50 Best Italian Restaurants near Lake Grove

“Recently visited with friends for lunch. Table service was excellent with server explaining the specials along with recommendations on the basic menu items. Dining area was clean and overall ambiance simple but appealing. Ordered the chicken roll which they specifically cooked for me and a vegetable which were cooked to perfection. Overall service was great. Server checked up on us multiple times and we felt right at home, not rushed at all. Restaurant located on the main road but entrance and parking are behind the strip center off Hawkins.“

“Osteria Umbra Restaurant in Smithtown, New York, is a true gem that shines brilliantly with its creativity in food and perfection in service. This exquisite dining destination invites guests into a world where traditional flavors meet innovative culinary techniques, creating unforgettable dishes. Each plate is a masterpiece, prepared with meticulous attention to detail and a deep passion for Italian cuisine's rich heritage. The ambiance is as inviting as the menu, with a warm, welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit special. The staff at Osteria Umbra go above and beyond to ensure every guest feels cherished, making the dining experience flawless from start to finish. Whether it's a casual meal or a special occasion, Osteria Umbra remains a cherished spot among locals and visitors alike, promising an exceptional culinary journey that leaves you longing for your next visit.“

“Once you go to orto, you’ll keep coming back. From the bread pairings, the four course prefix.. everything tastes fresh and absolutely amazing. You can taste the care they put into their food. I also love how the menu is constantly changing with what is fresh during each season. Orto has become my favorite restaurant. Never change! Thank you.“

“Fantastic meal tonight. We had several food allergies including gluten and dairy. They were amazing at making sure that we had several options to meet all of our dietary needs. The owner came out and explained the menu to us. They were unbelievably helpful and the food was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend the gluten-free/dairy free pizza with dairy free/vegan cheese. Our server, Jenna was fantastic! Everything was wonderful.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free and dairy free“

“Excellent!Amazing food, amazing service, exceptionally clean restrooms (it shows you how clean they are if even their restrooms are cleaned that thoroughly!)All our wishes were heard, alterations made without any additional charges or etcA wonderful place on the way to MontaukHope to stop by here again soon ☺️❤️“

“We were a party of 4, and seated right away. The place was very crowded and our drink order was taken and delivered right away. We ordered and shared the arancini and eggplant appetizer and a salad which were all delicious. I had the 28 ounce pork chop which was very tender and perfectly cooked. One of the chef/owners Martin came over to the table and said hello. Our waitress was great and our busboy Hector was very nice. Deserts were the Biscotti and Tartufu. Both great. Highly recommend to visit.“

“So last night we order the islander combo normally the food is delious I don't know they where busy and rushing but the pizza was terriable small slices asked for half pepperoni on one of the pizzas n it was placed on there n got garlic knots they where burnt n the sauce literally was all oil ! So very disappointed they really need to take there time n pay attention to orders n how the food is prepped a little“

“This place is like the Authentic Freshly Made Vegetarian Italian Food Restaurant with Amazing service, it’s like ticking off your bucket list to eat this kind of Delicious Vegetarian Italian Food. We Linguine Primavera with Arrabbiata Sauce, specially made vegetarian for us and Burrata Salad with grilled Vegetables also made vegetarian just for us. These two were made to order and were not on the menu. So whenever you visit you must ask for vegetarian options and the servers will not only recommend you the best but also have it made to your taste.“

“Joey Z's has some of the best breakfast around! I always enjoy coming here for consistently good food and quick service. I had the banana pancakes (which are my go-to) and my mom had the Eggs Benedict which came with potatoes. The staff and owner are so kind and make you want to keep coming back!“

“Been going there for 25 years the best pizza in Patchogue Bellport and surrounding areas Rocco is a great guy and so are his kids friendly courteous and makes pizza for the people that is good five star 10 star 20 star whatever this place is it“

“First time at Linda's & was greeted right away. I had margarita slice which was very good. My husband had a square slice which he said was good. The regular slices didnt look appetizing at all but maybe everyone else ordered a specialty slice so they were out there too long? I choose my slice by the look of freshness. Limited inside seating. There are tables/benches across the street with beautiful views but it was pretty windy so we sat inside. There is a variety of food if you dont want pizza. We will come back again and maybe try a panini or a salad? They also have fish & soup if you dont want pizza“

