50 Best American Restaurants near Mount Olive

“We go to Chilis quite often and are always welcomed with open arms! Our waitress Alexis is the best, and is always making sure our little ones food order comes out not long after being seated so he can eat right away! Our son also has food allergies and the staff is always very accommodating to make sure he’s given safe foods to eat. The manager Edgar is always checking on us and making sure all is good and everyone is happy. If he gets a quick minute he even helps keep our son entertained by giving him a quick tour of the kitchen! It’s so nice to go to a place and be treated like family :-)“

“Love this place! It is BYOB or you can order a bottle of wine. They do not serve by the glass or have any other alcohol. They have a chefs tasting menu in addition to the 3 or 5 course meal. You may have to ask for it, but it's worth it! Food is always phenomenal.“

“I finally got to Andy's after everyone telling me I had to try it out. I was not disappointed! If you are a fan of hotdogs, you must try what Andy has to offer. I tried The Pig Dog and a new option that wasn't even on the menu yet. He warned me it would be a LOT of food and he wasn't kidding, but it was so good I managed to finish it all. Try it out, then go back and try again!I will definitely be returning.“

“I cannot say more about how happy and easy going the atmosphere and service of this place is. Each time we dine in, it’s like walking into our home with the family. The food is great, always conversations happening and friendly staff, no matter how early or late in the afternoon you go.Parking: Parking is available on street or back of place.Kid-friendliness: Area is small but able for kids to watch the tv or sit comfortably.“

“Excellent family atmosphere to dine in. Our greeting when my family and I walked in was so welcoming. The waitress were very nice and friendly. They looked like they enjoyed working there. The food was very flavorful and not overpowered with salt. The buffalo chicken egg roll was delicious. My little one enjoyed the mac n cheese with a grilled cheese (just cheddar). I ate some of her meal too! LOL. I had the meatloaf with mash and gravy and sauteed green beans. This entree hit the spot. My husband had the chicken tenders and fries. The tenders were lightly coated and seasoned just enough. Now I know when people hear GF dessert, they're turned off. Nope, the GF Black and white cake for dessert was very moist, lightly sweetened, and delicious. This place was fantastic. I will return and recommend that you try it.“

“Gatwyns II is a very good neighborhood restaurant/ bar. The food (Portuguese Mussels and Pizza) are great but the beer choices are very poor. Lack of attention from the bar tender can be too frequent but the table service is strong. Definitely recommended, some areas could use improvement but generally happy with this place.“

“Jose and Anif are the absolute BEST hosts at any restaurant my family has ever visited. Not only are they extremely polite with wonderful customer service skills, they are fast and efficient and keep the entire flow of people moving which is crucial to the operation of the entire restaurant. I am super impressed with these two employees, and would come back to dine here again simply because of them. Also, thank you so very much for going above and beyond to give my son a memorable and special birthday experience that he will always remember. You both deserve a promotion to leadership positions - and my family appreciates everything you did. Thank you soooo much!!! ?❤️?“

“We've had lunch here about 10 times this year, and we really like it. Wish we had discovered it 24 years ago!We've had a few Summer dinners on the back patio sitting by the Raritan river headwaters, just a babbling brook at this point. It's enchanting! Try it!“

“Always a favorite when traveling through NJ or PA. I can't help it- I crave these delicious, fresh burgers with the toppings bar so that you can make it just perfect! And after all these years they still have the same amazing buttered bund and potato-wedge fries :)“

“Vegetarian options: The menu includes a falafel wrap. I believe they are most popular for their wings. For vegetarians and vegans they have tofu and falafel "wings" with 350 different sauce combinations! The best vegan wings I ever had!“

“First visit to Alice’s. We will return. Fun bar downstairs with outside heated seating looking over the lake. The food was ok. Steak was ordered rare and that came out perfect. The Salmon though was over cooked. Sides were fine though the vegetables were a mix of warm and cold. Service was great. Nice people.“

