26 Best Bakeries near Gordonville

“I have not been to this establishment personally but am a devoted follower of Von Thun Farms in Washington NJ. I saw these Iced Cinnamon Buns for Sale in their farm store. I thought my partner would enjoy these. I was correct they are extraordinarily good. This kind of dessert is not my thing but I did enjoy these Cinnamon Buns too! It is the Maple Icing for me! I would like to purchase another item from your bakery another time I stop by the farm. I hope to see this bakery label so I can try another dessert. I recommend you try- you will not be disappointed.“

“I've ordered from Sweet Shenanigans several times, large orders and also a few just to take and home and share with my boys. My favorites are her unique flavors you don't find at other bakeries. I recently served the lemon drop and simply strawberry cupcakes at a baby shower. So many of the guests told me they're not even "cupcake people" but these cupcakes were the BEST they ever had. You can always save money and make your own, or you can get what you pay for, save time, and serve delicious and decadent cupcakes that your guests will remember and request again a d again!“

“I'm in Sales, so I stopped in to talk to the owner about establishing a business relationship. I left with a dozen donuts...LOL. They make some of the freshest and best tasting donuts I've had. And, the owners are very nice. Will be back!“

“Been using them for 3 years for fantastic treats for my customers and family! Small issue with an order this morning. They immediately acknowledged the mistake and made it right, no questions asked. That's how business is done! I'll continue using them and referring them as the best cookies anywhere!“

“We visit on every trip to Lancaster county. Love their pies, cookies, whoopie pies and especially their dinner and hamburger rolls. They also have good ice cream and will make you a shake. During the summer there is a food truck outside baking pretzels. They're also extremely helpful if there's something special you want they will make it for you, you can either call or order it while you're there and pick up the next day. Coconut cream pie is amazing. Pumpkin pie also amazing, and pumpkin custard pie is seasonal but definitely worth trying.“

“Love this place! I shop here regularly for ready to heat meals. Choose raw beef and poultry, deli meats, their own sausages and smoked meats, or prepared foods, homemade pizzas, soups, or baked goods, and now produce. They even have cheese curds, ginger root, and sandwiches.“

“i just have to say this is the best hidden gem i found in quite a while. food is so fresh, really great selection. love how i can get heat up easy meals that taste fanstastic. the sugar free treats are huge for my family and they dont taste sugar free. Staff is so friendly and helpful. we make this a weekly stop now“

“Our second visit to Pastry Paradise and their delicious baked treats will keep us coming back! Our Fathers Day cake was a huge hit! Super moist cake that melts in your mouth and you will be impressed with the unique and creative decorating! You won’t be disappointed!“

“WOW! This is one massive sticky bun. I purchased three kinds: one with nuts, one without nuts and the cinnamon roll. Why wait to go home and who could resist? I ate my just received sticky bun, in my car; fingers gooey. Ask for wet wipes, I believe they have them. Next day, reheated a bun in my oven and folks; it was Still amazing. This bun oozes with the sticky stuff and cinnamon, within the crevices. My car smelled like Yankee Candle's Cinnamon Bun; it was truly intoxicating.“

“Stopped here in the morning to get a sticky bun! Waited a few minutes for the plain ones. While waiting we talked with the staff and the lady up front was very friendly. It was worth the wait. So good. Probably could have ate the whole thing in one sitting but I held myself back. So good especially when they are warm! Def recommend you stop if you're in the area.“

“this is by far our favorite coffee spot to come too on the weekends!! such friendly employees, coffee is always soo good and their lotus drinks are a fun tasty drink to have as well!the little notes they leave on your coffee will definitely brighten up your day!highly recommend if you’re in the area !“

“Perfectly soft/chewy/crunchy texture of our soft pretzel sticks. I really liked the free taste-testing area allowing new customers to flavor the many different mustard varieties—my favorite was horseradish and honey. I’d never had sweet baloney before and the free bites encouraged me to make a purchase. Also, to whet your whistle and wash down the mustardy pretzel tastes, I’d highly recommend picking a glass bottle ($2 deposit) of the sweet-tart lemonade.“

“Nice little shop for baked goodies! Got a sweet tooth? Need goodies for a get together? Need something to go with that morning coffee? They’ll have something for you if they didn’t sell out. Go early for the single donuts! Dropped a star due to the size of the donuts available on 1/26/24. They shrunk since the last time I’ve bought from.“

“The long John's were delicious!! It was a mix of donut and croissant. The topping was amazing! It was a whipped fudge frosting that was light but thick. And it wasn't overall sweet!! The homemade fry pie was equally excellent!Highly recommend.“

