Magpie Irish Pub

$$ • Irish Pub

653 Park Ave, Rochester
(585) 271-4150



Reviews for Magpie Irish Pub

Awful experience and I'll never go back. Two friends and I were outside at a table while the bar was packed inside (oh yeah, they don't even pretend to follow distancing or capacity laws). The bouncer decided to latch onto us for some reason and told us we need to finish our drinks and close our tab. OK, whatever. I go in to try and pay, stand at the packed bar for five minutes without being acknowledged, and give up to head back outside. Finish my drink, go back in to pay, full review
Both times I went here I waited over 10 minutes to get a drink. The first time I went up to the bar & the bartender said he couldn't serve me, I had to be seated at a table. I said I was but no one can to service me. So I sat back down & continued to wait. The second time, I waited again, then saw people getting served at the bar so I finally walked up to the bar to order. I ordered a glass of wine that he put in a shot glass & charged me $6 for. Now the bar full review

Friends of mine seem to really like this place so I thought I'd give it a try and I don't understand the hype. It was a tiny dive bar, with alright music, a crappy back part that had minimal seating and a terrible placement of the singular dart board. The tiny bar area was PACKED to the point where you couldn't move and took forever to get a drink. I personally don't see myself returning. There was out of the ordinary and it was just okay.

More Reviews(97)


Monday 1PM - 2AM
Tuesday 1PM - 2AM
Wednesday 1PM - 2AM
Thursday 1PM - 2AM
Friday 1PM - 2AM
Saturday 10AM - 2AM
Sunday 12PM - 2AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.