“We are new to the area, so we stopped in for a quick bite and drink.Its a nice sized place, well spaced out so you dont feel like you are on top of the next table.The staff was quick, attentive and professional.The food- AMAZING. I ordered the grilled octupus and want to come once a week to just get that. My girlfriend ordered the corned beef spring rolls and they hit the spot as well.We will def be back to explore more of the menu, as those 2 items alone have us wanting more.Parking: Is a lot of traffic but people come out and you park easyKid-friendliness: YesWheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“Stopped here after church and was pleasantly surprised. The owner greeted us and sat us immediately. You can genuinely see his care and pride in the restaurant. The service was outstanding. Our daughter was the only child there but they all fussed over her. We really appreciated that. They also made menu modifications for her with no issues. We all loved our food. Portions were plenty and we all brought home some leftovers. Oh and get the beets if you are a beet person. They were fantastic!“

“The clams in wine sauce were so salty it was insane. They hurt mine and my partners tongues. Otherwise the food was good. The teriyaki salmon was amazing!!!! We also had their winterberry sangria which tastes exactly how you think it would--the mulled cider was the standout of that drink. The pub is very small town Irish pub style. It was cute.“

“It was a Thursday evening and we sat in the bar. We ordered off of the Chefs Tasting menu. We both ordered a salad and had the salmon entree which was deliciously perfect. Then we got to order a dessert because all the were included in the 29.99 price! It was excellent. We also had wine with our dinner.“

“We have always enjoyed coming to Gladstone Tavern for dinner, but I can now recommend it for an event as well! We hosted a 70th birthday party for about 30 people in the upstairs room. Everything was excellent. The food and service were amazing, and Sue Farkas was wonderful to work with.“

“Wow. The Black River Barn has outdone themselves again. What I remember growing up is an older pub feel with ok food, that has changed. It's now the most reasonably priced, delicious, kid and adult friendly food in a good part of Northern NJ. The atmosphere is palpable and full of life. Everyone loves their service, food, and drinks along with the prices. Can't say enough good about a restaurant I once wrote off as an older crowd. If you haven't visited in a while, give it another chance and they WILL impress you.“

“Our experience at The Windlass restaurant for Easter Brunch was simply outstanding! From the moment we arrived, we were greeted with warm hospitality and a festive atmosphere that set the tone for a memorable dining experience with family.The selection of food at the brunch buffet was exceptional, with a wide variety of delicious options to satisfy every palate. From traditional brunch favorites to inventive chef specialties, each dish was beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. The freshness and quality of the ingredients were evident in every bite, and we appreciated the attention to detail in every aspect of the meal.The ambiance of the restaurant was charming and inviting, with stunning views of Lake Hopatcong adding to the overall atmosphere. The staff were attentive and accommodating, ensuring that our dining experience was nothing short of perfect.Overall, our Easter Brunch at The Windlass exceeded our expectations in every way. We left feeling thoroughly satisfied and grateful for the wonderful memories created with family. We cannot wait to return and indulge in more of the culinary delights that this gem of a restaurant has to offer.“

“We had the pleasure of throwing my daughter's baby shower at Stone Water on St. Patrick's Day. From beginning to end, it was a complete success. Karissa worked tirelessly with me to ensure that the entire planning process was seamless and that our event would be perfect! Perfect is an understatement!!! The event exceeded all of our expectations - the room was beautiful, the staff was incredible to work with and the food was out of this world! Family and friends are still raving about the event and of course, my daughter was equally floored. We will definitely be returning for future events and truly cannot say enough about how wonderful it was to work with Karissa and all of the staff at Stone Water!“

“This diner eclipses all others in NJ. Peter does a fantastic job in serving the customers and pays attention to details. Only one thing needs changing to get the coveted 5 star rating; Please procure a higher quality bacon. The sausages and the rest were superb!“