“A hidden gem in an unlikely spot. The atmosphere was relaxing and calming. Not what I was expecting to see from the outside but once you enter you're transported to a new world. The staff was very friendly and our waitress was so kind. She was attentive, kind, and made sure we were taken care of..... But the food......" amazing". Very flavorful and mouth watering. Meatballs were a hit and the desserts are a must at the end. The drinks were made perfectly. You will be spending a little more than usual but it is so worth it.“

“First time at Ciro's. Greeted immediately. We wanted a certain table so we waitied for them so set up. I think they were a little short on wait staff but there were plenty of buspeople so bread and OO came out fast. Took a little while for the drink order but once he took that the service was excellent. We had a full baked clams (yummy) and Rice balls (5 delicious Arancici in a little ricotta and red sauce, also delicious.) My entree was the pounded Veal Chop Voldestana and it was the size of Home Plate and outstanding. I recommend it. My wife had their signature Lobster Rav. Also top notch. All the food was hot and fresh. Overall and outstanding meal. Not cheap but they offer great value and quality.“

“Met some friends here on a Wednesday night. Our first time here and it won't be my last. First impression was very nice atmosphere when we walked in. Service was tremendous. When we arrived, we were greeted promptly and throughout our dinner multiple people had come around asking if anything was needed including the manager a few times. Food was excellent. A variety basket of fresh breads was set down and we started and shared the calamari which was flavorful and seemed perfectly cooked. Wasn't squishy or rubbery which would be the adjectives I'd use at some other places. I can't remember the name of the dish I had but it included house-made pasta, diced chicken and brown sauce. It was delicious. I'll be coming back with my wife and daughter very soon.“

“Saw this cute cafe from the outside a few weeks back, decided to go tonight with mom and it turned out to be a wonderful restaurant, with so many delicious dish choices and specials! Parking was easy and they were absolutely great in making sure we had the most suitable “accessible” table (thank you Scott!) The service was professional, fast, friendly.. the atmosphere was cozy, warm, and artsy. We will definitely be coming back here more often :)“

“I love this pizzeria the staff is always friendly, place is always clean. The food is delicious and you cannot beat their light and airy garlic knots, and specialty pizza slices. Wish the young owner lots of luck and everyone should definitely give this place a try.“

“We’ve ordered through uber eats twice and have been so happy every time! The margarita pizza and the vodka pie are both great.I was prompted to review with 5 stars because i ordered a ginger ale, and they didnt have any. Not only did they read the order instructions and replace it with a sprite, they also left an apology note on my drink! They not only have stellar food, but they clearly have great people working for them too.“

“Went here to celebrate with my boyfriend. I had the Cajun pasta with blackened chicken and sausage it was delicious! Their house made bread was amazing as well! Our server was attentive but not too overbearing. I will be coming back to try the other dishes. Their tomato sauce is amazing !“

“I was really surprised by this hidden gem. Such a cozy place with really friendly and excellent service and amazing food at a really reasonable price. I definitely recommend La Cova to anyone who’s hungry and wants a nice relaxing experience.“

“Great portions for the price, garlic knots in the break basket were delightful. Italian wedding soup was a little too salty for my liking. The penne arrabbiata with breaded chicken and asparagus was nice, not too spicy. My wife ordered the pesto gnocchi, which is a little on the soft side. The chicken and mushroom were good and the pesto creamy. Service was very attentive and refills came quicker than I could drink them.“

“I had dined at Stella Trattoria only once before, at Christmastime 2022. I can’t for the life of me figure out why I didn’t get back there sooner. This restaurant is spacious, well appointed, and comfortable. We were seated immediately upon arrival, & had drinks in less than 5 minutes. Our waitress, Julie, was the best. The food was nothing short of wonderful! It arrived at the table hot, in very generous portions, and was absolutely delicious! When I took out my “doggie bag” to enjoy a second dinner, I found Julie had marked all our containers making it easy to identify the contents, as well as making sure everything came home, sauce and all! Each one of our party of four thoroughly enjoyed their dinner. Stella Trattoria is FINE DINING.“

“I kept going for pizza alone and most recently started trying the various pasta dishes. There are so many other places in the surrounding area that are well known with a lot more space for indoor dining. I would hands down choose Isabella's for the amount of food you receive and the taste (small space to dine in, but we do take out). My son is a bit of an Italian food addict and we were trying different places to keep it interesting. I just can't believe how good the food is and the price at Isabella's. Why go out of my way to try other places when I have found our favorite? To be continued with more pics as I make my way through the menu....today we got 2 regular, 1 buffalo, chicken Florentine with spinach and kids chicken parm with spaghetti. The bread that comes with the pasta dishes is amazing! There is no need for garlic knots I'd you get this bread.“

