15 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sutersville

“O.M.G. this place is amazing! This was our first time here, after passing it up so many times on our way to different places. The advertisement for the Peanut Butter brownie parfait on their sign near the road was all the motivation I needed to finally stop. I am so glad I did! The custard is delicious. Unlike many other frozen custard I have had. I'm more of a soft serve ice cream person so this was right up my alley! Most ice creams upset my stomach later but I'll suffer though it to have some ice cream. I'm typing this up 3 hours later, and nothing yet! Finally a frozen treat I can eat that doesn't upset my stomach! The parfait I had, had bits of brownie in it and most places that I have had a brownie in the ice cream, its stale, this was like the brownie was only a couple hours old, it was that fresh tasting. The girls there are so sweet and nice, which just puts the cherry on top of the first time experience there. I will definitely be back to try their giant gobs and to try more of their frozen treats! Make the stop, don't wait like I did, you don't know what you're missing until you do!“

“This place is just flat out AWESOME! Not only are the sundae creations unique, but they're DELICIOUS! The old school candy throughout the shop took me back to my childhood instantly, and the newer creations appealed to my daughters! (freeze dried gummi works?! Oh yes!!) Wrap it all in a fun Christmas theme, and set some games out to have some quality family time while enjoying your sundaes and you just can't go wrong!!“

“Al's is my first ice cream shop since moving to Pittsburgh and no reason to go anywhere else! We started off with a couple of great, juicy hotdogs! My sundae was so large, I guess because of it's deliciousness it was easy to finish! The flavor and the portion sure beats where I came from. Thanks Al's.Wheelchair accessibility: Nice ramp from upper lot“

“Absolutely love coming here. The honey lavender is my favorite. Every time I’ve come in the gentleman there is so kind and patient with us as we pick out the flavors we want at the time. My niece begs to come here every time we drive past. I highly recommend giving this place a try“

“Big thing here for the non-locals - CASH ONLY !The owner is one of the most down to earth people you'll meet. All the ice cream here is lovely, haven't had one bad thing here. There is no hard serve ice cream, but you can figure that out based on doing basic research. The place is exactly how you see it as well, right off of 5th avenue, so if there is a massive line you'll wait and like it!There usually isn't ever a large line and there is shaded seating on the left side of the building. They have blizzards, cones, sundaes, milkshakes and slushies, so there is more than enough to choose from. Does not hold back on hooking you up, and the price is cheaper than DQ“

“This place has the best soft serve in the area hands down. They flurry flavors are more than any other place I’ve seen.The girls than man the windows are so sweet and always so efficient. I always put money in the college fund jars. They definitely deserve it and how can you not!“

“Great convenience store with basic food items, deli cheese and meats, fresh milk selection, large homemade ice cream selection. Also early in the day usually a Hot lunch selection. Ice cream cones all day. An Alpine slide & playground also mini golf. They also host birthday parties with inside and outside seating.Kid-friendliness: Especially great for kid's!“

“Under new management and better than ever. I met the owner and he is very nice and very knowledgeable about his ice cream game. The prices are really affordable and the ice cream and the selection of different products will have us coming back all summer long.“

“I've been to this location a few times before and I've always enjoyed the staff and the quality of the cookies. I had stopped in today to take advantage of the limited time offer to get the Tres Leches cake before it would be discontinued after this week. The cake was so very good and the staff who had prepared my order today were extremely nice and attentive. I highly recommend this place to anyone.“

“Everything was Great! We recently spent a date night downtown in Irwin, Mcfeely's chocolate and ice cream was the highlight! Customer service was great as we fumbled around selecting several chocolates to take home, the young lady was friendly, patient, and informative. We also got ice cream that we enjoyed outside. As we have got to enjoy every piece of chocolate since our visit highlights included the peanut butter chocolate pie, the brownie, chocolate covered cherries, chocolate covered pretzels and chocolate covered smores! Look forward to our next visit to try more of the items and revisit some of our favorites!“

“This place is so eclectic. It is a FULL VIBE! I love everything about it! The service is impeccable!! FISH TACOs are absolutely delicious! Most of all the tacos have the same ingredients in them. The shrimp taco is a quite delicious as well; I think a Mango salsa would pair good on it. The chicken meat is cooked to perfection super tender! Wish there would have been different ingredients in the chicken opt. I added the street corn & guac to it & that elevated it forsure. Really cute & charming spot. Staff is incredibly kind!“

“Small DQ next to gas station and Dunkin'. Def convenient to grab after fueling up vehicle . Typically only grab DQ for the ice cream , but it was lunch time so I ordered a double cheeseburger and Oreo hot cocoa blizzard . I forgot how good their burgers are! Tastes delicious . Blizzard was rich and chocolatey. Yum!!“

“So far this summer we have tried the gummy bear flavor & loved !!! Bonus for the gummies in it, so cute! Wish there was some additional on top for a cute picture though! We also tried the sour patch mixed with lemonade which now a new favorite for me! Rita’s is such a nice summer treat to bring the kids. Can’t wait for new flavors! Bring gummy bear back lol“

“We got burgers and a blizzard for dinner and everything was excellent. The burgers actually had a slice of tomato on instead of the normal fast food burgers where finding the tiny slice can be quite challenging. Good grub, empty dining area = ultimate eating experience!“

“A good dairy queen with above average service. The food isn't as good as some other local small business ice cream shops but the service is above average and the atmosphere and location are central to a lot of other places making this an excellent place to go for ice cream!Parking: Parking is in an adjacent lot, business is on a steep hill so turning into and out of the lot can be difficult. Parking is free and plentiful though.“