Italian Restaurants near North Tonawanda

Forno e Gelato Bakery •
18 Webster St, North Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Gelato

“I visited Forno E Gelato on 3/8/2024 to check out what they had since we were early for our reservation at Frank Primo's next door. The gelato case was well stocked and there were several enticing items in the pastry case. As I asked whether they made Italian almond amaretti cookies, Rachel, the owner came in and we had a pleasant discussion about them, she looked them up on her phone on the spot, and forwarded to the pastry chef for consideration. I recounted my fond memories of visiting my sister in Brooklyn and enjoying almond amaretti, which often entailed extensive negotiations for the last one! Anyway, I purchased pistachio amaretti and Grandma whites cookies for later, and consumed salted caramel gelato (made by Forno E Gelato) at the end of dinner at Franki Primo's. The salted caramel gelato was excellent, with a nice ribbon of caramel through it. It's my favorite flavor, so I have a lot to compare it against. Forno E Gelato's salted caramel was in the top 3 best ones I've ever had (in competition with Siena in Snyder and a place in Italy)! The pistachio amaretti were also excellent with the perfect soft chew and great nutty flavor. Grandma whites cookies were good with a slight anise flavor, and just not a cookie I would normally gravitate to or rave over anyway. I'll definitely be back for the salted caramel gelato, the pistachio amaretti, and (hopefully) some almond amaretti!“

4.5 Superb29 Reviews
Roman Cafe Italian • $$
797 Payne Ave, North Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan with Fettuccine Alfredo
Chicken Parmigiana
French Onion Soup
Peanut Butter Pie
Chicken Wings
Mom Burger

“If there were 10 Stars available - they would received a "10" from our group of 3.We had a girls night out for supper and we were Blown Away with the service, food, and cocktails!I would ask the restaurant to maybe play some Frank Sinatra/Tony Bennett music for the ultimate Italian Experience.My new Favorite Place for a gathering!“

4.1 Good49 Reviews
Primo Classico Italian • $
105 Main St, North Tonawanda

“Ordered the Primo pizza with the extra cheese extra pep. Very thin crust and very light sauce. I like it that way but some may not. Pizza was delicious. My daughter enjoyed it as well. We reheated the next day in oven and it was even better. We also ordered the fried dough bites. Great little dessert to pair with the pizza. Highly recommend if you are in the area or live nearby. They do DoorDash free delivery with order of 15 dollars or more.“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Frankie Primo's +39 North Italian • $$
26 Webster St, North Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parm
Shrimp Salad
Fettuccine
Speghetti

“My first visit and enjoyed the friendly and welcoming atmosphere while I was waiting for my friend to arrive. The service was casual and unhurried. The menu and specials held much to choose from. Our wait staff was helpful in suggesting a selection to accommodate a dietary need. I will definitely come back bringing new guests to experience this restaurant.“

3.8 Good80 Reviews
Pane's Restaurant Italian • $
984 Payne Ave, North Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Bowtie Pasta with Chicken
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo
Marsala Meatballs 1oz
Garlic Cheese Bread
Italian Wedding Soup
Fettuccine Alfredo
French Onion Soup
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmigiana
Roast Beef Dinner

“I had my daughter's baby shower here. From beginning to end Liz and her crew are amazing! They are extremely friendly and accommodating. The food is delicious, the atmosphere was beautiful, the service was friendly and affordable. It was a pleasure doing business with Pane's and would recommend to anyone looking for a venue.Dietary restrictions: There were people in our party who were gluten free and Panes was very accommodating with gluten pasta!“

3.9 Good90 Reviews
North Tonawanda-Pizza Amore “The Wood Fire Way” Pizza • $
1030 Payne Ave, North Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Pizza Amore Salad
Garlic Knots

“Amazing pizza and amazingly friendly tall blonde girl working here alone 2pm 11/29/23She also recommended me the old world square slice as well as the 2 slices for lunch special with a soda. It was like $10.60 for 3 slices of fresh delicious pizza, great service, and an ice cold bottle of soda.“

3.6 Good28 Reviews
Loading...
map Map