“Best Pizza I have had since moving back to Long Island from Florida. The reg pizza was baked to perfection and the specialty slice I had was just as good. I found my new Pizza spot, I have to try every variety of slices they stock. Thanks for a great experience“

“While looking for a quick place to stop for dinner before a LI ducks game, I found this place on maps and decided to give it a try. Just from the look of it, I had a good feeling about it, and I was right. The pizza was amazing, the workers were friendly, and the parking was easy. I will be coming back here anytime I'm on the island.“

“Absolutely amazing food! So fresh, everything is made to order, best eggplant parmesan I have ever had! My daughter had the Carrot Ginger Soup with Mascarpone & Amaretti Crumbles and that was incredible. Service was impeccable, would give it 10 stars if I could!“

“This hidden gem looks like a hole in the wall do not be fooled the food is excellent. The staff amazing and fun and more importantly, the owner is always their! He also great his guests and knows all the regulars names he really cares about his guests. It is not fancy but homey, cozy and fun we love this place! The prices amazing!“

“Have been a regular at Branchinelli for years. Food is always great. Service is good. Even when there is a line to wait, you are called within a reasonable time. Would recommend to everyone. If it is just Pizza, full meal or catering, can't go wrong“

“Love Furcis.The food is great, price isn’t bad, and the people who work here are amazing.Jim, the guy who usually is at the counter, is the nicest person you’ll ever meet.So personable. He greets you with a smile every time.Highly recommend this pizzeria to anyone.“

“So friendly! So nice! Open late and delicious food!!! Something for everyone. Tonight we had everything delivered and I'm so glad!!! We had pizza, knots, the BEST mozzarella sticks, a yummy Greek salad, delicious spanakopita, and baked clams. Everything came nice and hot. Perfect Sunday night dinner for a late night with the family.“

“The restaurant is cozy and inviting, with a warm and homey atmosphere.The food was delicious, but the calamari fritti was truly exceptional ,a perfect ten out of ten!Our server, Dylan, was absolutely amazing, ensuring we had a wonderful time throughout our visit. Overall, it was a fantastic experience, and I highly recommend it - 100% - for a cozy date or family dinner perhaps.“

“I stopped in for a few slices after seeing my doctor, who is next door, and I am glad I did! The pizza not only looks delicious, it is insanely delicious! It's some of the best pizza I have had on Long Island! (and I have had a lot, haha). This place is under new ownership, and the owner is so nice you can tell he really cares about the customer experience and delivering amazing food and quality! Also, given what prices for slices lately have been, the fact that you get such large slices at such fair prices for such good pizza is really nice. I highly recommend this place for great slices, and I am sure the rest of the food is great, too. I will try it soon.“

“We catered our small home wedding this weekend from Gianna's. Food trays were hot ..great temperature.. and Delicious! The trays were full to capacity. Salad and bread..also great quantity, came with our order. Everyone raved on the food. We will definitly use them again and again. Thanks for helping make our day great!“

“We went to Mannino’s tonight for the first time. The hostess was welcoming and our server and wait staff were friendly and polite. We enjoyed our drinks and appetizers to start. The food was amazing my husband had the Bronzini and me and my daughter-in-law had Seafood Fra Diavolo, my son had a plain chicken cutlet which they did for him when we asked for just a plain breaded chicken cutlet no sauce or cheese. They were very accommodating. We definitely will be going back with more family“

“I just have to say this place is amazing,everything so far I've gotten has just been delish and the prices are just amazing, you truly get what you pay for,not like all they other restaurants that make prices higher and the quality of food definitely doesn't match,matches both quality and quantity. This place reminds me of the pizzeria I had as a kid. So good!,and the people that work that are just as nice.“

“Best pizza place in town. I rave about this place to everyone I know! If you haven't tried it already the Thai chicken pizza is fantastic! Their service is also always great. There’s no better pizza place to go to besides this here :)“

“It's a great monthly date night choice for my wife and I. We both enjoy the food and they add new items occasionally so you can often try something new. Our bartender/server, Ally B., is the best! She treats us well and knows what beverages to serve without asking. The entire staff is always friendly. Its a busy location but I would highly recommend“

“The cheese pizza is always good, the knots here are unique bowtie shaped dough, always soft and oily and my overall favorite knots on long Island. I've yet to meet a staff member that I didn't think was excellent and personable. Branchinelli's is my miller place go-to pizzeria.“

