Ice Cream Shops near Rye

Piazza Pizza Pizza • $
520 Milton Rd, Rye

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Scarpariello
Chicken Fingers
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wings

“FANTASTIC PIZZA. EVEN BETTER SERVICE. I don’t normally write reviews, but these guys absolutely deserve one. I can’t believe I’ve been missing out on Pizza Piazza my whole life, I’ve lived in the area for 20+ years, and now I wish I could have those 20 years back. If only there were more spots like this around that truly cared about the quality of their food, and the experience of their customers. The gentlemen behind the counter made me feel like ive been one of their most loyal customers for years. I will be returning to try more items from their menu very soon! Or I might just get more pizza since it was that good!“

4.4 Superb32 Reviews
La Fenice Of Rye Cafe • $
3 Purdy Ave, Rye

“Discovered this place when searching for gelato in the area and could not be more impressed with the amazing selection of pastries, gelato, and even crepes. The lady behind the counter recognize us since the first time we visited. Very personal and warm atmosphere. It's our dessert spot forever now.“

4.2 Good17 Reviews
Longford's Ice Cream-RYE Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
4 Elm Pl, Rye

Customers` Favorites

7 Cake

“All I can say is wow. What an amazing establishment. I had the pleasure of having their ice cream sandwiches. The cookies are fresh, and they have MANY flavor options to choose from. The ice cream is some of the best I've ever tasted, and I will most definitely be coming back NEXT WEEK!!!!!!!!!!!“

3.1 Average32 Reviews
Carvel Express Ice Cream Shop • $
Playland Pkwy, Rye
0 Na0 Reviews
SCOOP & COFFEE Ice Cream Shop • $
271 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Out of the Oven

“We love this establishment!!We have had various coffees, pastries & now ice cream!Cheesecake, chocolate and tiramisu ice cream was a delicious creamy treat.The pastries are so good that every bite makes you go “mmmmm!”Bayville is lucky to have you “

4.9 Superb46 Reviews
Crumbl - Port Washington Dessert • $
20 Soundview Market Pl Unit #7, Port Washington

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Raspberry Truffle
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Peanut Butter M&M
Lava Cake
Cookies

“These are all my cookies i have ever gotten from crumbl. They were all delicious. Cannot eat a whole cookie in one sitting tbh but that is not a bad thing at all! That means I can savor the cookie over a period of time woo! My favs from the times I've got crumbl were blueberry cheesecake, snickerdoodle cupcake, cannoli and cinnamon square! Many awesome and yummy flavors. The store is very clean and smells of fresh cookies. Yummmm“

4.7 Superb94 Reviews
Cups N' Cones of Old Greenwich Ice Cream Shop •
235 Sound Beach Ave, Old Greenwich

“We had the best time celebrating our son's 3rd birthday at Cups n' Cones! The location is perfect and Anna and her team could not have made it simpler. Besides the obvious perk of having ice cream and toppings for the kids, the space also gives you the opportunity to plan any other activities you like. We will definitely be back for future parties!“

4.9 Superb32 Reviews
Ice Cream Social Ice Cream Shop • $
481 Mamaroneck Ave, White Plains

“If you want to enjoy some delicious ice cream?? this place is incredible and Luz's attention is super, she speaks English and Spanish. I also love that they have an area where you can hydrate, I don't know about you but after eating ice cream you are thirsty?“

4.6 Superb54 Reviews
COCO Confections and Coffee Ice Cream • $$
365 Glen Cove Ave, Sea Cliff

Customers` Favorites

Hand Painted Truffles

“The best chocolatier in the NY-metro area! Great array of unique and interesting flavors that one doesn't see anywhere else. You can tell they put their heart into their craft. I am eating art. Great for gifting, the recipients always love their treats. The staff are always very nice and helpful.“

4.9 Superb24 Reviews

10
Carvel

Carvel Ice Cream Shop • $
262 N Saw Mill River Rd, Elmsford

Customers` Favorites

Ice Cream Cone
Birthday Cake

“The few, the proud,.. Come on, folks! It's Carvel Ice Cream! This location has always been monumental in my life growing up and still today. It would get a biased 5 stars ? on that alone. The ice cream is second to none. Whether soft-serve, traditional, cake, or shake, it's great! Scoops or soft serve in your choice of cones or a bowl, floats, banana splits, a sleeve of flying saucers, and more are there for you to enjoy. They still make the ice cream cakes with the crunches, too. The service is pretty good, and they will allow you to customize your order with toppings, etc. Be mindful and patient of customer surges and the occasional understaffing.The dining space is limited to the two historic, small benches outside the building. Of course, you can sit in your car in the parking lot to indulge in a cool treat. This location in Elmsford is a great stop after shopping locally or passing through regardless of the weather or season. Ice cream is the reason!“

4.7 Superb33 Reviews
Loading...
map Map