“Hidden Gem we found on our way from NYC to the Poconos. The owner, Mattar, who has been running this great restaurant for 40 years, seated us. Very nice ambiance and a robust menu. The most difficult part was deciding between so many delicious choices. We settled on sharing the Goat Cheese and Beet salad, cheddar broccoli soup, mushroom flatbread, and the short ribs, followed up with cappuccino. We loved everything and can't wait to come back. Thank you for the great food and great service!“

“On vacation nearby & visited the Beacon on several occasions over last few weeks for drinks & food. Delicious, particularly recommend crab dip, seafood flatbread & burgers.Really enjoyed the live music and trivia night!Can’t wait to visit during the warmer months and spend time on the deck.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free catered for.“

“The burgers were ok,nothing special being I'm a butcher.The service was superb!!It's a nice place for date night with your wife or girlfriend,it's laid back!One thing that bothers me when we go out is everything still over priced!!This inflation is out of control, this dinner should have cost about $45.00 including TIP.They say things are getting better, where I ask??Things were so much better beforeParking: leaving the pub is a bit difficult pulling out onto traffic!“

“This is the first time I've visited there and I was so pleasantly surprised at how very cozy and cute this beautiful restaurant is. You automatically feel comfortable just walking through the door. Quaintly decorated. Old school comfortable ? I love that feel!The food?? 10 Stars Excellent!!The drinks? Big and Excellent as well. Bathroom has a very comfortable charm.Very clean and a place you want to hang out in with friends or family all night. They do catering as well!I highly recommend this Awesome Restaurant!!“

“Went for lunch today and everything was so delicious! Ordered a Brooklyn panini and Polo’s punch. Shared an order of pesto garlic park boneless wings which are a must have everytime we come. Service at the bar was amazing even for it being 12“

“I went there with both of my daughters & my grandchildren that are 4 years old and 1 1/2 & we enjoy ourselves. The reason we went here was because the donate a percentage of the bill to the local high school. Staff friendly & atmosphere.“

“Loved the meal and environmentUnfortunately my meal was cut short when someone walked in with latex balloons.I am severely allergic to latex and had to vacate immediately. Left half meal andbucket beverage on the table.Please encourage patrons to celebrate with mylar balloons. I am not the only individual with a latex allergy.Thank you“

“Went with 4 people - not too many 4-tops. I’m guessing it’s mostly 1-2 tops on purpose. Short wait for a table but VERY much worth it. Food was delicious. I had a basic Bacon & Cheese but my friend had the breakfast tacos and said they were also delicious :)“

“I past but this place very often and it always catches my eyes, because of it's unique A-frame log cabin look. Also, that it has a sign that says 'Drive-Thru' and next to it is another sign that says 'We Sell Beer'...always shake my head and have a chuckle!! One day decided to pop in and grab a dog. The inside is a bit odd, as the outside. The interior decor is a mashup of ski log cabin, a diner, and a hot dog stand...hilarious!! The staff at the counter was friendly and patiently waited for me to decide on what I wanted...breakfast or lunch...brunch times are the toughest!! Their menu board is larger than expected, also they serve breakfast all day. So, I got the breakfast sandwich to go and a hotdog with fries and a shake to eat in. The food was ok, a little pricey for average size portions. The staff was nice as they brought the food to the table. As I was sitting there looking around, taking in the unique decor once again. Not saying it's bad, just needs a few things updated. One area I enjoyed looking at...was a display case with the owner's father U.S. Army service jacket from WWII with a couple of his medals, photos, and letters. Definitely respect and appreciated that display of that history. One day I would like to come back to help them update that display case.“

“Stopped by with another couple for drinks after dinner elsewhere. Nice bar and pleasant atmosphere. Bartender was knowledgeable and friendly. Although I only had a Sambuco Black, it was served appropriately with three coffee beans. Would stop by this bar again. Maybe even do dinner here next time.“