“I attended a Baby shower in Amici Restaurant. The staff were the best ! They were attentive, helpful and always standing by ready to do anything they could to make my visit even better. The food was delicious ! I will visit Amici Restaurant again.“

“So happy we found this place. Were always looking for great Pizza nice crust not too thick. So many different choices always ready & the specialty rolls, capellini cakes are so delish.. and everything is a fair price especially for the good quality you get.They give back alot to those whom may need help as well and that means something to have a business give back to the community. Were not even local but drive over every week for our take out & always pop in when we are passing through.Everyone's always friendly and counter help always knows whats out so they are helpful to suggest thigs to try..“

“I've lived in the area for years and never been inside this place until two weeks ago. The inside of the establishment has this classy old-school charm about it. It was a tiny bit confusing because they had the podium in the front by the door and the sign on it said to wait there I noticed everybody walked in anyway so I just went. Maybe they can hide that somewhere else until it's that time of the night or something? Anyway, one of my favorites slices is the grandma slice and I had to try theirs because it was suggested over and over to me by many people. So after finally trying one slice, I ended up buying a whole pie and taking it home. Yes, it's a tiny bit expensive in comparison to the other places locally but the quality of pie is worth the extra money. If you want to be taken back in time and enjoy a great slice then come here.“

“Our first time here and what a great experience! I love the coziness of the restaurant. Everyone is very friendly and attentive. Menu has so much to choose from! It was very hard to decide. I went with the Shrimp and Risotto and it was delicious! My husband had the chicken scarpiarello and he said it was awesome! Our Martinis were perfect and the apple tart and ice cream was divine! I look forward to going back!“

“I came back for some Pizza, and they did not disappoint. Staff was attentive and the Pizza was crispy, with a really good sauce. I liked looking at the wall of artist covers from some of the best bands, it's a great collection! I ended up taking some food home for my son, chicken Parmesan over ziti pasta. Again, the sauce was really good and the chicken was topped with homemade mozzarella cheese for a great meal. I'm definitely going back, so I can try a few more dinners.“

“First visit, staff was super attentive and friendly. Nice menu choices for a pre-fixed and the amount of food your getting for the price is crazy good! Upgraded prices for certain menu items were worth it as well. So nice that they even offered complimentary after dinner drinks cause it was my dad's birthday dinner.“

“Food was great. Our server was also really friendly and super patient with us. We were there with my friend’s toddler who was hangry. Also loved the affordable pricing and smaller portion sizes. For two adults and a toddler it was only $50 with appetizers. Overall, I’ll definitely be back.“

“I’ve frequented Leonardo’s Pizza Cafe and it never disappoints. From the warm greeting by Leonardo himself to the expertly crafted dishes, it’s a gem. While the pizza is top-notch, don’t miss out on the eggplant and baked ziti. Every bite takes me back to my hometown of Campania. Truly a culinary haven.“

“This place was great! Had a party to attend there, the food came out family style, appetizers were crispy and fresh, Caesar Salad, Fried Calamari, Mozzarella sticks, baked clams, fried Zucchini. Then lunch choices, Shrimp Scampi, Eggplant Rollatini & Chicken Piccata. Everything brought out was so delicious and well done, the pasta was not overcooked, the sauce was savory. I would recommend this place to anyone who was looking for a delicious meal at reasonable price!“

“Great spot for a family dinner or out with friends. Cool vibe and good service. As a Mount Sinai native I’m always happy to see this historic spot thriving!Vegetarian options: Nothing inventive but what we are used to and they do it well: salads, pasta primavera.“

“I'm a truck driver, me and my wife, we were delivering nearby. This place came highly recommended for my last stop on Long Island. Ended up being far far better than I expected. Tough to find good Italian authentic food these days. From the minute I walked in the door so accommodating, The food was to die for, definitely not finishing an entree. I got one of the small entrees and I couldn't finish half of it. Excellent food, excellent service, and very very relaxing atmosphere. Just a good meal all the way around at " La famiglia"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“We had our food catered by Giorgio’s this past weekend and it was AMAZING! Steve is very nice and worked well with us adjusting some things on the menu to fit our needs very accommodating! Delivery was on time and he helped us set it all up too. Very genuine guy running a great place 10/10 recommend and we can’t wait to work with him again!“

“Honestly wow! Not only is this place beautiful and clean, their food and service is simply top notch. Every single dish was delicious, I highly recommend the short rib agnolotti!! I've never had anything like it; the flavors and the melt in your mouth tender short ribs inside the pasta are to die for. 10/10 can't wait to be “