26 Best Bakeries in Lancaster

Lancaster Pie & Coffee Coffee & Tea • $
136 N Prince St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Onion and Mushroom Quiche
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Blueberry Pie
Oatmilk Latte
Liege Waffle
Pumpkin Pie
Apple Pie
Cherry Pie
Affogato

“My experience with Lancaster Pie & Coffee began before even entering. My husband and I were reading the sign and then when we finally headed in the owner was there opening the door for us, because he saw my husband was using a cane. Once we were inside we were met with the prettiest cafe, local art to peruse, the incredible smell of pie and the warmest smile from the woman behind the bar / register. The vibes were top notch. So what about the pie? If you call yourself a pie place the pie should be, at least- good. Well, the pie is actually quite amazing. We tried the apple, blueberry and the lemon. The lemon was the showstopper, but all three were spectacular. It felt like coming home and home is perfect and has great pie. Their hot chocolate was good and included rustic homemade marshmallows. The tea selection was fantastic. One of my favorite things (and there were many from my experience), was the quiche. I've tried the quiche in just about every establishment in downtown Lancaster that offers it- none compare to the quiche here. I ordered the Swiss mushroom and it was a revelation. I feel bad for all of the other quiche makers everywhere else. So far behind..... Overall, I was immediately love stricken with the business. They deliver on every level. And the kindness and charm of the employees, owner and hostess must not be diminished. I have a handful of businesses in downtown Lancaster I order from or frequent quite a bit and the owners who are always there are rarely ever friendly or chatty, which is fine, but I wish there was more friendliness. Pie & Coffee has amazing food, fantastic pies and beverages and then the staff is so welcoming and sweet. It's all the things.“

5 Superb100 Reviews
Bistro Barberet & Bakery French • $$
26 E King St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Various Cookies and Treats
Raspberry Macaron
French Onion Soup
Pan Seared Salmon
Moules Frites GFO
Pastry Selection
French Pastries
Choux Chantilly
Mac and Cheese
Moules Frites

“A real French bakery with the best macaroons and a variety of pastries.The quality is what you would have in France. Its worth driving over from Philly to have this.It would be one of best experience your taste buds would have had.I would be surprised if anyone would mention that they have had better deserts for the same items anywhere else.I would doubt if any NYC place can be better than this. Have visited them since the last 5 years and the quality is consistent.They have crossaints and coffee, that i plan to be there for breakfast some weekend.Their bistro has great food french food, if you are a fan of real french food.“

4.7 Superb250 Reviews
Wish You Well Bakery Bakery • $$
47 N Queen St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Brown Butter Snickerdoodles
Quart of Tomato Soup V
Hand Pies
Bialys

“Best bakery in Lancaster city, hands down. Incredible bagels and breakfast sandwiches along with inventive treats and desserts. Tons of solid standbys along with rotating new ideas which keeps it exciting to go back again and again.Everything is done with passion behind it. Cute little space to sit and eat, very kind owners and staff. Can’t recommend enough!“

4.9 Superb44 Reviews
Passenger Roastery & Coffee Bar Coffee Shops • $
131 N Plum St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Espresso & Bag of Coffee Beans
Vegan Chocolate Chip Cookie
Poptart
Scone

“Been frequenting both locations for a year and a half. Even when I’m not getting a coffee, I’ll grab a bag of their whole beans for my home setup (minor bias I’m a fan of coffee in general)Pricing is on the higher side but the quality is there; They set the gold standard for a great cup of coffee. Treat yourself!Also those vegan chocolate chip cookies are excellent“

4.9 Superb35 Reviews
Mr Sticky's Homemade Sticky Buns Bakery • $
501 Greenfield Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Bun with Walnuts Extra Icing
Regular Sticky
Walnut Sticky
Cinnamon Roll
Mr Sticky Bun

“WOW! This is one massive sticky bun. I purchased three kinds: one with nuts, one without nuts and the cinnamon roll. Why wait to go home and who could resist? I ate my just received sticky bun, in my car; fingers gooey. Ask for wet wipes, I believe they have them. Next day, reheated a bun in my oven and folks; it was Still amazing. This bun oozes with the sticky stuff and cinnamon, within the crevices. My car smelled like Yankee Candle's Cinnamon Bun; it was truly intoxicating.“

