15 Best Ice Cream Shops near Lakehurst

“You know if there is a line on a cold day the ice cream must be good. And it was. This ice cream shop is tucked in a cute small town downtown area in Lakehurst. The young ladies were friendly who scoop there. The flavors and sizes are on a whiteboard so you can formulate your selection while in line. There are a few tables to sit outside and you order from a window nearby. The banana fudge in a small sundae is a cup of happiness. The creamy banana has ripples of fudge. Add fudge sauce if you need more chocolate. The rocky road was delicious too pair that with their marshmallow sauce. No matter your flavor it will be enjoyable. Whether it be sundae, cone, or cup, it is a perfect place to get your dessert on!“

“Miss Mindy's homemade ice cream is out of this world, with fun and unique flavors that change regularly - you'll never get bored! And for my vegan friends, they have a fantastic selection of vegan flavors that are just as delicious. The atmosphere is vibrant and inviting, perfect for hanging out with friends or enjoying a sweet treat solo. The staff are always friendly and helpful, making every visit a delight. Highly recommend! ?✨“

“Wonderful addition to the area- delicious food and drinks, bright and airy atmosphere, and such a friendly owner! I go here often with my family and it’s one of our favorite places to go for a delicious coffee & pastry!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options!“

“Clean, quick service this time. I love the taro tea with almond milk. Other places I've had it taste like your drinking dirt but not here. No place to sit and eat if you want to hang out. Just a few lawn chairs along the wall while you wait. Very small parking lot. It's an in-and-out-and-on-your-way place.“

“The food is exceptional and consistent! It’s nice to have local business like this thrive. The owners are awesome people that collaborate with other businesses in the area; bringing everyone up with them, that’s the way small business should be. Try a lettuce wrapper classic burger with old bay fries; you won’t be dissapointed.“

“We love coming here. Always friendly service and fresh. The only reason I'm removing a star is because on our last visit the employee was wearing gloves and took out money and made change. She did not change her gloves and proceeded to go package up cinnamon buns, a big no-no in food safety. She was young and maybe doesn't understand how gloves work. I'm just hoping by leaving this review that maybe the manager/owner can go over food safety with all the employees.“

“I recently visited Sundaes, and I was pleasantly surprised by the efficiency of their service. Despite the anticipation of a long wait, our orders were ready in less than 10 minutes. The variety of ice cream flavors and toppings they offer is impressive, providing customers with countless options. I must say, the quality of the ice cream was exceptional, and my wife and nephew shared my enthusiasm for their choices. Sundaes is definitely a great place to get some ice cream“

“Rebecca and her mom, Tammy Sue, are super friendly ladies. All their items are very fresh daily and delicious. I love their bagels fresh each day from Staten Island. The crumb cake is out of this world. Give this place a try. You won't be disappointed.“

“Nostalgia plus great food and ice cream? Yes, please! Menu is refreshed and yummy, with lots of fresh produce and healthier options. My clam chowder and half chicken salad was fabulous. Even the sliced egg was thoughtful. The frozen yogurt is perfection. Friendly’s will always be my favorite. Wish we had one in Hampton, VA!“

“The staff here is so kind and sweet and the whole menu looks so delectable ? Tried their Iced Matcha Latte w/ Strawberry Purée & The Club Pretzel Sandwich and it was one of the best I’ve tried, very yummy and would be happy to come back here “

“Came on a Motzai Shabbos.Short line and the workers were quick.Got to medium cones with sprinkles.Size wise the medium was huge.Ice cream was standard Kosher soft serve, no complaints there.They also had a section with gifts, balloons, etc.Definitely great option if you have a craving for some Cholov Yisroel and aren’t looking for anything high end.“

“I attended this whimsical shop on a whim while driving around. I asked for their chocolate flavor and a strange, larger boy with glasses was working at the counter. Once he heard I was ordering chocolate, his eyes lit up. He went into the back and reappeared 5 minutes later. I heard a distant grunt but it was worth it when he delivered a cup of ice cream because I have never had such a unique and beautiful cup of ice cream before!“

“Tons of flavors to choose from! The staff was super friendly and even told us the top 3 flavors. Extremely colorful and bright within the store. I wish there was a table or two inside the store. There are a lot of tables outside though. I love that they offer a wide variety of toppings. It was so good that we went back for seconds the next day! My friend purchased two kinds of fudge. It didn't taste as fresh and rich as she would have liked.“

“Good old fashioned Ice Cream with ALL the trimmings you can think up of. HotCake to Banana Split,Steaming fudge and the works.Youll be surprised at how popular and full the joint will be on a hot Sunday BUT the lines move very quick and overall there is a friendly feel to the dininh experience.“