board
The Cheeseburger
Clams Casino
Pretzel
Wings

“First time visiting here as we celebrated a long time friends' birthday. Our table of 10 were all over the board as to ordering and I didn't have the luxury of asking their thoughts on their dish. My wife and I ordered one of the specials, a broiled grouper florentine with cherry tomatoes in a butter sauce. Done just right, with an ample side of asparagus and an even larger dollop of mashed potatoes which came on a separate plate!!!!This was executed beautifully, and I have no doubt that it was the right choice. Fwiw, it's a bar, with outdoor seating, ....a real nice room on what was a beautiful night. The menu smacks of pub grub, but we were ecstatic as to our grouper dish. There is a limited entree menu and I have no doubt that the kitchen stars on any of which is on the menu or their special menu for the evening. We were there to catch the birthday girls' cousin who plays there each first and last Wednesday. Frank with his Gibson is an amazing musician who along with Tommy on saxs (soprano, tenor & baritone, along with flute) with Jerry on the congas just tore through a musical itinerary that had them covering George Benson, Carlos, War, to changing gears and doing Neil, and Dylan. They were great and not to be missed. There's so much music to be had down here, be it AP, Bradley, etc. Not many had music as what went down last night at Jacks. There were also more than a few people who were there for Frank and Tommy. Very cool place. Waitresses rock and make sure you're taken care of.“

3.8 Good82 Reviews
Joe's Bagel and Grill Bagels • $
801 Main St, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Pork Roll Egg and Cheese on Poppy Bagel
Pork Roll with Egg & Cheese
Breakfast Sandwich
Specialty Bagel
Crumb Cake

“Should’ve never let go the handsome kid behind the counter but wow does this place make a great bagel. Originally went for the hot boy at the register but now go strictly for a fantastic bacon egg and cheese. Charlie who used to work at joes bagels please call me!“

3.5 Good40 Reviews
Marina Grille Bar & Grill • $$
905 NJ-35, Belmar

Customers` Favorites

Linguine White Clam Sauce
New England Clam Chowder
Fresh Flounder Sandwich
Clams on a Half Shell
Crab Spinach Fondue
Hot Lobster Roll
Ahi Tuna Nachos
Citrus Calamari
Lobster Bisque
Grilled Octopus

“Marina Grille is a great bar/restaurant. Located right next to Shark River where you can see a beautiful view of the sunset. The waiter was very nice and courteous. We ordered light; appetizer’s, salads and pizzas. All were delicious and well cooked! Our daughter was celebrating her 21st birthday , the waiter went out of his way to make her feel special. We are truly contented with our time at Marina Grille. It’s highly recommended if you’re in the area.“

3.6 Good153 Reviews
Loading...
map Map