“The restaurant is decorated with colorful fabrics and banners and there’s Latin music to set a festive atmosphere. The service was very good and our server was very friendly and answered our questions. My chicken empanada was stuffed with seasoned chicken and definitely homemade. My fish tacos had great sauces and presentation. Some parts were a little fishy so I wouldn’t order again. My husband’s enchiladas platter was so generous he took some home. The green sauce and chorizo are spicy so go for the milder options if you don’t want heat. The food was fresh and house made and priced reasonably so I would definitely go back.“

“The best pickles ever!!! The Habanera Dill Blast are so good that even despite the heat, I could finish a whole jar in one sitting!And the sweetest vendor ever! Pre-pandemic I was shopping for my usual pickles and jerky and was short $5 cash. The man trusted I’d be back cause I was a regular, and spotted the rest of the cash. Just a few weeks later the city went into lock down. When the market reopened post-pandemic I would always check to see if he was back and was concerned he wouldn’t return, since it had been several months since the reopening. Even though it was almost 2 years later, the stand was back at the union square market and I got to repay my loan. #1 fan here!“

“I grabbed breakfast here yesterday and have to say this is quite the hidden gem. The building and decor are so cozy and made me feel right at home. The owners have a dog who runs around the property and was just the sweetest thing, making the trip even more fun. I ordered a vanilla latte, which was good and had a strong espresso. I also ordered a brick house omelet to eat. Unfortunately it seemed like my omelet was forgotten about because they were in the middle of a rush, so I asked for it after 30 min. They then got it out quickly and it was delicious- filled with sausage, bacon, peppers, onions, and cheese. It was so big and came with toast, so I was stuffed by the time I was finished. Other than the service snafu, I really liked this cafe!“

“These are easily the best dang donuts I’ve ever had. Last visit I picked up a dozen without thinking. They’re yeasty, thick, stuffed with jam, and powdered just right. You can’t really refresh them in an oven though, nor freeze them. It doesn’t work out. Just gotta go get them fresh… which isn’t so bad since Beiler’s fruit farm is next door. Run, don’t walk. You’ll find the entrance at the back of a home - the door is unlocked and usually there’s nobody there but if you wait a few minutes they’ll come and help you. Have fun y’all.“

“If you're around the area, you should stop by and get some of the delicious cheesecake, pie and torte. They are just like those you can find in local supermarkets or restaurants except they have more selections. The prices were reasonable and customer service was excellent.“

“Super cute shop! A lot of it is not Amish made which we didn’t know but still good! We got the red apple balsamic, homemade Cheetos, blueberry bread, honey white bread, black raspberry jam, chocolate covered pretzel and coffee. Everything tasted great! The workers were very friendly and it was a great “

“I bought a coconut cake at Christmas time last year. We didn’t eat it all and decided to freeze some of it. I just got it out of the freezer and thawed it out. The cake was just as moist and delicious as the day we bought it. I didn’t even have it an airtight container. They make an awesome cake. You can freeze it and thaw it out and it is as fresh as the day they make it.“

“Parking: Store entrance & parking lot are located in the rear of the store/factory. If you visit early in the day, you can watch pretzels being made. They sell bulk quantities in addition to the usual packs you'd find in a grocery store. Plus, Martin's sells so many flavors!! Good deals on bags of broken pretzels.“

“They moved to a different storefront within Rockvale Square outlets. They are now in between the Disney store and Jack and Janie. I have been shopping here for years to buy bread, goldfish, etc. Buy one of the resuable bags and every time you bring it back it gets you an additional 15% off your total purchase.“

“OMG, they made the best cupcakes I’ve ever tasted! My nephew bought their cupcakes for his wedding cake, and they were just the best! He ordered the raspberry chocolate hazelnut flavor. I’ll definitely use them in the future. I live an hour away, but these are worth the drive!“

“This is one place you’ll want to stop while traveling Route 30 east. You can’t miss this iconic bakery known for its windmill shaped roof. It also has the best shoo-fly pie! When I arrived I was instantly greeted with a warm, freshly baked sample of the pie. They also have a nice selection of cookies, jams and jellies , and souvenirs.“

“First visit. Spacious parking ( I'm from NYC ), great customer service. Even it's supposed to be crowded on a Saturday afternoon, it's still very comfortable compared to NYC. Saw a couple things we don't see at NYC, such as stir fry noodles and meatloaf in the fridge. We ate at the food court with the always low price menu. We saw the parking 'garage' for the Armish buggies which was interesting to us.“