4.6 Superb77 Reviews
Thom's Bread Bakery Bakery • $
113 Butler Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Brick Oven Pizza
Large Margherita Pizza
Cinnamon Swirl
Rustic Italian
Pizza Crusts
Rosemary
Ciabatta

“We ordered a 16" Pepperoni pizza just before closing, and we would like to express our gratitude to the staff for completing our order despite the late hour. Upon walking in, we were warmly greeted by friendly staff, and we even had the pleasure of meeting the owner. The owner shared information about the new procedures they use for making their bread, and we decided to try a loaf. The bread turned out to be not only delicious but also phenomenal.Once we arrived home, we eagerly indulged in the pizza. The crust and dough surpassed the traditional pizza dough available in the area. The sauce boasted a fantastic flavor, and the quality of the pepperoni was evident. We are incredibly pleased and thankful for the wonderful experience. We look forward to returning soon!“

4.7 Superb50 Reviews
Savoy Truffle Sandwich Shop • $
398 Harrisburg Ave #250, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese with Fries
Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Strawberry Shortcake Jar Cake
Birthday Cake
Loaded Fries
Egg Cheese
Bagel

“This is the best grill cheese sandwich in Lancaster! Perfectly made w/ gooey cheeses on sourdough bread. Also tried a twinkie cupcake which was moist & sweet! The service was quick & easy. Cute place w/ several small tables & chairs to sit & enjoy some tasty treats. Will come back & try a breakfast sandwich!“

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
House of Clarendon Bakery
240 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Wedding Cake
8 Cake

“I was blown away with the birthday cake we recently ordered for my MIL’s 94th. It was absolutely perfect! Everyone said it was the best carrot cake they’ve ever had! The decoration was beyond what I had imagined! The cake made her day extra special and I would highly recommend this place for any special occasion.“

4.9 Superb24 Reviews
Cake Creators Bakery • $
3543 Marietta Ave # I, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Icing
Yellow Marble Cake with White Icing
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Cupcake

“Amazing every time! The cakes are moist. The flavor is delicious, and so many flavor combinations to choose from. She is so easy to work with and very friendly! Never disappointed, whether we order in person in her cozy cheerful bakery or over the phone she uses her creativity to create amazing cakes/cupcakes!“

5 Superb19 Reviews
Central Manor Bakery & Grille Bakery • $
3667 Blue Rock Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Old English Cheeseburger
Chicken Tenders
Whoopi’S Pies
Chicken Pie
Sandwich
Cookies
Cake

“Best place is a cultural icon of the area and highly highly recommended if you're ever in the area stop by they have chicken pot pie already prepared single servings they're like $7 and amazing they also have a full menu and amazing bakery items that are baked on the premise by the family it's “

4.8 Superb27 Reviews
Empanada Gourmet Bakery • $
46 N Prince St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Vegan Red Beans and Rice Empanadas
Uruguayan Empanadas
Beef and Cheese
Chicken Empanada
Empanada Beef
Caprese

“Delightful cafe which sells mainly empanadas. They are a bit small so you will likely want more than one. They have a wide selection of flavors, make them in-house, and serve with a dipping sauce. They have nice indoor and outdoor seating areas.“

4.8 Superb25 Reviews
Butter and Bean Cafe • $
100 S Queen St, Lancaster

“We stopped in to get lattes on our way out of Lancaster. I ordered a Carmel frappe which was really good. My husband ordered hazelnut cappuccino and lived it. There is a nice sitting area while you wait.We will definitely return.Parking: This is a very busy parking lot because of the outlets. I was surprised how open the parking lot was.“

4.6 Superb39 Reviews
La Petite Patisserie Bakery • $
621 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pain Au Chocolate Croissant
Breakfast Sandwich
Almond Croissant
Potato Hash Bowl
Nutella Pastries
French Macarons
Croissants
Macaroon

