20 Best Italian Restaurants near Port Murray

“The whole Jackson family did an absolutely amazing job for our wedding. The appetizers were amazing, the BBQ truck was amazing, and the desserts were amazing. No more could be asked for“

“Safe and yummy for my GF/DF daughter! Their extensive vegetarian, GF and DF options work well for our family's needs.“

“This is not our first trip here. We are always very happy with the service and the food. It's a nice quiet setting with plenty of cocktails and wines to choose from to go along with your meal. The sea bass and risotto was cooked to perfection, as was the Veal marsala.“

“Great food. Friendly service, nice atmosphere and reasonably priced.“

“Came here with my family for a goodbye dinner, and I have to say it was quite cozy and cute inside. They are a BYOB restaurant, so we brought our own wine and our waiter opened and poured it for us throughout the visit making sure our glasses were always full. I strongly suggest they type up the specials for people to read and to view prices. The waiter told us the specials from memory; so of course, all three of us had questions to ask and the waiter was getting angry that we couldn’t remember all of what he just said. After we order, we receive these absolutely delicious breadsticks and they were gracious enough to bring out seconds! I ordered the meatballs as an appetizer, I thought they were really tasty and juicy! I ordered the Chicken Milanese as my entree. I thought the chicken was a bit dry and super thin, it definitely looked like a large piece of chicken but was very deceiving. I was very excited for dessert because I was told by the lady that everything was homemade. I also work in the restaurant industry; I recognized 3 of the desserts right away being from a restaurant company. She then told me that the Tiramisu was a family recipe of theirs and let me say this, it is a must try for sure. Tiramisu is a favorite of mine and it did not disappoint! The lady also sold me on ordering her cappuccino because she makes them really good; it was good and extra foamy. Overall, it was a nice experience. However, I don’t think I will be coming back anytime soon due to the prices. If I knew 3 meatballs were going to be $19 I would have skipped it. Same for some of the other dishes, especially on the specials menu. I get they are going for a more upscale feel but having your waiter and waitress sit a table away from you eating and talking with other workers doesn’t really give off that vibe.“

“Lived here over 5 years and never checked this place out. My daughter and I went for a quick bite tonight. The pizza was delicious! And everyone was so warm and friendly! I'm from NY and I'm picky about my pizza! Definitely go check them out!!“

“The pizza here is god tier. I was at the Pilot truck stop near there and you know how it is, ya get tired of the same food thats at every truck stop. I searched up pizza near the Pilot and originally i was gonna get dominoes but seein as this place was only like 1.5 miles away i decided to take a chance on this place and wooo booiiiiiii. I had already ordered online and went inside for the pick up sounded like italian music playin, it threw me off(kind of like yo this real italian place?). The guy there idk im assuming he the owner of the place, he was really cool he showed me the pizza and it looked better in person than in the pics no joke.I took it back to the truck stop i was at to eat it there and man that pizza was really good, especially with sauce. All i know is i highly recommend this place if you a trucker and you at the Pilot near there looking for some good pizza, just drop ya trailer at Pilot and come here and then go back to Pilot cuz i know there's always that chance of a tow. Idk what the other food here taste like but im gonna assume the other food taste fire af too. I will be back if im at that same Pilot again to try some other food.“

“Grandmas Pizza to go is the best! I bring it on road trips out of state when visiting friends in Central PA. Market case is brimming with a good variety go food by h the pound. Service is really good and Everything is freshly made in house.“

“I have ordered takeout from here twice and eaten here twice, and we are now considering this our favorite date night spot close to home. Each time, the food was far above my expectations regarding restaurants in Hunterdon County. You would think from the name of the place that it was simply the standard Italian fare, and you would be mistaken. There are Asian, Mediterranean, and American influences as well, making the selection very well rounded, and everything is prepared and presented with obvious care and attention to detail. The sauces are TO DIE FOR. The owner is a very warm gentleman who makes his rounds not only to greet customers but also to provide support to his staff. Don't miss out on this gem!“

“Pino is awesome Greets all his customers and knows them all that is so important and I'm sure all his customers appreciate his big smile when they enter the restaurant The food is fresh and well prepared Great location as well, don't forget BYOB Liquor store right next door which is extremely convenient Highly recommend this cozy restaurant“

“Good Italian food in a great location. Service was just okay - but it could have been an off night. The menu has a good range of options - but not so many that you have to wonder how many of them are good. The was a live band, which was nice. Cocktails were good (not great) too.“

“Just got the BEST Italian food at Galasso's In Lebanon NJ. OMG the bruschetta just melted in our mouths! Lasagna was better than my mother's(sorry Mom). The baked ziti with eggplant was incredible & enough for 2. The sauces on both entrees were ummm, also better than Moms. And Mom was an amazing Italian cook. Went to pick up the food(ready on time) & the pizzas in there looked amazing(next time). The aroma was enough to make you salivate. The guy(owner?) was so nice. Came with salad & bread too! Oh, the escarole & bean soup-another hit. Apparently we were hungry & over ordered. Do not miss this place. Trust me.“

“A terrific experience. Staff was amazing - extremely attentive yet not the slightest overbearing; extremely personable (especially Ari)! Our meals were delicious - fun and unobtrusive ambiance. We'll be coming back with friends in a week for birthday celebration dinner. I Highly recommend Janina's Bistro.“

“Pizza was amazing and calamari was out of this world“

“Very good place to grab a lunch or dinner! The owner works very fast, he was very professional and also the price was good. The food was delicious. Perfectly cooked. I live around the area and it's a perfect spot for a pickup and go meal on a small main street! They do have a tables for sitting inside of the place “

“everything! they are the best around❤“

“Last night I had chicken francese at Franks. I like plenty of lemon tast and that is how it arrived Portion size allowed take home for today“

“We ordered catering yesterday for my sons first birthday party and it was fantastic! We got chicken francese, baked ziti, sausage and potatoes, and grilled veggies. Fantastic prices and amazing food! He even made the chicken francese dairy free since my son cannot eat dairy and everyone said they couldn’t tell and it was the best chicken francese, and so juice! My Italian family raved about all the food and all asked where the food came from! Thank you!!“

“Union county in the house! The best pizza in the area here in warren county .Compares to none other. Tried them all in the 20 years since we moved here. We Always ask for thin crust and it never disappoints. Mangia mangia!“

“We order from Sonny’s more than we would like to admit. Over the weekend, I last minute ordered a grilled chicken salad to go. It was a busy day, and they forgot the chicken. We called and were ready to just drive back and go grab it. They immediately said they were giving it to their delivery driver to add to his drop off. They didn’t have to do that, and we really appreciated it- they definitely did right by us. Also, have to recommend the pierogi pizza and chicken Marsala pizza!“