9 Best Italian Restaurants near New Carlisle

“We absolutely love Franco the foodie! The food there tastes amazing, we haven't had a dish that we didn't absolutely love. We try to go at least twice a month as our schedules allow. I even ran into Mr Franco at Sam's Club a couple of months ago. And he couldn't have been nicer. Absolutely great place!“

“Had a special order for a birthday party. Needed picked up before normal store hours and store made the adjustments to fit our timeframe. Bobby who made the pizzas was awesome and went above and beyond to make everything fresh and by the time we needed them. Great owners and great workers. Would recommend a thousand times over.“

“Food was really good, we got a basic pepperoni pizza with some breadsticks and marinara sauce. The pizza was good with pepperoni under the cheese so it had more than I initially thought, breadsticks and marinara sauce were both delicious. Carpet was a little worn and a bit dirty but service was awesome. Will be back for sure!“

“Went here for lunch! Omg it was delicious. They have lunch specials. I got the meat lasagna it was so good. It came out sisaling hot!! The place is small but again very good food! They also have an outside seating area. The service was great. I went at noon and I was only one in restaurant at this time. I am shocked more people were not there. If you live near Fairborn Ohio... definitely try this place! It's awesome!“

“I tried the cheeseburger pizza it was amazing!!!This is my second time since they have been back in the area.The first time was when they first came back in the area and it was not a good experience at allBut here we are years later and I finally tried them again and it was amazing. I will definitely be back for the cheeseburger pizza again in the near future!“

“Stopped in this evening to grab a couple pizzas. Friday evening and it was a last minute decision. I thought for sure we’d be waiting an hour plus. To our delight, the gentleman behind the counter told me 20 minutes. He was pretty much spot on. They are utilizing what I’ll call old brick ovens. In my opinion, the best way to make a pizza ever! They aren’t sending it down a conveyor style oven as most places do now days. It actually takes a lot of skill and monitoring to make them this way. I put their pizza over Marion’s easily. If you like “Dayton style pizza”, do yourself a favor and try it out! If you like a Chicago style with thick crust, don’t go here. But, for what the demographics are here, it’s no wonder why they’ve been in business as long as they have. The community raves about this place. And I’d have to agree with that 110%“

“Just happened to be in the neighborhood and looking for a place to eat. My partner recognized Giovanni's from 30 years ago and wanted to see if it was still as good. It was extraordinarily good! It was the best, most perfect pizza I have had in years! The pizza was so good and the pitcher of beer was so cold and good! What a great idea to eat here. I will go back!“

“Came out to see Matt Stell at K99.1 Unplugged night and enjoy a great evening. Loved the bar, food was great, staff was awesome! For a packed house, there was little wait and the unplugged concert was so much fun. We can't wait to be back!“

“Just moved to the area. Ordered a Steak Hoagie (not in picture, bc fiancee already ate half), a small Stromboli and their Blazin wings. It was all very good!!! The sauce is very good. Plenty of topping on everything. Service was friendly and fast, was in and out in 15min for a to go order. Way better than a food chain pizza company, hands down. And if that's a small Stromboli, I can only image how big the Large one is.? We will definitely be returning!“