“This was a FANTASTIC experience. If you're a little boujee and like food, you'll love this spot. It's classy and beautiful and yummy! We couldn't stay to eat but we'll be back. The enjoyment of the store details is real. The French Apple Cake was picked by our son, and he wasn't a fan because he's got the palate of a cardboard box (his loss). It has a beautiful taste with rum (?) Or maybe bourbon notes, so that's why he didn't like it. Hubby did NOT mind having to finish that delight off ?? The kiddo loved his macarons despite the new textures (weird, huh), so there's some hope left for him. The sausage gravy meal was delish per hubby.Shout out to Chef Nate, who went above and BEYOND with his food and service. That southwest bowl (sans cheese) was AMAZING, and since I don't get to eat out often due to food restrictions, I thank you from the tips of my toes to the bottom of my heart!10 out of 10, highly recommend.Vegetarian options: Semi generous vegetarian options. One vegan option. Removals permitted on menu items but no substitutions.“

4.5 Superb46 Reviews
Torres Family Bakery Bakery • $
447 S Prince St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Macaroon with Cream Cheese and Guava
Salami Queso Y Huevo Sandwich
Cheesecake Raspberry Jam
Guava and Cheese Pastry
Apple Pie Mantecaditos
Ham Egg Cheese Sandwich
Pastelillos De Guava
Chocolate Cupcake
Various Desserts
Cubano Sandwich

“Cubano has mustard, mayo, lettuce, tomatoes, and was fresh. Nothing stood out for me but it was fine as a sandwich. The pastries are flavorful in a cultural way- especially with the guava flavoring. You know it has to be a local bakery because it is on the outskirts from downtown and this section seems kind of iffy. Places like this give the neighborhood a chance to be uplifted more. At least some of the workers here speak English and Spanish? Fluently. Stool seating here.“

4.6 Superb28 Reviews
Kom-Essa Deli •
247 Lancaster Ave, Lancaster

“This was the best pretzel I've had in my life. It was made fresh, was crispy on the outside and so soft on the inside. Flavor was great, no bitterness, and just enough salt without being overpowering. Service was also quick! It's located inside in the marketplace.“

4.9 Superb12 Reviews
Tequila Mexican Grill & Bar Mexican • $
805 A Rohrerstown Rd, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Special Beef Barbacoa Tacos
Camarones A la Diabla
Molcajete Vegetariano
Burrito de Carnitas
Tacos De Carne Asada
Shrimp Enchiladas
Tapatía Burrito
Seafood Molcajete
Fresh Guacamole
Barbacoa Taco 1

“This is our favorite restaurant in Lancaster. The food is always delicious, cooked perfectly and even when we doordash it is like being there in person. Jackie was our server and she is always so sweet and wonderful. All of the staff are amazing. We love Tequila mexican grill .“

4.3 Superb105 Reviews
Ric's Bread Bakery • $
24 N Queen St, Lancaster

“I've read a few about "these women" from 2014- 2018, and it seems they are no longer around as it seems they were actually hurting business. I had a matcha cookie and a lemon muffin at the last minute (about 220 PM Sat) but everyone kind of wants the day to end sooner in the market at that point. Both were very flavorful and I'd certainly be willing to come back and see what some other artisan or artisan like creations they might offer as that fits the bill for me.Male staff was friendly- maybe Ric himself.Environment is the typical intimate small spaces nature of the Lancaster market.“

4.8 Superb12 Reviews
Pepperidge Farm Bakery •
35 S Willowdale Dr Suite 1718, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Cookie

“They moved to a different storefront within Rockvale Square outlets. They are now in between the Disney store and Jack and Janie. I have been shopping here for years to buy bread, goldfish, etc. Buy one of the resuable bags and every time you bring it back it gets you an additional 15% off your total purchase.“

4.4 Superb35 Reviews
Scratch Bakes Cafe • $
13 W Chestnut St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Pick Two Lunch Combo Soup Option
Egg N Cheese
Bakery
Bagel

