12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Nutley

“I’ve been looking for a Neapolitan pizza place for a bit and I just happened to see one in my own neighborhood! The pizza was incredible. The dough was perfect and the toppings complemented eachother really well. Staff was so warm and welcoming. It’s a cute little spot and feels cozy and comfortable inside. Will be coming back! Also always a bonus when the staff is respectful of my service dog!“

“If you are looking for GOOD NY style pizza, you need to try Nonno's. There are many pizzerias in the Clifton / Nutley area, but in my opinion the pizza here is one of the best I have had. Sauce is favourable. Cheese is good quality unlike some places where they fall off the moment you pick up the slice. Service is super friendly and accommodating. It's a small place with a feeling of a neighbourhood-go-to pizzeria“

“After ordering from countless restaurants in Nutley, my family and I have always found ourselves going back to Amore. The pizza here is phenomenal and is truly a hidden gem in town. A part from having amazing food, they’re also extremely generous and caring. I would like to take time to appreciate their donation to the Nutley Red Cross.“

“Post Covid, it seems like the Marinara Sauce in NJ has become somewhat like what they serve in California. Hence, I was happy to learn about Bell Paese (196 Franklin Ave Nutley NJ), a place known for their sauce and fresh seafood,

I walked in Bell Paese and right away noticed Scungilli and Calamari in Marinara Sauce on the menu. Still somewhat skeptical, I ordered a slice of pizza. Indeed, both the crust and sauce were different. One slice and I was a believer.

I next requested Joe (one of the owners) to make me a Scungilli & Calamari Sub. After some 10, maybe 12 minutes of robust discussion, Joe convinced me to try their Shrimp Parm Sub instead. Dominick (the other brother and co-owner) offered a sample portion of Spicy Mussel Marinara for being a good sport.

Let me pause here and tell you that a sign at the counter at Bell Paese warns you that yelling, and screaming are possible (think, “The Bear”). The sign requests you to ignore everything, to sit back, and enjoy the food. For sure this is a family run establishment, the emphasis is solely on good food.

The Shrimp Parm Sub was exceptional. Amazing sauce.

The spicy Mussel Marinara was out of this world good. It was made by Dominick. Joe assured me that the next time I visit, the Mussel Marinara will be better because typically he makes it. Needless to say, we had another round of robust discussion as to who, Joe or Dominick, makes a better Spicy Marinara.

I cannot wait to go back for the Scungilli & Calamari and also for Zupa de Pesce. At Bell Paese you get real food, made by real people. Places like Bell Paese are hard to find. Go there with an appetite, enjoy the food and enjoy the company.“

“Ritaccos is a foundation Pizzeria here in Nutley, their food is fresh and always delicious, the owner is one of the nicest people you could possibly meet. The pizza is fresh and amazing. I could not say enough great things about this restaurant“

“LOVE THE PHILLY CHEESE STEAK PIZZA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!“

“The new owners approach to pizza is great, it’s a thin slice now compared to the previous owner. I ordered off of slice and the pizza maker was very generous with toppings even if there was a delay. The toppings on my pies were great, the sauce was good, and the cheese was good too. Overall a good experience, would recommend for pickup. Pepperoni and garlic is a solid combo.“

“Best pizza in northern NJ!“

“Amazing stuffed meatballs!“

“***** Omg this place is amazing. Great food fresh and delicious. A friend recommend me this place for their great hamburgers and he wasn’t lying omg there are awesome. The same the pizza and the pasta.“

“Excellent customer service & delicious food. Can’t wait to go again!“

“You are my sons favorite resteraunt in town ! So much so he wrote about it today 😃 Thank you“