“We have eaten there several times and it is always delicious. We want to give special appreciation to Rachel, your manager, for her special caring and sensitivity to our needs. In today's world, where one struggles, especially if old like we are, to speak to a live human being, when you are able to converse with a person who is actually listening to what you said, this is rare. Add to that delicious fresh food and you have a winner. Tonight we had fresh large shrimps with a most delicious home made cocktail sauce. Fresh crab cakes with a fabulous remoulade, and a chocolate mousse to die for as dessert. We ordered too much and have to save some for tomorrow. We live in town, and are happy to see the names of so many out of town visitors appreciate Chesapeake Tavern.“

“The hotel looked very nice and modern with a great entryway. The rooms were well maintained and clean especially the beds, so comfortable. The staff was excellent especially Steve at the bar who helped us have a great evening after the wedding!“

“Lunch - was just right.We all ate from the office and the owner - Joe was attentive , food on point and cooked just right.A veggie , a meat eater and a starving crew enjoyed french onion soup, matzah ball soup and the winner chicken noodle.Next round was the blue cheese burger , Salad with veggies tacos and so much more.Staff was great , food was A++ and plenty of parking for 4 people.We will be back - thank you, H. Diner.Dietary restrictions: We all had different needs and vegetarian was met , medium rare meat was achieved .Wheelchair accessibility: A separate entrance for wheel chair is available.“

“Lakeside tavern is a great place to go! The bartenders are amazing. Michele is my favorite to visit every time I go. The line dancing every week is so much fun! It’s great when they have entertainment. They really should charge a cover charge because you’re getting a lot. I hope they continue to Linedancing every week because it’s a lot of fun and the food is amazing. The chef there does the most amazing job!“

“I recently visited BEX in Califon , NJ while out on a group bicycle ride and it was a great experience. This coffee stop is cozy and inviting, and the staff is friendly and very welcoming - especially important for cyclists. The coffee and treats were varied & delicious. I would highly recommend this coffee shop to anyone but specially cyclists , looking for a great cup of coffee & a treat.Enjoy !“

“I grew up with my parents taking my brother and l to this Friendly’s location, usually a celebration or simply a night off of cooking for my mom. Because of this, l always associated Friendly’s with happy times and have a deep affection for the chain. I understand the intervening years since the 1980’s have not been kind to the company, but they continue on and so do we. Tonight my wife and l had dinner here. The food was simple and tasty just as it’s always been. Our server, Lis, was a delightful young woman, pleasant and efficient and on point. And what trip to Friendly’s would be complete without some ice cream? That l can enjoy a meal and the same Reese’s Pieces sundae l remember 40 years later pleases me immensely. I do hope Friendly’s can pull off a turn around. It would be a shame for this piece of Americana to vanish. If you haven’t been to Friendly’s in a while, why not stop by and support this local establishment? I’m glad l did.“

“Four friends had lunch today. We got there right at opening. There was only one server, tending bar and waiting on tables. She was excellent! Our drinks and our food came in a timely manner. Her attitude was friendly and professional. Our food was very good, with great portions.“

“My family came for the grand opening ! The new owners cook amazing! You can get Mexican like nothing I have ever had , right down to diner classics like melts , burgers and eggs . I tried something I’ve never had . It was Stir fried veggies with orange chicken and I’m so excited I have enough for lunch tomorrow lol thank you for bringing something great to this town ☺️“

“I think this place is really cute and has great tea. The downside is that the afternoon tea portions are TEENY TINY. I've been to other afternoon tea locations, and never had finger sandwiches so small. It was cute, but if it weren't for the delicious scone, I still would have been hungry. If you're going for afternoon tea, definitely don't do it on an empty stomach“

“Charley's Tavern impressed me with their prime rib—flavorful, perfectly cooked, and a true delight for the taste buds. The inviting atmosphere and attentive staff further enhanced the overall dining experience. I highly recommend Charley's for a fantastic meal!“

