13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Nutley

“I had been meaning to go for about a year. A friend and I finally went last night. The waitress was awesome! We ordered an appetizer: bruschetta. We shared a pizza...it was absolutely delish! I heartily recommend this place.Vegetarian options: We had a specialty vegetarian pizza. It had spinach, artichokes, garlic and lemon zest.“

“Perfectly cooked pizza. This place is super consistent which is always a win in my book. Crust has a nice touch of oregano to give it an aesthetically pleasing look. We got the 16 inch plain. Amanda was also super hospitable and made sure we got everything we needed! Will be back“

“Food is amazing! But wow, these young servers are either smoking something before work or just not interested in remembering the little things. Very forgetful on orders, refills and overall paying attention to tables needs. (Clearing table prior to dinner arriving, following up after orders come out to see if anything is needed… the little things that make the difference.)“

“Wasted talent has always been a pet peeve of mine: however, Ralph's pizzeria is not wasted talent...they bring the heat when it comes to their food. First off, the pizza - which is fair to say - has got the crisp, cheese to sauce ratio and taste of a winner. Some say don't be a jack of all trades be a master of one. But do they agree..no! They also make an amazing penne vodka. Don't listen to the negative reviews. They didn't put the thought that I did in my review“

“Have the Chicken Dominick you won't be sorry! Delicious buttery and just the right texture and seasoning. Fresh bread rolls baked on site . I couldn't fit dessert or id tell you about that also I took a bite of my aunts Picatta that was also wonderful. Worth it. There is also parking just before the building.“

“We always pass by this place and we finally had the time to come here. We ordered Pepperoni Pizza and Mussels. They were both really delicious. The place was busy answering the phone for orders and delivery. Staff were really nice. I highly recommend this place if you are nearby the area.“

“Awesome food, phenomenal servings, and great spot. Owner is really great and so are the staff. Some people that rated low here are people taking out their bad days on the staff/owner even when they attempt to rectify whatever issue it is. Hidden gem too since they've been operating for years! I've been eating here since I was in elementary school too! Highly recommended giving this place a shot!“

“Outstanding Italian pizzeria and the best Italian cuisine in Nutley by far.The owners create an authentic, welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel like family. The pasta is divine—cooked to perfection, and the subs are savory from the high-quality ingredients they use. As for the pizza, it's unparalleled in town—crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and an abundance of toppings. Every bite is a taste of genuine Italian craftsmanship. The authenticity and passion for their craft shine through in every dish. This pizzeria is a true gem, setting the bar high for others. Five stars for exceptional food, friendly service, and an all-around delightful dining experience.“

“Just amazing pizza. Cracker thin crust lets you eat slice after slice without feeling bloated. Warning: this place is for serious eaters! Dieters and vegans stay home (although there are vegetable sandwich options!). Try something you think you won't like and I promise you'll love it. I had the Marciano sandwich. It's enough for three meals. Several pounds of the most moist, shredded short rib in its juice topped with frizzled thin onions and melted Swiss on the most perfect long roll. I am drooling from the memory of devouring it. Also, the staff is so polite. And the prices are very fair. You can usually find parking on the side streets. Go and treat yourself! Just try to get a reservation though because they tend to book at lunch and they are almost always booked for dinner.“

“Found this spot on DoorDash. The large pizza is a solid option in the area. A lot of pizza spots have started to cheap out on the ingredients but the last few pie's I got from Loue's have tasted very good. The prices are also very reasonable. I paid $12 for a large plain pie. I have no idea how some places are charging $20 or more even with inflation the way it is. As far as pizza goes, I'm a fan of Loue's. I have to give 4 stars because I was not a big fan of the sandwiches I ordered. The bread was too mushy and I've just had better in the area.“

“Experienced staff, Manager is 100% Always professional and accommodating, come here all the time and NEVER have a problem. Bathrooms are always clean and seating area is clean and sanitary always. FAST carryout pick ups, even when they are busy they still are able to complete all tasks. THANK YOU!!“

“Mamma Mia's, you have my heart. I have never in my life been able to heat up pizza in the microwave and it be just as good as the first time I ate it. I order from Mamma Mia's multiple times a week not only because it's by my apartment, but because it's the best pizza shop I have ever tried. I love the owners, I love the staff. They make their food with love and at a great price, too. They have the BEST disco fries in the area. They also have the best marinara sauce, which I learned from ordering their delicious fried ravioli. I have tried so much from this place, but their pizza is really top notch. The amount of pizzas I've shared with my husband on movie night would shock you. There is never a day my husband and I argue about what is for dinner and end up both saying to each other, "Mamma Mia's?" We have no shame. If I want to be healthy, I go for their salads. If I want to bad, I go for their pizza. I've tried so many menu items from the cheese steak, garlic knots, jalapeño poppers, chicken parmigiana sandwich, grandmas pie, salads, bruschetta, and desserts. I have never had a single bad thing from this place and have never had any leftovers go past 1 day. I love this pizza shop. It deserves way higher reviews than it has. They also followed me back on Instagram without knowing how much of a fan I am. I respect that. As well as their menu deals and lunch specials. Fabulous and UNDERRATED. I've never heated up a chicken bacon ranch and have the ranch actually stay on it when I heat it up. This is THE pizza shop in the area and I can crown it as such because I am the pickiest eater when it comes to QUALITY.“

“Pizza is amazing!! I ordered a thin crust pie (well done of course) and it was cooked to perfection. The sauce has a sweet taste to it that some might not like but I think it’s awesome! The crust was crispy, a little flop, a little greasy but not over the top. I would definitely be stopping here whenever I’m in the mood for pizza. I’ve tried the other places in town and I think this might be the best one.Parking: They have a parking lot. Seems like it can get really tight if this place is ever packed.“