13 Best Bakeries near Sutersville

“O.M.G. this place is amazing! This was our first time here, after passing it up so many times on our way to different places. The advertisement for the Peanut Butter brownie parfait on their sign near the road was all the motivation I needed to finally stop. I am so glad I did! The custard is delicious. Unlike many other frozen custard I have had. I'm more of a soft serve ice cream person so this was right up my alley! Most ice creams upset my stomach later but I'll suffer though it to have some ice cream. I'm typing this up 3 hours later, and nothing yet! Finally a frozen treat I can eat that doesn't upset my stomach! The parfait I had, had bits of brownie in it and most places that I have had a brownie in the ice cream, its stale, this was like the brownie was only a couple hours old, it was that fresh tasting. The girls there are so sweet and nice, which just puts the cherry on top of the first time experience there. I will definitely be back to try their giant gobs and to try more of their frozen treats! Make the stop, don't wait like I did, you don't know what you're missing until you do!“

“Very quiant & charming little shop, super cozy! Aesthetically pleasing atomsphere. Service was exemplary! The Cinnamon Honey Latte was the best tasting variation of that drink, I've ever tried! Too delicious! Will most definitely be back!“

“Patti's Pasticceria is a family-owned Italian-American bakery. Its menu includes breakfast pastries, cookies, cupcakes, rolls, specialty cakes (e.g., wedding, anniversary, birthday, and graduation), and even non-baked goods such as soups and espresso drinks. Prices are reasonable. For Easter, my family purchased a chocolate cake, a white cake, a strawberry pie, and lady-lock cookies from Patti's. My family members and I thought that these desserts were fresh and tasted good, but we prefer the flavors of desserts from a few other bakeries. I would feel happy to try many of Patti's other desserts, including her cinnamon rolls, pecan rolls, apple strudels, cold-dough apricot cookies, s'mores cookies, cheesecake, carrot cake, sfogliatelle, etcetera. Please note that some desserts must be ordered in advance, and catering is available.“

“I've been to this location a few times before and I've always enjoyed the staff and the quality of the cookies. I had stopped in today to take advantage of the limited time offer to get the Tres Leches cake before it would be discontinued after this week. The cake was so very good and the staff who had prepared my order today were extremely nice and attentive. I highly recommend this place to anyone.“

“First time there and it was really good. Not a fan of the slice of cake but everything else was delicious. Their rolls are sooo soft and delicious. Had a Tuesday sale of rolls and their homemade speciality butters. Got maple Pecan. Omg sooo delicious!! Also got two cannolis and two cupcakes. Only $18.70 for all we got! Such great prices! The employee we had was very sweet and definitely made us want to return. It's a very cute store and even though we showed up like 5 mins before close, she was still sweet and accommodating.“

“I am overly impressed. I can be picky with cake fillings and icings. And Sambol's went above and beyond to meet my needs. I ordered cakes for my wedding from this place because when I tried the sample cupcakes I was blown away by the taste and perfection. The moist cake and perfect density ratio impressed me, she nails it! The customer service and accommodations I got from them was great. I felt that she took her time to understand what I wanted and turn it into something beautiful. Thank you so much! I will never order a cake from anywhere else!“

“the only place to go if you want to be the guy bringing the doughnuts. The only place around that understands “a box of assorted doughnuts”. it’s unbelievable how other places complicate this but here they got it. Try the other items too it’s not just good doughnuts.“

“Cakes by Colby made what seemed like a difficult choice a super easy one! From moment one walking in the door, you could see the artistry in her work and where her specialties lay. The tasting was a delight, and if anything we ate waaaaay too much while were there, but it was all so incredibly good! Fast forward to the wedding day, everything went off without a hitch and the cake was absolutely gorgeous! She took reference images we provided and went above and beyond, it was elegant without being pretentious and truly lovely on top of being delicious as well. Our guests raved about it too. Can’t recommend Fran and Cakes by Colby enough!!“

“The best ever paska raisin bread! They use not only dark raisins but the golden raisins! Love it! Also they make a braided breakfast roll with nuts/or without and 3 different fruits. We bought the lemon/apricot/cherry. Then it's drizzled with icing! So delicious with coffee!!“

“This is really the only place in town to get "a dozen assorted donuts". Very old town timey bakery and good selection and prices and quick and easy. I don't know why it is so difficult to get a dozen doughnuts but even shop and save cant get this right so skip all that and just go to Keystone. Nice cookie assortment too for later in the day.“

“Great food . Can't pick anythig as a favorite because everything is delicious. Staff is friendly and helpful and courteous. Can't recommend enough. Try the Chicken Parmesan Sub. One of my many favorites . Also Phil is the man . Forgot the cookies and pastries are the best “

“My 1st visit. And the Cinnamon Scone was the best. We also partaked on chocolate chip cookies, salted caramel cookie, apple streudel and brownies. Kim, A. Mgr was helpful and welcoming. All the staff were nice and could help with confirming ingredients. We will be back!!“

“My daughter in law had cookies made for grand daughters 1st. She wasn't concerned with taste because she wanted them to be pretty. And they turned out so adorable and perfect. But can I tell you they were so yummy and delicious! I'm sad I didn't get a better picture. I need to mention they were a bit pricey but I'm sure that is due to the time and decorating. Perfect!“