“Our entrees were very good and the portions were just right. Our waiter was excellent and didn't check on us very 2 minutes., but was there for drink replenishment when required. My only complaint was the drink prices, thought $5.00 for Miller Lite was a little steep and will keep my future refills to a minimum.“

“This diner is definitely a favorite stopping place when we are back in our home state! The lobster bisque is not to be missed but only available on the weekend. They had a beef and barley soup, reminded me of home.The server was very friendly. Staff was joyful. ❣️“

“Surprisingly good Irish food. We stopped in on a random Wednesday night while staying in the area. There was some bingo going on and it was not very crowded. I always feel the need to try corned beef or a Reuben any time I visit any Irish eatery. I asked the server how the Reuben egg rolls (yes Reuben egg rolls!) were and she said they are a big hit. So I got those as an appetizer and they were very good and something very unique. I also had the burger with corned beef on it and it was cooked perfect and the corned beef had just the right amount of tang to it. My daughter loved her fries and mozzarella sticks and filled up on those before she even got to try her Mac and cheese. Overall the food was delicious, the server was incredibly friendly and helpful and was extremely patient with a 4 year old that was a bit fussy from traveling all day. I'll certainly return the next time I'm in the area.“

“Nice, cozy spot, family restaurant with a nice bar. My daughter loved her ziti with meatball. My wife really enjoyed her chicken over pasta, and I was surprised by the quality of the prime rib king cut. The prime rib was fresh, tender, and juicy. It was a bit under seasoned, but it didn't matter at all. The quality of the meat was really impressive. There was no photo of dessert, but the apple crisp was warm and delicious.“

“Best wings in the area. I always get the slammin hot and ask them to add some sauteed garlic to the sauce. It's a game changer. Great family restaurant and bar. I've had drinks with adults and had wonderful family meals with my toddlers. Great service and the prices are reasonable.“

“Food was great. Hot fresh and served quickly. Open floor plan and there were 2 large parties going on so for a quiet evening out this wouldn’t be your place. But for good food and great service it’s a great place. Remember cash only !Parking: Large parking lot but seams to be more than enough for their seating capacity.“

“BEST WINGS IN AREA - when it comes to wings i really don't play. it's hard to find the right wing spot. marley's been my to-go wings spot for the past 2 years and they never disappoint. Dining in is a dope option too the atmosphere is cool for both dates, hangouts or just dinners with family. if your going i'd get the mammas chicken sandwich it's amazing. can't stress it enough. if your deciding in between marley's and some other spot i'll save you the time and money. GO TO MARLEYS.“

“All in all we very much enjoyed our night out to PH Steakehouse. Drinks were properly made and they had Monkey 47 (my favorite gin that can be hard to find at restaurants) and we enjoyed everything we ordered. They start the night with complimentary Parker house rolls and a seasoned olive oil. I sprung for the French onion soup, which I must admit was one of the best I’ve ever had. Our entrees were enjoyable, however my wife’s medium filet came out closer to medium rare. Having cooked many steaks I fully understand this can happen and they were happy to refire it to my wife’s content. I got the swordfish entree which was cooked perfectly (grill marks and all) and was pleasant enough. My one gripe is the rice and veggies that came on the plate screamed for updating. They were reminiscent of a restaurant from the 70’s, completely bland and felt as if they were there to fill the plate rather than to enjoy. We paid a little more than I would of liked considering I’ve had better meals at the price point, but all in all I would return here.“

“Stopped in for a late breakfast with my husband and Dawn made the most beautiful hot chocolate! They are so friendly and hospitable it’s like eating at a friends house. I have been coming here for over 20 years and have never had a bad experience.“

“Due to laryngitis, I was unable order specifically what I wanted & was brought out a similar item from what I wanted. Bora, our server, corrected it immediately. I appreciated the quick & efficient service. He is a delightful young man & an asset to IHOP.“