“(I ordered through DoorDash!) I was sick today and needed a quick pick me up so I tried Scratch Bakes for the first time - it was EXACTLY what I needed. I got the pepper jack tomato soup which was amazing. It hit the spot just right!! I went simple and got a Grilled Cheese to go with it but even that was prepared super well. Paired with an iced latte, I was able to get a delicious comfort meal.I also deliver for doordash occasionally and have had a good experience picking up in the store. The employees were kind and helpful. The atmosphere inside was incredibly calm considering it's right downtown!“

4.4 Superb32 Reviews
Thom's Bread Bakery • $
23 N Market St, Lancaster

“I saw those Yelper pizza pictures and found myself dreaming of Thom's pizza. Who knew, a bread bakery, would have such delicious pizza? Those pictures don't lie, I'll tell you that. Only two tables, up front and my hubby and I snagged one of them. A large pepperoni pizza, took about 15 minutes. I should have taken a picture of it, but I just couldn't wait to dig in. Burnt the roof of my mouth, of course. Sauce was crushed tomatoes, loads of gooey cheese, lots of those tasty cupped pepperonis and that crust, ooh my; thin, chewy, bubbly, thick around the edges; are you drooling yet?“

4.7 Superb11 Reviews
Alfred & Sam's Italian Bakery Bakery • $
17 Fairview Ave, Lancaster

“Fresh bread, service with a smile and wonderful smells...what more could you ask for from a bakery? Made for a wonderful destination for a morning walk. Oh let not forget how wonderfully clean this place was most bakeries seem to have a light dusting of flour everywhere (not complaining about either just noticing).“

4.4 Superb21 Reviews
La Dolce Vita Courthouse Bakery Bakery • $
9 N Duke St, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Vanilla Strawberry Layer Cake
Egg and Bacon on Onion Bun
Holiday Pastries
Fruit Tart
Croissant
Cannoli
Pignoli
Bakery

“You want a banger for a bakery look no further than La Dolce Vita. As the name suggests, the bakery expertly makes a huge variety of Italian desserts, which of those I have tried are excellent. I especially love the cannolis, which are beautifully flaky coated with a variety of chocolate on the inside. The whole place smells so darn good. They even offer lunch options as well. A must try if you love desserts !“

4.2 Good53 Reviews
Sweet Legacy Gourmet Bakery • $
23 N Market St, Lancaster

“This place is absolutely delicious!! We stopped in to grab some sweet treats while passing through Lititz. We were immediately greeted with very friendly and helpful staff who pointed us in the right direction with our choices. Our favorite treat was the coconut macaron. DELICIOUS and perfectly sweet from the flaky coconut. I also had a caramel covered marshmallow which was great (but extremely sweet!). The cookies were tasty (blueberry white chocolate). Prices were reasonable. Definitely check this Lititz gem out!!“

4.5 Superb8 Reviews
Amaranth Bakery Bakery • $$
614 4th St, Lancaster

“I've been buying Amaranth Bakery breads at a local farm market. When they have it, I pick up as many loaves as my freezer can hold! I love the maple oat for an outstanding basic bread great for toasting and dipping in eggs or for French Toast.“

4.4 Superb10 Reviews
Costco Bakery Bakery •
1875 Hempstead Rd, Lancaster

“First visit. Spacious parking ( I'm from NYC ), great customer service. Even it's supposed to be crowded on a Saturday afternoon, it's still very comfortable compared to NYC. Saw a couple things we don't see at NYC, such as stir fry noodles and meatloaf in the fridge. We ate at the food court with the always low price menu. We saw the parking 'garage' for the Armish buggies which was interesting to us.“

4.4 Superb7 Reviews
Good Life Ice Cream & Treats Ice Cream Shop • $
2088 Fruitville Pike, Lancaster

Customers` Favorites

Extra Scoop
1 Scoop

“It was quiet today, but the two ladies that helped us did a great job. My don got to sample two flavors and picked one of them for his ice cream. May have to go back to try the bday cakes or other goodies!Vegetarian options: It’s ice cream so much of the food is vegetarian-friendly. Some mix-in options have gelatin.Dietary restrictions: There was signage that stated allergens, e.g. contains wheat, contains peanuts“

4 Good30 Reviews
Loading...
map Map