Restaurants in Sleepy Hollow

“Best pizza I've ever had in New York. Visited last October from West Virginia. We talk about how good the pizza was all the time. Wish we could get it shipped here lol. Will definitely be stopping in our next trip .Everyone was very kind as well...”

“Fantastic local spot, gets quite busy during peak lunch and dinner/weekends. Nice salads, burgers and wings. Lots of interesting patty choices (elk, bison, etc). Also, one of the best (most diverse, interesting) rotating domestic crafr tap lists in the county. They're always playing great rock, blues & funk.”

“The food score is based mostly on the beer. The selection is fantastic and rotates often. The pizza is decent in general and the weekly specials is fairly imaginative. The bartenders don't let you hit empty without asking if you'd like another.”

“Wow 🤩 - this place is the real deal. Finally got to try the Gangster Parm - we’re talking big time chicken cutlet, crispy bacon, bomb vodka sauce, melted cheesy mozzarella, all piled high on a deliciously fresh roll. Not your average sandwich and 10/10 would highly recommend this spot!!”

“The Original Cubano…
Crunchy bread on the outside, moist, tasty meats on the inside. Simply delicious.
Lovely people and atmosphere!
This is the thing cravings are made of.
You won’t be disappointed.”

“Okay but I won't go back.

Kid-friendliness: Not at all kid friendly, TV was showing sexy gangster girls firing automatic weapons and trying to look tough in videos.... I'm not a conservative or libertarian but why would we allow kids to watch that kind of thing or show it in a public place like that's normal- acceptable?”

“Excellent food, large portions, friendly staff. Ingredients are fresh, food served fast and hot! Eat in or take out!”

“Every order is consistently fresh, delicious and flavorful, but most important, the owners genuinely care about the craft and culture of the food they are preparing for their customers. If I could rate them with more stars I would!”

“Great atmosphere very nice and attentive wait staff would definitely visit again”

“Honestly best Dominican food in town. You will not be disappointed! From the Rabo , churrasco, pollo empanisado to the pepper steak and more !”

“items i ordered were slightly better than every other chinese place ive been. general tso chicken had a slight pineapple flavor, hinting a tang-soo-yook (for those korean) profile. veg lo mein tasted exactly how it was supposed to. even the wonton soup had this extra egg/chicken umami to it. added bonus... the mom (i assume owner) and little daughter (just hanging out there) were very welcoming and hospitable to me/wife/my 3 yr-old. perhaps this place deserves 4 - 4.5 since its not like food was anywhere close to Michelin Star level - but i rate as 5 in context of chinese take outs.”

“We had lunch here after the visit to Sleepy Hollow, we were quite hungry and we appreciated the cuisine, above all finding real food and not the usual burgers and sandwiches that pop out of our eyes these days and the staff is very kind. Abundant dishes and definitely cheap!”

“We fell upon Justin’s the weekend before Halloween - what a find. My husband got the largest plate of food (delicious) that I have ever seen for $12. I got a massive bowl of chicken soup with fresh herbs and lime juice that was the tastiest chicken soup I’ve ever had. Between ourselves and our friends we went up multiple times to get more food, smoothies and drinks. Honestly so good, great value and the staff were so accommodating and sweet.”

“My first time I ate from gustito was was Sunday January 6th about 3 days after it opened. I had a sandwich called “ Riky” it was amazing . Although I’m from the Dominican Republic I never had it. Today Sunday January 13th I ordered a shrimp mofongo , Salmon and chicharrones de pollos, all a hit. Gustito will definitively be a favorite Restaurant in sleepy hallow . Best of luck to the chef Ramon Rodriguez owner and Lourdes Rodriguez.”

“Food is delicious, (so far I’ve had the chicken / vegetable tacos, as well as the veggie taco bowl tonight), the ambiance quaint and lovely, service highly efficient, and the prices, despite an economy plagued by inflation, were surprisingly reasonable. I have a feeling this will be my new go to…dining in or for take-out. This place is a day-brightener.”

“Every thing I’ve ever tasted from this bakery elicits a reflexive “mmmmm!”. Can’t wait to go back!!!”

“Today I went to the restaurant to purchase yucca. They were so friendly and so nice. I will most definitely be back at this restaurant. I was so impressed at how nice they were. Thank you!!!!!! food is extremely authentic and fresh.”

“The food was excellent and the service was even better! Looking forward to our next dinner there.”

“The food is delicious, the seasoning is incomparable, the service is very very friendly and the prices are extraordinary.

Best place to eat in Sleepy Hollow!”

“Excellent customer service”

“Delicious and fresh food. I had the tomato shrimp meal and it was scrumptious! The portion size was great too! The server taking my order was very nice and patient. I would order again if I’m in the area.”

“100% recomendado torta tres leches Tema Harry Potter me encanto el diseño y el sabor delicioso. Muchas gracias.”

“Love finding these small places. The tacos were amazing, I had the steak, son had the pork and wife had the Mahi. Everything was extremely flavor full, the guacamole was fresh and had a great flavor. Really small and very busy. Would 100% eat here again (without kids)! Thank you!”